7.7. Results and Discussion

The following illustration shows the deformation plots (USUM) of the camshaft assembly at various time steps during one full rotation (θ = 360 degrees) of the shaft:

Figure 7.7:  USUM Plots of Camshaft Assembly During Analysis

USUM Plots of Camshaft Assembly During Analysis

The plots show that the valve always remains in touch with the cam throughout the analysis.

The following figure shows the maximum and minimum principal stress plots of the valve and shaft at the end of the analysis:

Figure 7.8:  Maximum and Minimum Principal Stress Plots

Maximum and Minimum Principal Stress Plots

The shaft and valve are subjected to nonaxisymmetric deformation. The results show that general axisymmetric elements are capable of modeling nonlinear general 3-D deformation. The problem also demonstrates how general axisymmetric elements can have any axis as the axisymmetric axis.

7.7.1. Results Comparison: General Axisymmetric Model and Full 3-D Model

To verify the accuracy and efficiency of the general axisymmetric element model, a transient analysis was performed on the full 3-D model of the crankshaft assembly. Both the general axisymmetric model and the full 3-D model simulations were run on the same computer. Solution settings for both models were identical.

The following figure shows a direct comparison of results between the full 3-D model and the general axisymmetric model:

Figure 7.9:  Comparison of USUM Plots: General Axisymmetric Model and Full 3-D Model

Comparison of USUM Plots: General Axisymmetric Model and Full 3-D Model

In the full 3-D model, the number of degrees of freedom (DOFs) is approximately 300,000. In the general axisymmetric model, the number of DOFs is only 18,000. The smaller number of DOFs in the general axisymmetric model is possible due to the combination of axisymmetric and 3-D modeling.

Following is a comparison of the general axisymmetric model and the full 3-D model in terms of computational efficiency:

FEA Model DetailsGeneral Axisymmetric Model [1]Full 3-D Model [2]
Number of elements in FEA model41408473
Number of elements in valve component691632
Number of elements in shaft component1023453
Number of elements in valve ball component11581122
Number of elements in cams17691769
Simulation timeSimulation time for the general axisymmetric model is observed to be approximately 55 percent less than that of the full 3-D model.
  1. In the general axisymmetric model, the valve and shaft components are meshed with general axisymmetric SOLID272 elements. The remaining components consist of standard 3-D elements.

  2. In the full 3-D model, all components are meshed with 3-D elements.

The analyses show that using general axisymmetric elements can reduce computational time significantly with no loss of accuracy.


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.