3.1. Mesh Nonlinear Adaptivity Benefits

These example problems highlight the benefits of mesh nonlinear adaptivity:

3.1.1. Example: Rubber Seal Simulation

To demonstrate the benefits of mesh nonlinear adaptivity, consider a rubber seal simulation, with an initial geometry and mesh as shown in the following figure:

Figure 3.1:  Rubber Seal with Coarse Mesh

Rubber Seal with Coarse Mesh

Downward displacement is applied to the rigid surface on the top of the seal. The following figure shows the program output for the deformed seal:

Figure 3.2:  Deformed Rubber Seal with Coarse Mesh

Deformed Rubber Seal with Coarse Mesh

The shape of the deformed material in the gap is not realistic because the mesh is too coarse. To create a more accurate simulation, nonlinear adaptivity with position-based criteria is used to refine the mesh of the elements which will fill the gap. Two mesh refinements are performed automatically during the solution to create a more detailed mesh in the model. The following figure shows the first mesh refinement:

Figure 3.3:  Rubber Seal Model with Initial Mesh Refinement

Rubber Seal Model with Initial Mesh Refinement

The following figure shows the second refinement of the part of the rubber seal model that will fill the gap:

Figure 3.4:  Rubber Seal Model with Second Mesh Refinement

Rubber Seal Model with Second Mesh Refinement

When the full load is applied in the simulation, the program outputs the following deformed seal:

Figure 3.5:  Deformed Rubber Seal with Mesh Refinements

Deformed Rubber Seal with Mesh Refinements

With nonlinear adaptivity, the accuracy of the simulation of this type of rubber seal problem is greatly increased.

See Example Input: Rubber Seal Simulation for the input file.

3.1.2. Example: Crack Simulation

Another example of the increased accuracy achieved with mesh nonlinear adaptivity involves mesh refinements in regions with high stress concentrations. For example, consider this material cracking model:

Figure 3.6:  Crack Simulation Model with Coarse Mesh

Crack Simulation Model with Coarse Mesh

The following figure shows the program output for the crack simulation:

Figure 3.7:  Crack Simulation Solution with Coarse Mesh

Crack Simulation Solution with Coarse Mesh

The solution and solution time are:

σx σy τxy σ_VM Elapsed Time
21411391103.291641.224460612.00

For a more accurate solution at the crack tip, nonlinear adaptivity is applied using energy-based criteria. When three refinements are applied during solution, the program outputs the following:

Figure 3.8:  Crack Simulation Solution with Three Mesh Refinements

Crack Simulation Solution with Three Mesh Refinements

The solution and solution time are:

σx σy τxy σ_VM Elapsed Time
26271329181616447136141364

If the same simulation is performed with a fine mesh and no mesh nonlinear adaptivity, the program outputs the following:

Figure 3.9:  Crack Simulation Solution with Fine Mesh and No Mesh Nonlinear Adaptivity

Crack Simulation Solution with Fine Mesh and No Mesh Nonlinear Adaptivity

The solution and solution time are:

σx σy τxy σ_VM Elapsed Time
293992274278160033365929190

As demonstrated, nonlinear adaptivity provides sufficient accuracy, yet with drastically reduced simulation time.

See Example Input: Crack Simulation for the input file.

3.1.3. Example: 3-D Metal Forging Simulation

This example problem demonstrates how to apply mesh nonlinear adaptivity to remove mesh distortion and solve problems associated with high deformation. Unlike the two prior problems, general remeshing is necessary with the mesh-quality-based criterion applied in this problem.

Consider a metal forging simulation, with an initial geometry and mesh, as shown in this figure:

Figure 3.10:  Metal Block Ready to Be Forged Showing Initial Mesh

Metal Block Ready to Be Forged Showing Initial Mesh

The flexible block has symmetry boundary conditions on three facets. A rigid die is placed on the top of the block with applied displacement in the Y direction. It is intended to compress the block to 80 percent. Without nonlinear adaptivity, the simulation cannot converge because of high mesh distortion, as shown in this figure:

Figure 3.11:  View of Block on X-Y Plane After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

View of Block on X-Y Plane After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

The solution diverges at approximately 40 percent load with the following error:

Nonlinear adaptivity with a mesh-quality-based criterion corrects the mesh shape caused by high distortion. To check the mesh quality at every substep, skewness is set to 0.9 (NLADAPTIVE,,,MESH,SKEWNESS,0.9). With several remeshings, the full load is successfully applied, as shown with deformation in this figure:

Figure 3.12:  Final Solution After Converging Using Nonlinear Adaptivity

Final Solution After Converging Using Nonlinear Adaptivity

See Example Input: 3-D Metal Forging Simulation for the input file.

3.1.4. Example: 2-D Metal Extrusion Simulation

This example problem demonstrates the benefits of mesh nonlinear adaptivity for simulating cases with very high deformation. This 2-D problem uses a generalized plane strain extrusion model.

The flexible block of height = 19.5 in this figure will be compressed on the right side by a rigid die (where applied displacements = 30) to reduce its height to 6.5:

Figure 3.13:  Metal Block Ready to Be Extruded Showing Initial Mesh

Metal Block Ready to Be Extruded Showing Initial Mesh

The bottom of the block has a symmetric boundary condition, the die is a frictionless rigid, and the material is elasto-plastic.

Without nonlinear adaptivity, the solution diverges at approximately 80 percent load due to mesh distortion, generating the following error message:

Figure 3.14:  Deformed Shape of Metal Block After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

Deformed Shape of Metal Block After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

Nonlinear adaptivity with a mesh-quality-based criterion corrects a highly deformed mesh shape. To check the mesh quality at every substep, the maximum corner angle of the mesh shape is set to 155 (NLADAPTIVE,,,MESH,SHAPE,155). With several remeshings (depending on the platform), the full load is successfully applied, as shown with deformation in this figure:

Figure 3.15:  Shape of Metal Block After Converging (Using Nonlinear Adaptivity)

Shape of Metal Block After Converging (Using Nonlinear Adaptivity)

See Example Input: 2-D Metal Extrusion Simulation for the input file.

3.1.5. Compression of 2-D Thermo-hyperelastic U-Shape Simulation

This example problem using mesh nonlinear adaptivity simulates high mesh-deformation with coupled structural-thermal degrees of freedom. The analysis uses the 2-D coupled-field element PLANE222 with structural-thermal coupling and plane strain options.

A U-shape workpiece is compressed between two rigid and frictionless target surfaces. The top target surface is displaced in the negative y direction to compress the workpiece to reach a state of complete self-contact. A temperature difference is applied on the top and bottom surfaces. Temperature-dependent thermal material properties are defined in the model.

Figure 3.16:  Initial Geometry of a 2-D U-Shape Model

Initial Geometry of a 2-D U-Shape Model

Figure 3.17:  Deformed U-Shape After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

Deformed U-Shape After Diverging (No Nonlinear Adaptivity)

Without nonlinear adaptivity, the highly deformed mesh shape leads to a diverged solution. A mesh-quality-based criterion defined by nonlinear adaptivity measures the mesh quality and verifies a maximum corner angle of 150 degrees (NLADAPTIVE,ADD,,MESH,SHAPE,150) at every substep. With refined meshing, the solution can converge with the total displacement load applied.

The following figures shows the results for the converged solution:

Figure 3.18:  Equivalent Stress for Deformed U-Shape with Nonlinear Adaptivity

Equivalent Stress for Deformed U-Shape with Nonlinear Adaptivity

Figure 3.19:  Temperature for Deformed U-Shape with Nonlinear Adaptivity

Temperature for Deformed U-Shape with Nonlinear Adaptivity

See Example Input: Compression of 2-D Thermo-hyperelastic U-Shape Simulation for the input file.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.