19.7. Results and Discussion

The following animation (generated in ANSYS Workbench) shows the motion of the digger-arm assembly:

Figure 19.7:  Digger-Arm Assembly Animation

Digger-Arm Assembly Animation

The following figure shows the rotation of the frame with respect to ground for all three transient dynamic analysis cases. The motion of the frame (due to the activation of the piston-cylinder assemblies) is the same in all three cases.

Figure 19.8:  Relative Rotation at Cylindrical Joint (Ground-to-Frame)

Relative Rotation at Cylindrical Joint (Ground-to-Frame)

The following figure compares the relative rotation of the bucket with respect to the frame for the three analysis cases. The rotations in the three cases are nearly identical.

Figure 19.9:  Relative Rotation at General Joint Along Local Z Axis (Bucket-Frame)

Relative Rotation at General Joint Along Local Z Axis (Bucket-Frame)

Both relative-rotation figures shown above indicate that the kinematic behavior of the digger-arm assembly, whether modeled as entirely rigid or as a rigid/flexible combination, exhibit the same behavior. When flexibility is involved in an analysis, modeling the assembly as though it consisted of rigid parts, and ensuring that the joints are defined correctly, allows the engineer to focus on other issues.

The stresses and deformation fields can be evaluated when the connecting rods are made flexible. The following figure shows the deformation plots (USUM) of the connecting rods when the rods are modeled as flexible:

Figure 19.10:  USUM Plots of Connecting Rods

USUM Plots of Connecting Rods

The following figure shows the equivalent stresses in the connecting rods when the rods are modeled using SOLID185 elements and as CMS superelements, respectively.

Figure 19.11:  Equivalent Stress Plots of Connecting Rods

Equivalent Stress Plots of Connecting Rods

The time point is at 25 seconds (load step 3, substep 25). The equivalent stress plots show good agreement with each other.

The following table shows the CPU time comparisons between the three analysis cases.

All Rigid PartsFlexible and Rigid PartsCMS and Rigid Parts
Total degrees of freedom6062874702
Total iterations458489436
Generation time (with original database saved)------2.38 seconds
Use pass time------46.8 seconds
Total CPU time (including full-model save, generation pass, use pass, expansion pass, and results processing)42.5 seconds372.68 seconds78.06 seconds

In all cases, shared memory parallel with two CPUs is used. The results are reported for a 64-bit Linux system.

The table and the other results discussed illustrate some essential analysis considerations:


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.