To perform a similar analysis, consider the following hints and recommendations:
For constitutive models that require a stress integration algorithm, ensure that the algorithm is accurate. Exercise the user material in simple simulations to determine if it is producing accurate stress results for the types of simulations that will use the user material routine. The accuracy of the stress update directly affects the accuracy of the finite element solution.
The material tangent returned by the user material routine should be the algorithmic tangent in the co-rotated frame. For a Newton-Raphson solution, the material tangent affects the convergence rate and an algorithmic material tangent will generally give a quadratic convergence rate for iterations that are close to the solution.
The user material routine is available only for displacement-based element formulations. Since it is not available for the mixed-uP formulations, materials that are nearly incompressible need to use a penalty formulation for the volumetric behavior. This can cause convergence difficulty and errors in the pressure calculation when the volumetric behavior is very stiff. Therefore, the user material subroutine should not be used for nearly incompressible materials when the volumetric behavior is important.