35.1.5. Adjoint Solver Stabilization

When applied to problems with large cell counts and complex geometry, adjoint solvers sometimes experience stability issues. These instabilities can be associated with small scale unsteadiness in the flow field and/or strong shear, and tend to be restricted to small and isolated regions of the flow domain. Despite the spatial localization of these instabilities, the linearity of the adjoint problem provides no intrinsic limit on their growth during solution advancement. Their presence, if not handled, can disrupt the entire adjoint calculation despite the problem occurring in sometimes just a few cells. A stabilized solution scheme will be required to obtain adjoint solutions for problems at high Reynolds number in which there is strong shear and/or complex geometry.

Three stabilization schemes are available in Fluent in order to overcome these stability difficulties when larger cases are being solved. The stabilization schemes are designed to intervene only when the standard advancement scheme is experiencing instability.

Spatial scheme

The spatial scheme operates by identifying parts of the domain where unstable growth is occurring and applying a more direct and stable solution procedure in those regions.

Modal scheme

The modal scheme involves a process of identifying the particular details of the unstable growth patterns or modes. These patterns are localized in space and they are used to split the solution into parts that have stable and unstable characteristics when advanced. The stable part is advanced as usual, while the algorithm is designed now to compensate for the unstable part so that the overall calculation is stabilized.

The emergence of the unstable patterns can happen at any time during the adjoint calculation and the total number of unstable patterns is case-dependent. Having 10 to 20 unstable modes present would not be considered unusual. Large cases may have many more. As a general trend, the most rapidly-growing unstable patterns appear often within a few iterations with more slowly-growing modes appearing later in the calculation. The unstable patterns are handled as they appear.

Dissipation scheme

The dissipation scheme provides stabilization for the solution advancement of the adjoint solution by introducing nonlinear damping strategically into the calculation domain. The strategy is intended to provide minimal intervention in order to damp the growth of instabilities that lead to adjoint solution divergence. A marker is tracked, based on the state of the adjoint solution, and damping is applied directly to the adjoint solution in regions where the marker becomes large.

Unlike the modal and spatial schemes, the dissipation scheme can affect the adjoint solution slightly. In general, the spatial order of the damping is chosen to be one order larger than the adjoint calculation order. This means that the formal order of accuracy of the adjoint solver is unaffected by the addition of the dissipation scheme. In practice, regions of intense dissipation can appear for some cases which may result in isolated spots and/or streaks in the solution on surfaces. However, the scale of these solution features is such that they are often easily smoothed during postprocessing to generate design changes.

Some additional computational overhead is associated with the stabilization schemes. In general, the dissipation scheme is the least resource-intensive of the three schemes.

For information about using the stabilization schemes, refer to Stabilized Scheme Settings.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.