45.8. Results and Discussion

The modal frequencies of the NASA Rotor 67 fan blade cyclic sector model and the full model are compared in the following table:

Table 45.2:  Comparison of Modal Frequencies

Mode No. Cyclic Sector Model (Hz) Full 360° Model (Hz) Error (%)
1370.17370.170.00
2370.17370.170.00
3376.70376.700.00
4376.70376.700.00
5377.12377.120.00
6377.12377.120.00
7377.41377.410.00
8378.93378.920.00
9378.93378.930.00
10380.42380.420.00
11380.42380.420.00
12381.65381.650.00
13381.65381.650.00
14382.65382.650.00
15382.65382.650.00

The nonlinear (NLGEOM,ON) prestressed modal frequencies of the cyclic sector obtained from the linear perturbation analysis also show strong agreement with the full-model results, as shown in the following table:

Table 45.3:  Comparison of Prestressed Modal Frequencies

Mode No. Cyclic Sector Model (Hz) Full 360° Model (Hz) Error (%)
1519.09519.090.00
2521.05521.050.00
3521.05521.050.00
4522.69522.700.00
5522.70522.700.00
6526.38526.390.00
7526.39526.390.00
8528.12528.120.00
9528.12528.120.00
10529.65529.650.00
11529.65529.650.00
12531.07531.070.00
13531.07531.070.00
14532.29532.290.00
15532.29532.290.00

The prestressed modal frequencies can be plotted as a function of the number of harmonic index (nodal diameter) using the PLZZ command:

Figure 45.14:  Interference Diagram of NASA Rotor 67 Fan Blade Model

Interference Diagram of NASA Rotor 67 Fan Blade Model

Modes dominated by blade motion tend to appear in a tight frequency range in the plot. In contrast, the modal stiffness of a disk increases rapidly as the harmonic index (nodal diameter) increases, and so disk-dominated system modes appear as slanted dotted lines in the plot. This plot is also known as a SAFE diagram or a ZZENF diagram and indicates potential frequencies where resonance may occur.

To postprocess the results of a cyclic symmetry mode-superposition harmonic analysis, you must first issue the CYCFILES command in /POST1.

For the nonlinear prestressed tuned response analysis, the following figures compare the postprocessing results of the cyclic-sector model to the full 360° model:

Figure 45.15:  Total Deformation Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

Total Deformation Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

Figure 45.16:  Equivalent Stress Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

Equivalent Stress Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

Figure 45.17:  Equivalent Strain Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

Equivalent Strain Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 522.76 Hz

These results show strong agreement between the cyclic-sector model and the full 360° model. The nodal solution plots (NSOL) show the amplitude of a nodal degree-of-freedom (DOF) value with respect to the frequency of excitation:

Figure 45.18:  Nodal Solution Plots with Respect to the Frequency of Excitation

Nodal Solution Plots with Respect to the Frequency of Excitation

The plots indicate the occurrence of a resonance condition at 522.70 Hz. The displacement amplitude of nodes at symmetric angular positions on sectors 1 through 10 is plotted. The plots show strong agreement between the cyclic and full-model results.

You can also retrieve a maximum result value which occurs among all sectors of the model and all frequency points using CYCSPEC and CYCCALC. With these commands, you can extract tables of displacement, stress, and/or strain data for all computed harmonic solutions and for all sectors. The extracted data can be plotted using PLCFREQ and PLCHIST.

For the tuned response analysis, the maximum directional deformation at the blade tip along the Z-direction is plotted using PLCFREQ, as shown in the following figure:

Figure 45.19:  Directional Deformation at the Blade Tip Along the Z-Direction

Directional Deformation at the Blade Tip Along the Z-Direction

The plot clearly indicates the sector numbers which contain the maximum and minimum values for the directional deformation along the Z-direction.

PLCHIST plots a histogram of the directional deformation along the Z-direction at the requested frequency of 522.76 Hz; one bar corresponds to one sector:

Figure 45.20:  CYCSPEC Histogram Response Plot at Frequency 522.76

CYCSPEC Histogram Response Plot at Frequency 522.76

For the nonlinear prestressed mistuned response analysis, the following figures compare the postprocessing (/POST1) results of the cyclic-sector model to the results of the full 360° model:

Figure 45.21:  Total Deformation Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

Total Deformation Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

Figure 45.22:  Equivalent Stress Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

Equivalent Stress Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

Figure 45.23:  Equivalent Strain Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

Equivalent Strain Pattern (Real Only) at Frequency of 534.76 Hz

The results show strong agreement between the cyclic-sector model and the full 360° model.

The nodal solution plots (NSOL) show the amplitude of a nodal degree-of-freedom (DOF) value with respect to the frequency of excitation:

Figure 45.24:  Nodal Solution Plots with Respect to the Frequency of Excitation

Nodal Solution Plots with Respect to the Frequency of Excitation

The plots indicate the occurrence of a resonance condition at 522.70 Hz. The displacement amplitude of nodes at symmetric angular positions in sectors 1 through 10 is plotted. The plots show strong agreement between the cyclic-sector and full 360° model results.

For the mistuned response analysis, the maximum directional deformation at the blade tip along the Z-direction is plotted using PLCFREQ, as shown in the following figure:

Figure 45.25:  Directional Deformation at the Blade Tip Along the Z-Direction

Directional Deformation at the Blade Tip Along the Z-Direction

The plot clearly indicates the sector numbers which contain the maximum and minimum values for the directional deformation along the Z-direction.

PLCHIST plots a histogram of the directional deformation along the Z-direction at the requested frequency of 534.76 Hz; one bar corresponds to one sector:

Figure 45.26:  CYCSPEC Histogram Response Plot at Frequency 534.76 Hz

CYCSPEC Histogram Response Plot at Frequency 534.76 Hz


Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.