17.7.4. Cavitation Models

A liquid at constant temperature can be subjected to a decreasing pressure, which may fall below the saturated vapor pressure. The process of rupturing the liquid by a decrease of pressure at constant temperature is called cavitation. The liquid also contains the micro-bubbles of noncondensable (dissolved or ingested) gases, or nuclei, which under decreasing pressure may grow and form cavities. In such processes, very large and steep density variations happen in the low-pressure/cavitating regions.

This section provides information about the following three cavitation models used in ANSYS Fluent.

The following assumptions are made in the standard two-phase cavitation models:

The cavitation models offer the following capabilities:

17.7.4.1. Limitations of the Cavitation Models

The following limitations apply to the cavitation models in ANSYS Fluent:

  • They can only be used for a single cavitation process. In other words, only a single liquid fluid is subjected to cavitation. Note that this liquid can be a phase or a species in a mixture phase. ANSYS Fluent cannot simulate multiple cavitation processes.

  • The Singhal et al. model requires the primary phase to be a liquid and the secondary phase to be a vapor. This model is only compatible with the multiphase mixture model.

  • The Singhal et al. model cannot be used with the Eulerian multiphase model.

  • The Singhal et al. model is not compatible with the LES turbulence model.

  • The Zwart-Gerber-Belamri and Schnerr and Sauer models do not take the effect of noncondensable gases into account by default.

17.7.4.1.1. Limitations of Cavitation with the VOF Model
  1. Explicit VOF with cavitation is not recommended for the following reasons:

    • Explicit VOF is solved once per time step, therefore the mass transfer rate (which is a function of solution variables such as pressure, temperature, and volume fraction) is only evaluated once per time step. This may not give results that are consistent with those achieved using the implicit formulation. It is recommended that the volume fraction be solved every iteration, which can be enabled through the expert options in the Multiphase dialog box.

    • Explicit VOF may not be stable with sharpening schemes such as Geo-Reconstruct and CICSAM. You should use either a Sharp/Dispersed or Dispersed interface modeling option, which provide diffusive interface-capturing discretization schemes for volume fraction, such as QUICK, HRIC, and Compressive.

    • Explicit VOF does not model any cavitation-specific numerical treatments for added stability.

  2. When using the implicit VOF formulation, numerical diffusion caused by turbulent effects is added by default. This added diffusion increases the solution stability, but has adverse effects on the interfacial accuracy. If interfacial sharpness is an area of concern, you can disable the diffusion by setting the rpvar (rpsetvar 'mp/turbulence-effect? #f).

17.7.4.2. Vapor Transport Equation

With the multiphase cavitation modeling approach, a basic two-phase cavitation model consists of using the standard viscous flow equations governing the transport of mixture (Mixture model) or phases (Eulerian multiphase), and a conventional turbulence model (k- model). In cavitation, the liquid-vapor mass transfer (evaporation and condensation) is governed by the vapor transport equation:

(17–473)

where

= vapor phase

= vapor volume fraction

= vapor density

 

= vapor phase velocity

 

, = mass transfer source terms connected to the growth and collapse of the vapor bubbles respectively

In Equation 17–473, the terms and account for the mass transfer between the liquid and vapor phases in cavitation. In ANSYS Fluent, they are modeled based on the Rayleigh-Plesset equation describing the growth of a single vapor bubble in a liquid.

17.7.4.3. Bubble Dynamics Consideration

In most engineering situations we assume that there are plenty of nuclei for the inception of cavitation. Therefore, our primary focus is on proper accounting of bubble growth and collapse. In a flowing liquid with zero velocity slip between the fluid and bubbles, the bubble dynamics equation can be derived from the generalized Rayleigh-Plesset equation as [57]

(17–474)

where, 
 

= bubble radius

 

= liquid surface tension coefficient

 

= liquid density

  = liquid kinematic viscosity
 

= bubble surface pressure

 

= local far-field pressure

Neglecting the second-order terms and the surface tension force, Equation 17–474 is simplified to

(17–475)

This equation provides a physical approach to introduce the effects of bubble dynamics into the cavitation model. It can also be considered to be an equation for void propagation and, hence, mixture density.

17.7.4.4. Singhal et al. Model

This cavitation model is based on the “full cavitation model”, developed by Singhal et al. [441]. It accounts for all first-order effects (that is, phase change, bubble dynamics, turbulent pressure fluctuations, and noncondensable gases). It has the capability to account for multiphase (N-phase) flows or flows with multiphase species transport, the effects of slip velocities between the liquid and gaseous phases, and the thermal effects and compressibility of both liquid and gas phases. The cavitation model can be used with the mixture multiphase model, with or without slip velocities. However, it is always preferable to solve for cavitation using the mixture model without slip velocity; slip velocities can be turned on if the problem suggests that there is significant slip between phases.

To derive an expression of the net phase change rate, Singhal et al. [441] uses the following two-phase continuity equations:

Liquid phase:

(17–476)

Vapor phase:

(17–477)

Mixture:

(17–478)

where, 
 

= liquid phase

 

= mixture density (function of phase volume fraction and density)

Mixture density is defined as

(17–479)

Combining Equation 17–476, Equation 17–477, and Equation 17–478 yields a relationship between the mixture density and vapor volume fraction ():

(17–480)

The vapor volume fraction () can be related to the bubble number density () and the radius of bubble () as

(17–481)

Substituting Equation 17–481 into Equation 17–480 gives the following:

(17–482)

Using the Equation 17–475, and combining Equation 17–476, Equation 17–477, Equation 17–480, and Equation 17–482, the expression for the net phase change rate () is finally obtained as

(17–483)

Here represents the vapor generation or evaporation rate, that is, the source term in Equation 17–473. All terms, except , are either known constants or dependent variables. In the absence of a general model for estimation of the bubble number density, the phase change rate expression is rewritten in terms of bubble radius (), as follows:

(17–484)

Equation 17–484 indicates that the unit volume mass transfer rate is not only related to the vapor density (), but the function of the liquid density (), and the mixture density () as well. Since Equation 17–484 is derived directly from phase volume fraction equations, it is exact and should accurately represent the mass transfer from liquid to vapor phase in cavitation (bubble growth or evaporation). Though the calculation of mass transfer for bubble collapse or condensation is expected to be different from that of bubble growth, Equation 17–484 is often used as a first approximation to model the bubble collapse. In this case, the right side of the equation is modified by using the absolute value of the pressure difference and is treated as a sink term.

It may be noted that in practical cavitation models, the local far-field pressure is usually taken to be the same as the cell center pressure. The bubble pressure is equal to the saturation vapor pressure in the absence of dissolved gases, mass transport and viscous damping, that is, .

where, 

= bubble pressure

= saturation vapor pressure

Based on Equation 17–484, Singhal et al. [551] proposed a model where the vapor mass fraction is the dependent variable in the transport equation. This model accommodates also a single phase formulation where the governing equations is given by:

(17–485)

where, 

= vapor mass fraction

= noncondensable gases

= diffusion coefficient

The rates of mass exchange are given by the following equations:

If

(17–486)

If

(17–487)

The saturation pressure is corrected by an estimation of the local values of the turbulent pressure fluctuations:

(17–488)

The constants have the values and . In this model, the liquid-vapor mixture is assumed to be compressible. Also, the effects of turbulence and the noncondensable gases have been taken into account.

17.7.4.5. Zwart-Gerber-Belamri Model

Assuming that all the bubbles in a system have the same size, Zwart-Gerber-Belamri [552] proposed that the total interphase mass transfer rate per unit volume () is calculated using the bubble number densities (), and the mass change rate of a single bubble:

(17–489)

Substituting the value of in Equation 17–489 into Equation 17–481, we have the expression of the net mass transfer:

(17–490)

Comparing Equation 17–490 and Equation 17–484, you will notice that the difference is only in the density terms in the mass transfer rate. In Equation 17–490, the unit volume mass transfer rate is only related to the vapor phase density (). Unlike Equation 17–484, has no relation with the liquid phase and mixture densities in this model.

As in Equation 17–484, Equation 17–490 is derived assuming bubble growth (evaporation). To apply it to the bubble collapse process (condensation), the following generalized formulation is used:

(17–491)

where is an empirical calibration coefficient. Though it is originally derived from evaporation, Equation 17–491 only works well for condensation. It is physically incorrect and numerically unstable if applied to evaporation. The fundamental reason is that one of the key assumptions is that the cavitation bubble does not interact with each other. This is plausible only during the earliest stage of cavitation when the cavitation bubble grows from the nucleation site. As the vapor volume fraction increases, the nucleation site density must decrease accordingly. To model this process, Zwart-Gerber-Belamri proposed to replace with in Equation 17–491. Then the final form of this cavitation model is as follows:

If

(17–492)

If

(17–493)

where, 

= bubble radius = 10–6m

= nucleation site volume fraction =

= evaporation coefficient =

= condensation coefficient =

17.7.4.6. Schnerr and Sauer Model

As in the Singhal et al. model, Schnerr and Sauer [429] follow a similar approach to derive the exact expression for the net mass transfer from liquid to vapor. The equation for the vapor volume fraction has the general form:

(17–494)

Here, the net mass source term is as follows:

(17–495)

Unlike Zwart-Gerber-Belamri and Singhal et al., Schnerr and Sauer use the following expression to connect the vapor volume fraction to the number of bubbles per volume of liquid:

(17–496)

Following a similar approach to Singhal et al., they derived the following equation:

(17–497)

(17–498)

where, 

= mass transfer rate

= bubble radius

Comparing Equation 17–497 with Equation 17–484 and Equation 17–490, it is obvious that unlike the two previous models, the mass transfer rate in the Schnerr and Sauer model is proportional to . Moreover, the function has the interesting property that it approaches zero when and , and reaches the maximum in between. Also in this model, the only parameter that must be determined is the number of spherical bubbles per volume of liquid. If you assume that no bubbles are created or destroyed, the bubble number density would be constant. The initial conditions for the nucleation site volume fraction and the equilibrium bubble radius would therefore be sufficient to specify the bubble number density () from Equation 17–496 and then the phase transition by Equation 17–497.

As in the two other models, Equation 17–497 is also used to model the condensation process. The final form of the model is as follows:

When ,

(17–499)

When ,

(17–500)

where and are the empirical calibration coefficients of evaporation and condensation, respectively. They are similar to the coefficients in the Zwart-Gerber-Belamri model (see Zwart-Gerber-Belamri Model). The default value of 0.2 for is recommended. You can change it using the expert text command option as described in Mass Transfer Mechanisms in the Fluent User's Guide.

17.7.4.7. Turbulence Factor

For the Schnerr-Sauer and Zwart-Gerber-Belamri models, the influence of turbulence on the threshold pressure can optionally be included. This is modeled in a similar way to that in Singhal et al. Model. The threshold pressure is calculated from:

(17–501)

where and are the liquid phase density and turbulence kinetic energy, respectively. The recommended value for is 0.39 and this value is used by default.

17.7.4.8. Additional Guidelines for the Cavitation Models

In practical applications of a cavitation model, several factors greatly influence numerical stability. For instance, the high pressure difference between the inlet and exit, large ratio of liquid to vapor density, and large phase change rates between the liquid and vapor all have unfavorable effects on solution convergence. In addition, poor initial conditions very often lead to an unrealistic pressure field and unexpected cavitating zones, which, once present, are usually difficult to correct. You may consider the following factors/tips when choosing a cavitation model and addressing potential numerical problems:

  • Choice of the cavitation models

    In ANSYS Fluent, there are three available cavitation models. The Zwart-Gerber-Belamri and the Schnerr and Sauer models have been implemented following an entirely different numerical procedure from the Singhal et al. model developed in ANSYS Fluent 6.1. Numerically, these two models are robust and converge quickly. It is therefore highly recommended that you should use the Schnerr and Sauer or the Zwart-Gerber-Bleamri model. The Singhal et al. model, though physically similar to the other two, is numerically less stable and more difficult to use.

  • Choice of the solvers

    In ANSYS Fluent, both the segregated (SIMPLE, SIMPLEC, and PISO) and coupled pressure-based solvers can be used in cavitation. As usual, the coupled solver is generally more robust and converges faster, particularly for cavitating flows in rotating machinery (liquid pumps, inducers, impellers, etc). For fuel injector applications, however, the segregated solver also performs very well with the Schnerr and Sauer and the Zwart-Gerber-Belamri models.

    As for the Singhal et al. model, since the coupled solver does not show any significant advantages, it is suggested that the segregated solver is used.

  • Initial conditions

    Though no special initial condition settings are required, we suggest that the vapor fraction is always set to inlet values. The pressure is set close to the highest pressure among the inlets and outlets to avoid unexpected low pressure and cavitating spots. In general, the Schnerr and Sauer and Zwart-Gerber-Belamri models are robust enough so that there is no need for specific initial conditions. But in some very complicated cases, it may be beneficial to obtain a realistic pressure field before substantial cavities are formed. This can be achieved by obtaining a converged/near-converged solution for a single phase liquid flow, and then enabling the cavitation model. Again, the Singhal et al.model is much more sensitive to initial conditions. The above mentioned treatments are generally required.

  • Pressure discretization schemes

    As for general multiphase flows, it is more desirable to use the following pressure discretization schemes in cavitation applications in this order:

    • PRESTO!

    • body force weighted

    • second order

    The standard and linear schemes generally are not very effective in complex cavitating flows and you should avoid using them.

  • Relaxation factors

    • Schnerr and Sauer and Zwart-Gerber-Belamri models

      The default settings generally work well. To achieve numerical efficiency, however, the following values may be recommended:

      • The relaxation factor for vapor is 0.5 or higher unless the solution diverges or all the residuals oscillate excessively.

      • The density and the vaporization mass can be relaxed, but in general set them to 1.

      • For the segregated solver, the relaxation factor for pressure should be no less than the value for the momentum equations.

      • For the coupled solver, the default value for the Courant number (200) may need to be reduced to 20-50 in some complex 3D cases.

    • Singhal et al. model

      In general, small relaxation factors are recommended for momentum equations, usually between 0.05 – 0.4. The relaxation factor for the pressure-correction equation should generally be larger than those for momentum equations, say in the range of 0.2 – 0.7. The density and the vaporization mass (source term in the vapor equation) can also be relaxed to improve convergence. Typically, the relaxation factor for density is set between the values of 0.3 and 1.0, while for the vaporization mass, values between 0.1 and 1.0 may be appropriate. For some extreme cases, even smaller relaxation factors may be required for all the equations.

  • Special tips for the Singhal et al. model

    • Noncondensable gases

      Noncondensable gases are usually present in liquids. Even a small amount (for example, 15 ppm) of noncondensable gases can have significant effects on both the physical results and the convergence characteristics of the solution. A value of zero for the mass fraction of noncondensable gases should generally be avoided. In some cases, if the liquid is purified of noncondensable gases, a much smaller value (for example, ) may be used to replace the default value of 1.5 . In fact, higher mass fractions of the noncondensable gases may in many cases enhance numerical stability and lead to more realistic results. In particular, when the saturation pressure of a liquid at a certain temperature is zero or very small, noncondensable gases will play a crucial role both numerically and physically.

    • Limits for dependent variables

      In many cases, setting the pressure upper limit to a reasonable value can help convergence greatly at the early stage of the solution. It is advisable to always limit the maximum pressure when possible. ANSYS Fluent’s default value for the maximum vapor pressure limit is five times the local vapor pressure with consideration of the turbulence and thermal effects. You can change the vapor pressure ratio (which is the ratio of the maximum vapor pressure limit to the local pressure) using the expert text command option as described in Mass Transfer Mechanisms in the Fluent User's Guide.

    • Relaxation factor for the pressure correction equation

      For cavitating flows, a special relaxation factor is introduced for the pressure correction equation. By default, this factor is set to 0.7, which should work well for most of the cases. For some very complicated cases, however, you may experience the divergence of the AMG solver. Under those circumstances, this value may be reduced to no less than 0.4. You can set the value of this relaxation factor by typing a text command. For more information, contact your ANSYS Fluent support engineer.

17.7.4.9. Extended Cavitation Model Capabilities

When cavitation occurs, in many practical applications other gaseous species exist in the systems. For instance, in a ventilated supercavitating vehicle, air is injected into a liquid to stabilize or increase the cavitation along the vehicle surfaces. In some cases, the incoming flow is a mixture of a liquid and some gaseous species. To predict those types of cavitating flows, the basic two-phase cavitation model must be extended to a multiphase (N-phase) flow, or a multiphase species transport cavitation model.

17.7.4.9.1. Multiphase Cavitation Models

The multiphase cavitation models are the extensions of the three basic two-phase cavitation models to multiphase flows. In addition to the primary liquid and secondary vapor phase, more secondary gaseous phases can be included into the computational system under the following assumptions:

  • Mass transfer (cavitation) only occurs between the liquid and vapor phase.

  • The basic two-phase cavitation models are still used to model the phase changes between the liquid and vapor.

  • Only one secondary phase can be defined as compressible gas phase, while a user-defined density may be applied to all the phases.

  • In the Singhal et al. model, the predescribed noncondensable gases can be included in the system. To exclude noncondensable gases from the system, the mass fraction must be set to 0, and the noncondensable gas must be modeled by a separate compressible gas phase.

  • For non-cavitating phase (), the general transport equation governing the vapor phase is the volume fraction equation in the Zwart-Gerber-Belamri and Schnerr and Sauer models, while in the Singhal et al. model, a mass transfer equation is solved and the vapor must be the second phase.

17.7.4.9.2. Multiphase Species Transport Cavitation Model

In some cases, there are several gas phase components in a system that can be considered compressible. Since only one compressible gas phase is allowed in the general multiphase approach, the multiphase species transport approach offers an option to handle these types of applications by assuming that there is one compressible gas phase with multiple species.

The detailed description of the multiphase species transport approach can be found in Modeling Species Transport in Multiphase Flows. The multiphase species transport cavitation model can be summarized as follows:

  • All the assumptions/limitations for the multiphase cavitation model apply here.

  • The primary phase can only be a single-species liquid.

  • All the secondary phases allow more than one species.

  • The mass transfer between a liquid and a vapor phase/species is modeled by the basic cavitation models.

  • The mass transfer between other phases or species are modeled with the standard mass transfer approach. In the standard model, zero constant rates should be chosen.

  • For the phases with multiple species, the phase shares the same pressure as the other phases, but each species has its own pressure (that is, partial pressure). As a result, the vapor density and the pressure used in Equation 17–487 are the partial density and pressure of the vapor.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.