1.2. Comparison of Pair-Based Contact and General Contact

In a pair-based contact definition, the contact interaction is defined between a contact surface consisting of contact elements (CONTA171 through CONTA177) and a target surface consisting of target elements (TARGE169, TARGE170). Contact elements and target elements from these two surfaces are assigned the same real constant set ID number, which must be greater than zero. The program looks for contact interaction only between surfaces with the same real constant set ID. The material ID of the contact elements is used to specify interaction properties (such as friction coefficient) via MP or TB commands.

In a general contact definition, general contact surfaces are defined. The contact elements (CONTA171, CONTA172, CONTA173, CONTA174) are overlaid on the exterior surfaces of deformable bodies, and the target elements (TARGE169, TARGE170) are used to cover standalone rigid bodies. The 3-D line contact elements (CONTA177) are overlaid on 3-D beams and on feature edges of 3-D deformable bodies and/or perimeter edges of shell structures. The contact vertex elements (CONTA175) are overlaid on convex corners of 2-D or 3-D solid bodies and/or shell structures and on endpoints of beam structures. A zero real constant ID and a zero material ID are assigned to the contact and target elements. However, different section IDs and contact/target element type IDs are assigned to different general contact surfaces. In other words, each surface consists of contact or target elements that have a unique section ID. The program looks for contact interaction among all surfaces, including self-contact (contact within a surface).

The table below compares characteristics of pair-based contact and general contact definitions.

Contact CharacteristicPair-Based Contact Definition General Contact Definition

Contact Element Real Constant ID

Real ID > 0 for contact pair identification

Real ID = 0 for general contact identification

Contact Element Section ID

Arbitrary Section ID, used as-needed for geometry corrections;

SECTYPE/SECDATA required

Unique Section ID for each general contact surface (for surface identification);

SECTYPE/SECDATA may not be needed

Contact Element Material ID

Used for interaction definition;

Mat ID > 0 assigned as an element attribute

Mat ID = 0 (not used by contact element)

Target Element

Real ID > 0 for contact pair identification;

Rigid or deformable surface

Real ID = 0 (not used by target element);

Unique Section ID > 0 for each rigid surface

Interactions and Contact Controls

Based on Mat ID and Real ID of contact element

Defined via GCDEF command between two general contact surfaces (identified by Section IDs).

The material ID and real constant ID supplied on the GCDEF command identify properties associated with the interaction but are not assigned directly as element attributes.

Asymmetric Contact Selection

KEYOPT(8)

GCDEF,OPTION

Interface Behaviors and Treatment

KEYOPT(12)

KEYOPT(9)

TB,INTER,,,TBOP

TBDATA,,C1

Contact/Target Radii

Real constants R1, R2

SECTYPE,,CONTACT,RADIUS

SECDATA,R1,R2

Contact Search

Within each pair

Among all general contact surfaces

Contact Surface Generation Tool

ESURF command

GCGEN command

General contact and pair-based contact definitions can coexist in a finite element model. For example, you may choose to use pair-based contact to model contact interactions involving cohesive debonding behavior, but model other contact interactions with a general contact definition.

If both pair-based contact and general contact are defined in a model, the pair-based contact definitions are always preserved, and the general contact definition automatically excludes overlapping interactions wherever pair-based contact exists.

The pair-based contact definition is usually more efficient and robust than the general contact definition. Some contact capabilities are not available with the general contact definition (see Features Not Supported by General Contact).

Following are advantages of general contact over pair-based contact:

1.2.1. Choosing Between Pair-Based Contact and General Contact

Most contact models can employ either the pair-based contact method or the general contact method. It is up to you do decide which contact method suits your purposes. The main difference between the two methods is in the input syntaxes. However, both definitions share the same contact algorithms.

Pair-based contact usually provides a more efficient and robust solution compared to the general contact definition. General contact offers a highly-automated contact definition procedure with limited user intervention. Therefore, the choice is a trade-off between ease of defining contact and solution robustness and performance.

General contact is mainly useful for models in which determining contact pairs between many parts is difficult or even impossible. However, if the identification of all potential contact interfaces is obvious, using contact pairs is recommended.

1.2.2. Difference in Default Settings

Notable differences in default element settings (key options) between pair-based contact and general contact are listed below. The general contact defaults apply when the GCGEN command is used to create the general contact elements.

Control ParameterPair-Based Contact DefaultGeneral Contact Default
Degree of freedom selection:

KEYOPT(1)

User-specifiedAutomatic based on the underlying elements
Contact algorithm:

KEYOPT(2)

Augmented Lagrange methodPenalty method
Asymetric contact selection:

KEYOPT(8)

No automatic pairing by defaultAutomatic assignment of contact/target pairing for any two surfaces coming into contact
Effect if initial penetration/gap

KEYOPT(9)

Included (controlled by KEYOPT(9))Excluded (controlled by TBDATA,,,C1 in conjunction with TB,INTER)
Beam/shell thickness effect:

KEYOPT(11)

ExcludedAutomatically included

For more information on default element key options for pair-based and general contact, see Defining Non-Default Contact Settings.

1.2.3. Features Not Supported by General Contact

The following contact features are not available in a general contact definition:

  • Debonding and cohesive contact behavior (TB,CZM)

  • Contact surface wear (TB,WEAR)

  • Impact constraints (KEYOPY(7) = 4)

  • Brake squeal analysis (CMROTATE)

  • Fluid pressure penetration loading (SFE,,,PRES).

  • 3-D thermal contact involving TBOT and TTOP degrees of freedom (KEYOPT(13))

  • Rezoning

  • Contact modeling for general axisymmetric solids and superelements

In addition, the Contact Wizard and the Contact Manager do not support general contact.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.