14.1.4. Prompt NOx Formation

It is known that during combustion of hydrocarbon fuels, the formation rate can exceed that produced from direct oxidation of nitrogen molecules (that is, thermal ).

14.1.4.1. Prompt NOx Combustion Environments

The presence of a second mechanism leading to formation was first identified by Fenimore [127] and was termed “prompt ”. There is good evidence that prompt can be formed in a significant quantity in some combustion environments, such as in low-temperature, fuel-rich conditions and where residence times are short. Surface burners, staged combustion systems, and gas turbines can create such conditions [26].

At present, the prompt contribution to total from stationary combustors is small. However, as emissions are reduced to very low levels by employing new strategies (burner design or furnace geometry modification), the relative importance of the prompt can be expected to increase.

14.1.4.2. Prompt NOx Mechanism

Prompt is most prevalent in rich flames. The actual formation involves a complex series of reactions and many possible intermediate species. The route now accepted is as follows:

(14–16)

(14–17)

(14–18)

(14–19)

A number of species resulting from fuel fragmentation have been suggested as the source of prompt in hydrocarbon flames (for example, , , , ), but the major contribution is from (Equation 14–16) and , via

(14–20)

The products of these reactions could lead to formation of amines and cyano compounds that subsequently react to form by reactions similar to those occurring in oxidation of fuel nitrogen, for example:

(14–21)

14.1.4.3. Prompt NOx Formation Factors

Prompt formation is proportional to the number of carbon atoms present per unit volume and is independent of the parent hydrocarbon identity. The quantity of formed increases with the concentration of hydrocarbon radicals, which in turn increases with equivalence ratio. As the equivalence ratio increases, prompt production increases at first, then passes a peak, and finally decreases due to a deficiency in oxygen.

14.1.4.4. Primary Reaction

The reaction described by Equation 14–16 is of primary importance. In recent studies [423], comparison of probability density distributions for the location of the peak with those obtained for the peak have shown close correspondence, indicating that the majority of the at the flame base is prompt formed by the reaction. Assuming that the reaction described by Equation 14–16 controls the prompt formation rate,

(14–22)

14.1.4.5. Modeling Strategy

There are, however, uncertainties about the rate data for the above reaction. From the reactions described by Equation 14–16 – Equation 14–20, it can be concluded that the prediction of prompt formation within the flame requires coupling of the kinetics to an actual hydrocarbon combustion mechanism. Hydrocarbon combustion mechanisms involve many steps and, as mentioned previously, are extremely complex and costly to compute. In the present model, a global kinetic parameter derived by De Soete [104] is used. De Soete compared the experimental values of total formation rate with the rate of formation calculated by numerical integration of the empirical overall reaction rates of and formation. He showed that overall prompt formation rate can be predicted from the expression

(14–23)

In the early stages of the flame, where prompt is formed under fuel-rich conditions, the concentration is high and the radical almost exclusively forms rather than nitrogen. Therefore, the prompt formation rate will be approximately equal to the overall prompt formation rate:

(14–24)

For (ethylene)-air flames,

(14–25)

is 251151 , is the oxygen reaction order, is the universal gas constant, and is pressure (all in SI units). The rate of prompt formation is found to be of the first order with respect to nitrogen and fuel concentration, but the oxygen reaction order, , depends on experimental conditions.

14.1.4.6. Rate for Most Hydrocarbon Fuels

Equation 14–24 was tested against the experimental data obtained by Backmier et al.  [19] for different mixture strengths and fuel types. The predicted results indicated that the model performance declined significantly under fuel-rich conditions and for higher hydrocarbon fuels. To reduce this error and predict the prompt adequately in all conditions, the De Soete model was modified using the available experimental data. A correction factor, , was developed, which incorporates the effect of fuel type, that is, number of carbon atoms, and the air-to-fuel ratio for gaseous aliphatic hydrocarbons.   Equation 14–24 now becomes

(14–26)

so that the source term due to prompt mechanism is

(14–27)

In the above equations,

(14–28)

(14–29)

is 303474.125 , is the number of carbon atoms per molecule for the hydrocarbon fuel, and is the equivalence ratio. The correction factor is a curve fit for experimental data, valid for aliphatic alkane hydrocarbon fuels () and for equivalence ratios between 0.6 and 1.6. For values outside the range, the appropriate limit should be used. Values of and were developed at the Department of Fuel and Energy at The University of Leeds in England.

Here, the concept of equivalence ratio refers to an overall equivalence ratio for the flame, rather than any spatially varying quantity in the flow domain. In complex geometries with multiple burners this may lead to some uncertainty in the specification of . However, since the contribution of prompt to the total emission is often very small, results are not likely to be significantly biased.

14.1.4.7. Oxygen Reaction Order

Oxygen reaction order depends on flame conditions. According to De Soete [104], oxygen reaction order is uniquely related to oxygen mole fraction in the flame:

(14–30)


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.