Chapter 9: Hourglassing

Despite being robust for large deformations and saving extensive amounts of computer time, the one-point (reduced) integration solid and shell elements used in ANSYS LS-DYNA are prone to zero-energy modes. These modes, commonly referred to as hourglassing modes, are oscillatory in nature and tend to have periods that are much shorter than those of the overall structural response (i.e., they result in mathematical states that are not physically possible). They typically have no stiffness and give a zigzag appearance to a mesh (see Figure 9.1: Hourglass Deformations) known as hourglass deformations. The occurrence of hourglass deformations in an analysis can invalidate the results and should always be minimized.

Figure 9.1:  Hourglass Deformations

Hourglass Deformations

Undeformed mesh and deformed mesh with hourglassing effect


Hourglassing can affect brick and quadrilateral shell and 2-D elements, but not triangular shell, triangular 2-D, or beam elements.

Good modeling practices normally prevent hourglassing from becoming significant. The general principles are to use a uniform mesh and to avoid concentrated loads on a single point. Since one excited element transfers the hourglassing mode to its neighbors, all point loads should be spread over an area of several neighboring nodes. In general, refining the overall mesh will almost always significantly reduce the effects of hourglassing.

ANSYS LS-DYNA offers a number of internal hourglass controls. The idea behind these methods is (1) to add stiffness which resists hourglass modes but not rigid body motions and linear deformation fields, or (2) to damp velocities in the direction of hourglass modes.

One method for controlling hourglassing modes is to adjust the model's bulk viscosity. Hourglass deformations are resisted by a structure’s bulk viscosity, which is automatically calculated by the program. It is possible to increase the bulk viscosity of the model by adjusting the linear (LVCO) and quadratic (QVCO) coefficients of the EDBVIS command. It is generally not recommended, however, to dramatically change the default values of the EDBVIS command because of adverse effects they will have on the global modes of the structure.

Another more generally applicable solution to hourglassing problems is to use the fully integrated formulations of SHELL163 and SOLID164. Fully integrated elements will never experience hourglassing modes. However, these options are more costly (in CPU time) than other element formulations, and they may lead to unrealistically stiff results (locking) for problems involving incompressible behavior, metal plasticity, and bending. The locking is remedied in SHELL163 by using an assumed strain field.

Hourglassing deformations can also be resisted by adding elastic stiffness to a model. Hourglassing can be a problem with small displacement situations, particularly when dynamic relaxation is used. In these cases, it is often beneficial to add elastic stiffness to the model instead of using bulk viscosity methods. This can be done by increasing the hourglassing coefficient (HGCO) of the EDHGLS command. However, use care when increasing these coefficients because they may over-stiffen the model's response in large deformation problems and cause instabilities when HGCO exceeds 0.15.

The hourglass control methods discussed so far have been for the entire model. The final method of hourglass control is to locally increase a portion of the model's stiffness by using the command EDMP,HGLS. For this command, the material number, the hourglass control type (viscous or stiffness), the hourglass coefficient, and bulk viscosity coefficients must be specified. (The defaults for hourglass coefficient and bulk viscosities should be sufficient.) Using this method, hourglass control is specified for a given material and not for the entire model. This allows resisting hourglass deformations in high risk areas of the model without dramatically changing the stiffness characteristics of the entire model.

When performing an explicit dynamics analysis with reduced integration elements, it is always important to determine whether hourglassing effects have significantly degraded the results. As a general guideline, the hourglassing energy should not exceed 10% of the internal energy. The hourglass energy can be compared to the internal energy by reviewing the ASCII files GLSTAT and MATSUM and can be plotted in POST26 (see Postprocessing). To make sure that hourglass energy results are reported in these files, the HGEN field of the EDENERGY command must be set to 1.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.