Use curve fitting to determine your creep material behavior. Thirteen creep models are available, along with the tools to generate and fit derived coefficients to your experimental data.
The following topics concerning creep material curve fitting are available:
The general process for creep curve fitting is defined as follows:
| Step | Detailed Information Found Here | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Step 1. Prepare Experimental Data | The experimental data must be a plain text file with headers to describe the data types and attributes. The test data must be delimited by a space or a comma. |
| 2 | Step 2. Input the Experimental Data | Read the experimental data in by specifying the file location on the command line. |
| 3 | Step 3. Select a Material Model Option | The material options for the applicable curve-fitting regimen are defined via the TB command. Support is offered for 13 implicit creep models. After you choose a model, you can still switch to another model if an ideal fit is not realized. |
| 4 | Step 4. Initialize the Coefficients | Creep curve fitting is a nonlinear regression; the initial values of the coefficients to be determined can be very important for a successful solution. |
| 5 | Step 5. Specify Control Parameters and Solve | Choose the error norm to be used for an acceptable curve fit. |
| 6 | Step 6. Plot the Experimental Data and Analyze | Review and verify the results by comparing them with the experimental data and the regression errors. If they are unacceptable, repeat steps 3 through 5 to obtain a new curve-fitting solution. |
| 7 | Step 7. Write Data to the TB Command | Write the curve-fitting results in the TB command format to the database. |
You need to provide accurate experimental test data in order to achieve valid curve-fitting results. For creep analyses, you use either the creep strain value or creep strain rate, derived as a function of time, temperature, stress, and/or creep strain. The type of data you need to provide will depend on the creep model you choose. The experimental data is named "creep" to distinguish it from other types of data, such as uniaxial, tension, biaxial, etc. The creep data must be a plain text file that contains the headers and the test data in table form, delimited by a space or a comma.
The header is used to describe the data types that characterize the test data columns or attributes of the data. Five different creep data types are available:
Table 7.5: Creep Data Types and Abbreviations
| Time | time |
| Equivalent Creep Strain | creq |
| Equivalent Creep Strain Rate | dcreq |
| Equivalent Stress | seqv |
| Temperature | temp |
The header format to define each column's data type is /n, abbr, where n is the index of the data column in the file, and abbr is the abbreviation for the type of data in the column, as described in Table 7.5: Creep Data Types and Abbreviations.
Following is a typical data input file:
/1,seqv ! indicates first column is stress /2,creq ! indicates second column is creep strain /3,temp ! indicates third column is temperature /4,dcreq ! indicates fourth column is creep strain rate 4000 0.00215869 100 0.000203055 4000 0.00406109 100 0.000181314 4000 0.00664691 100 0.000165303 4000 0.0102068 100 0.000152217 4000 0.0151416 100 0.000140946
When a particular column is unchanged over the loading history, you can define it as an attribute. For instance, in the above example, the stress and temperature are constant throughout the range. You define this data as an attribute.
The header format to define a data attribute is /attr, value, where attr is the data-type abbreviation, and value is the value of the attribute. The constant stress and temperature values above can be written into the file header, as follows:
/seqv,4000 ! indicate this creep has a constant stress of 4000 /temp,100 ! indicate this creep data is at a constant temperature of 100 /1,creq ! indicate first column is creep strain /2,dcreq ! indicate second column is creep strain rate 0.00215869 0.000203055 0.00406109 0.000181314 0.00664691 0.000165303 0.0102068 0.000152217 0.0151416 0.000140946 0.0220102 0.000130945
Thirteen model types are available for creep curve fitting. The model you choose determines the experimental data required for the curve-fitting process. The following table describes the creep data required to perform curve fitting for each model type. For strain hardening and modified strain hardening, you must input both creep strain and creep strain rate in the experimental data.
Table 7.6: Creep Model and Data/Type Attribute
| Creep Model | creq | dcreq | time | seqv | temp |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strain Hardening | x | x | x | x | |
| Time Hardening | x | x | x | x | |
| Generalized Exponential | x | x | x | x | |
| Generalized Graham | x | x | x | x | |
| Generalized Blackburn | x | x | x | ||
| Modified Time Hardening | x | x | x | x | |
| Modified Strain Hardening | x | x | x | x | |
| Generalized Garofalo | x | x | x | ||
| Exponential Form | x | x | x | ||
| Norton | x | x | x | ||
| Combined Time Hardening | x | x | x | x | |
| Prim+Sec Rational Polynomial | x | x | x | ||
| Generalized Time Hardening | x | x | x | x |
The experimental data must be read in from a plain text file. Prepare this file according to the previous section, including both header information and formatted test data. The header portion is required for creep analyses.
Each file is viewed as a data set, and can be a complete set of experimental test data or a part of a series of files of experimental test data. You can include several data sets, such as tests performed at different loading conditions, strain ranges, and temperatures in separate files. Each file can have only one header.
The EADD argument on the TBFT command is used to identify and specify the location of your data files. The command syntax is:
TBFT,EADD,ID,Option1,Option2,Option3,Option4
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option1 = creep |
Option2 = name of file containing experimental
data |
Option3 = file name extension |
Option4 = file directory |
The models available for creep curve fitting are defined in Table 7.7: Creep Models and Abbreviations. Select the one that best satisfies your requirements, and use the creep model abbreviation from the table in subsequent fitting operations. It is helpful to view the formula before solving, as you can better determine the initial coefficients to use and the format of your experimental data.
See Table 7.7: Creep Models and Abbreviations to determine a starting point for the initial creep model coefficients.
TBFT,FADD,ID,CREEP,Option2,Option3
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option2 = creep model abbreviation. See Table 7.7: Creep Models and Abbreviations. |
Option3 = not used for creep curve
fitting. |
The following table describes the creep models available and their abbreviated
names for Option2 (above).
Table 7.7: Creep Models and Abbreviations
| Model Number | Name | Fitting Name/Option2 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Strain Hardening | shar |
| 2 | Time Hardening | thar |
| 3 | Generalized Exponential | gexp |
| 4 | Generalized Graham | ggra |
| 5 | Generalized Blackburn | gbla |
| 6 | Modified Time Hardening | mtha |
| 7 | Modified Strain Hardening | msha |
| 8 | Generalized Garofalo | ggar |
| 9 | Exponential Form | expo |
| 10 | Norton | nort |
| 11 | Prim+Sec Time Hardening | psth |
| 12 | Prim+Sec Rational Polynomial | psrp |
| 13 | Generalized Time Hardening | gtha |
The experimental data must be consistent with the creep model you choose. See Table 7.6: Creep Model and Data/Type Attribute for the data types required for each creep model.
Creep curve fitting is a nonlinear regression process. A successful curve fit depends greatly on the initial coefficient values; certain variances will prevent your curve fit from converging. When a solution doesn't converge, you can adjust the initial value of specific coefficients and rerun the problem (you do not need to input the data again). In general, the more parameters a model has, the more difficult it is to get the solution to converge.
Models with many parameters will sometimes converge more easily if you fix (hold constant) your coefficients. You specify a value for a coefficient and keep it unchanged, while allowing the other coefficients to be operated on. You can then release the fixed coefficients to obtain a solution. By default, all of the coefficients are free to vary.
Although some creep models implicitly address temperature dependency, other models lack this capability. For both types of models, you can account for temperature dependency by generating coefficients at discrete temperature values.
Solve for separate coefficients at each of your desired discrete temperatures. If the equation implicitly supports temperature dependency already, that portion is eliminated by appropriately fixing the coefficient to a specific value. For example, if you have e(-C*T), then C is set to 0 to eliminate this term. To do this, you activate temperature dependency by setting the tdep parameter to 1.
For temperature-dependent experimental data, you enable temperature-dependency and specify a reference temperature before solving for the coefficients. You can set the reference temperature only to values specified using the /temp,value header line in the experimental data.
You can also specify tref = all and initiate multiple solves to evaluate coefficients at all available discrete temperature values. In this case, for data at three temperatures (t1, t2, and t3), a single TBFT,SOLVE entry will initiate three different solve operations at those three discrete temperatures.
With temperature dependency on and the reference temperature set to a particular value, a TBFT,SOLVE command solves for coefficients only at that temperature. To solve for coefficients at other temperatures, you set the reference temperature to each of the desired discrete temperature values and solve again.
You can initialize the coefficients before or after turning temperature dependency on. If the coefficients are initialized before turning temperature dependency on, the specified coefficients will become the initial coefficients for all future solves for that particular model. These coefficients are, however, overridden when temperature dependency is turned on and another set of initial values is specified at discrete temperatures. The curve-fitting tool looks for the initial coefficients at a particular temperature. If no coefficients are specified at discrete temperatures, the initial coefficients set before temperature dependency was turned on are used.
Define your coefficient values and temperature dependency using the SET option of the TBFT command, as follows:
TBFT,SET,ID,CREEP,Option2,Option3,Option4,Option5
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option2 = creep model name |
Option3 = order, if applicable |
Option4 = index of coefficient |
Option5 = value of coefficient |
| To modify the coefficients, use the FIX option of the TBFT command. |
TBFT,FIX,ID,CREEP,Option2,Option3,Option4,Option5
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option2 = creep model name |
Option3 = order, if applicable |
Option4 = index of coefficient |
Option5 = 0 - variable, 1 - fixed |
TBFT,SET,ID,CREEP,Option2,Option3,Option4,Option5
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option2 = creep model name |
Option3 = order, if applicable |
Option4 = tdep or tref |
Option5 = For Option4
= tdep, 1 to activate, 0 to deactivate. For
Option4 = tdep, a specific temp value, or
“all.” |
Your error norm, your maximum number iterations allowed, and your error tolerance will affect the accuracy of your results. There are two available error norms available for the regression. The default error norm calculation option is normalized curve fitting. It usually yields better results than non-normalized curve fitting, since normalized fitting gives equal weight to all data points when minimizing the error norms.
Other available solve criteria are number of iterations, residual tolerance, and coefficient change tolerance. The solution stops when both residual tolerance and coefficient change tolerance is met or if the number of iterations criteria is met. The coefficients are updated after every iteration during the solve process.
The batch command is:
TBFT,SOLVE,ID,CREEP,Option2,Option3,Option4, ..., Option7
where:
ID = Index corresponding to the material number |
Option2 = creep function name (See Table 7.7: Creep Models and Abbreviations) |
Option3 = ((Blank--not applicable for creep
models) |
Option4 = Error norm: 0 = non-normalized, 1 =
normalized (default) |
Option5 = Maximum number of iterations |
Option6 = Tolerance of residual changes |
Option7 = Tolerance of coefficient
changes |
Other solving parameters are available. See the TBFT command for details.
After you initiate , the coefficient tables will contain the fitted coefficients and also the residual errors. You can then plot your data and visually interpret the results. Column one is your X- axis, with each additional column plotted separately as a function of column one.
You should reserve column one for the variable that you would like to see vary in the plot. For example, if your data contains time, temperature, stress and creep strain, you may wish to see the creep strain vary as a function of time, at different temperatures and stresses in the plot. Add your experimental data using multiple TBFT,EADD commands. Split the file into multiple experimental fields as prescribed earlier, one for each combination of temperature and stress.
Right mouse button (RMB) functions allow you to Zoom, Fit, Save Plot to File, View/Hide Legend and View/Hide Grid. Two or more fitted functions can also be compared in the same plot. For example, you can view Mooney2 Uniaxial and Mooney9 Uniaxial plots right on top of each other, provided both of these function are already solved for. RMB also allows you to see the number of points used to generate the plot, and also change the Minimum X Value and the Maximum X Value in a plot. You can use the middle-mouse button (context sensitive) to hide a particular curve within a graph.
Graphically review the curve-fitting result and ensure a good fit throughout the range of data. Use the plotted curve-fitting results both to determine the degree of fit at various locations and to verify the error norm/residual value. You can then determine the quality of a curve fitting and decide whether to accept the results. If the results are unacceptable, you may want to go back to step 3, and then solve again with a new model, redefining certain initial values of the coefficients, and also modifying some of the other control parameters. You can continue to use your experimental data, repeating step 3 through step 6 until you obtain a satisfactory solution.
After you are satisfied with your curve-fitting results, you can write the curve-fitting data to the database using TBFT, FSET. The command converts the coefficients to the appropriate form before writing to TB tables. The data is stored as part of the material property set for use in subsequent analyses.
The following tips can help to ensure successful curve fitting. They are only suggestions, and do not represent a singular method or strategy. Also, following them does not guarantee a solution. Refer to Creep for additional details about each implicit creep model.
| Strain Hardening | Strain hardening has 4 coefficients, with C4 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C4 to zero. If you have difficulty solving temperature-dependent data, use experimental data for only one temperature and fix C4 to zero. Solve, and then add data for your other temperatures. Then release C4 and solve for all coefficients. You can also solve for just C4 by fixing the C1, C2 and C3 values. |
| Time Hardening | Time hardening has 4 coefficients, with C4 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C4 to zero. If you have difficulty solving temperature-dependent data, use experimental data for only one temperature and fix C4 to zero. Solve, and then add data for your other temperatures. Then release C4 and solve for all coefficients. You can also solve for just C4 by fixing the C1, C2 and C3 values. |
| Generalized Exponential | Generalized exponential has 5 coefficients, with C4 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C4 to zero. Use a low value for C5 (e.g., 1e-3) to avoid floating-point overflows in the exponential term. If you have difficulty solving for temperature-dependent data, use experimental data for only one temperature, fix C4 to zero, then solve. Then add data for your other temperatures, release C4 and solve for all coefficients. You can also solve for just C4 by fixing C1, C2 and C3. |
| Generalized Graham | Generalized Graham has 8 coefficients. You use C8 for temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C8 to zero. If you have difficulty solving temperature-dependent data, use experimental data for only one temperature, fix C8 to zero, and solve. Then add data for other temperatures, release C8 and solve for the remaining coefficients individually. |
| Generalized Blackburn | Generalized Blackburn has 7 coefficients. It is advisable to look at the exponential terms and try to keep them from floating-point overflows. To keep eC2σ within floating-point range, make sure the initial value of C2 is such that C2σ is close to 1. Similarly try to keep σ/C4 and C7σ close to 1. |
| Modified Time Hardening | Modified time hardening has 4 coefficients. C4 is for temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, fix C4 to zero. |
| Modified Strain Hardening | Modified Strain Hardening has 3 coefficients. This
model can be complex for curve fitting. To keep the |
| Generalized Garofalo | Generalized Garofalo has 4 coefficients, with C4 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C4 to zero. To keep the Sinh term within floating-point range, keep c2σ close to one when you initialize the coefficients. |
| Exponential Form | Exponential form has 3 coefficients, with C3 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C3 to zero. To keep eσC2 within floating-point range, keep σ/C2 close to one. |
| Norton | Norton model has 3 coefficients, with C3 dedicated to temperature dependency. If you do not have temperature-dependent data, set C3 to zero. |
| Prim+Sec Time Hardening | Time hardening has 7 coefficients. This is a complex model. Here it is advisable to solve for temperature independent data first and then introduce temperature related data. To keep the coefficients positive and to improve convergence, the curve-fitting process replaces coefficients C1 and C5 with exp(C1) and exp(c5), respectively, and converts them appropriately before generating the material data tables. |
| Prim+Sec Rational Polynomial | Rational polynomial is a very complex model for curve fitting, with 10 coefficients. If you find it hard to fit this data, it is advisable that you split the experimental data into primary creep data and secondary creep data. Primary creep data is the initial part of the curve that covers the nonlinearity in the strain rate. Fit only the secondary data by fixing C1 to 1 and then set all other coefficients except C2, C3 and C4 to zero. Use a low value of C3 to keep 10C3σ within floating-point range. Coefficients C5 to C10 in curve fitting refers to coefficients C7 to C12 in the implicit creep equation (rational polynomial). Then add the primary creep data, release all coefficients, and solve. |
| Generalized Time Hardening | Generalized time hardening has 6 coefficients. Set C6 to zero if you have temperature independent data. When initializing coefficients set C5σ close to 1 to avoid floating-point overflows. |