Chapter 16: Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian Formulation

The Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (ALE) element formulation is a standard numerical approach for solving large strain deformation problems encountered in metal forming and high-speed impact applications. The general concept of the ALE formulation is that an arbitrary referential domain is defined for the description of motion that is different from the material (Lagrangian) and spatial (Eulerian) domains.

In a pure Lagrangian system, the mesh deforms with the material being modeled so that there is no material flow between elements. The Lagrangian approach is well suited for moderately large strain problems where mesh distortion and element entanglement are not a significant problem. The advantage of the Lagrangian approach is that the free surface of the material is automatically captured by the mesh. The main disadvantage of the Lagrangian approach is that problems develop in physical situations that involve highly deformed surfaces. Consider the high speed impact problem of a metal bar shown in Figure 16.1: High Speed Impact of a Metal Bar. As shown in Figure 16.2: Lagrangian Impact Solution, the Lagrangian approach begins to break down along the impact surface between the metal and the rigid wall. The mesh in this region becomes highly distorted and will not yield accurate results. The best solution for increasing the accuracy of the Lagrangian approach in highly deformed regions is to use an adaptive meshing procedure. Adaptive procedures, however, are computationally expensive and are still not fully developed in three dimensional problems. Other disadvantages of the Lagrangian approach are that only one material can be modeled in each element and that new (damaged) surfaces cannot be created.

Figure 16.1:  High Speed Impact of a Metal Bar

High Speed Impact of a Metal Bar

Figure 16.2:  Lagrangian Impact Solution

Lagrangian Impact Solution

In an Eulerian based formulation, the mesh is stationary and the material flows through the mesh. The Eulerian approach originated in the fluid dynamics field and is best suited for very large deformation flow problems, such as the channel flow depicted in Figure 16.3: Eulerian Channel Flow Solution. In the Eulerian method, new (damaged) surfaces are automatically created. The greatest disadvantage of the Eulerian approach is that a fine mesh is required to capture the material response, making the method very computationally expensive. This is particularly true for problems that contain regions where the structural response is desired and the strains are relatively small.

Figure 16.3:  Eulerian Channel Flow Solution

Eulerian Channel Flow Solution

The Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (ALE) approach is a very effective alternative for simulating large deformation problems. In its most basic sense, the ALE method defines that the mesh motion is independent of the motion of the material being analyzed. Although the mesh motion may be arbitrary, it typically deforms with the material in 'near Lagrangian' flow fields. The greatest advantage of the ALE method is that it allows smoothing of a distorted mesh without performing a complete remesh. This smoothing allows the free surface of the material to be followed automatically without encountering the distortional errors of the Lagrangian approach (see Figure 16.4: ALE Impact Solution).

The main difficulty of the ALE method is the path dependent behavior of the plastic flow being modeled. Due to the path dependence, the relative motion between the mesh and the material must be accounted for in the material constitutive equations. In addition, the ALE method does not allow new (damaged) surfaces to be created and is limited to geometries where the material flow is relatively predictable.

Figure 16.4:  ALE Impact Solution

ALE Impact Solution

For more information about the ALE formulation, refer to Livermore Software Technology Corporation’s LS-DYNA Theoretical Manual.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.