11.2.5. Model Hierarchy

As discussed, turbulence modeling is a balance between accuracy and cost. The recommendation is to use RANS models as much as possible and as long as they provide the accuracy required for the simulation. RANS models will remain the workhorse of turbulence modeling for many years to come. Within the RANS family, eddy-viscosity models are typically sufficient for most engineering flow simulations. The application of RSM is only recommended for flows that are known to systematically benefit from their usage and justify the increase in computing power.

In cases where steady RANS or URANS models cannot provide the accuracy or unsteady information required, it is recommended that you switch to the SAS approach. It is relatively forgiving in terms of the grid resolution and will not deteriorate the results in case of insufficient resolution in the unsteady zone. The SAS model will only provide scale-resolution if a strong flow instability is present. Visual inspection (using isosurfaces of the Q criterion) will quickly allow a judgment if the model provides sufficient unsteadiness and resolution relative to the grid spacing. In such cases, the internal interface option of the ELES implementation can be applied to convert modeled turbulence into resolved turbulence (see Internal Interface Without LES Zone in the Theory Guide).

DDES (DES is not recommended) models can allow the formation of unsteadiness even for cases where SAS remains stable. DDES does require a more carefully crafted grid in the LES zone due to the DES grid influence on the RANS solution. For the DES-BSL / SST model, use the default DDES blending function for shielding.

SDES and SBES have an improved shielding function compared to DDES / IDDES. They provide strong shielding of the RANS boundary layer and demonstrate a fast “transition” between RANS and LES in separating shear layers. The SBES model formulation in combination with the WALE LES model is recommended over older models like DES, DDES, and IDDES.

ELES is recommended in cases where limited zones with high accuracy requirements are embedded inside a larger RANS zone. At the interface between the RANS and the LES zone, unsteady turbulence is generated either by the Vortex Method or the Spectral Synthesizer. For wall bounded flows, the ELES method requires a very fine near wall resolution in the LES zone.

Pure LES should only be applied to free shear flows (for example, combustion chambers without wall influence) or to very limited domains using meshes with fine LES near wall resolution. It is important to be aware of the strong increase of grid resolution requirements with Reynolds number for wall bounded flows. For wall boundary layers at higher Reynolds numbers, the IDDES model can be run in WMLES mode – meaning with specified unsteady inlet conditions.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.