This method works for generalized radiation problems involving two or more surfaces receiving and emitting radiation. The method involves generating a matrix of form factors (view factors) between radiating surfaces and using the matrix as a superelement in the thermal analysis. You also can include hidden or partially hidden surfaces, as well as a "space node" that can absorb radiation energy.
The following AUX12 topics are available:
The AUX12 radiation matrix method consists of three steps:
Define the radiating surfaces.
Generate the radiation matrix.
Use the radiation matrix in the thermal analysis.
To define the radiating surfaces, you create a superimposed mesh of LINK33 elements in 2-D models and SHELL131 (KEYOPT(3) = 2) elements in 3-D models. To do so, perform the following tasks:
Build the thermal model in the preprocessor (PREP7). Radiating surfaces do not support symmetry conditions, therefore models involving radiating surfaces cannot take advantage of geometric symmetry and must therefore be modeled completely (except for 2-D axisymmetric cases). The radiating surfaces usually are faces of a 3-D model and edges of a 2-D model, as shown below:
Superimpose the radiating surfaces with a mesh of SHELL131 (KEYOPT(3) = 2) elements in 3-D models or LINK33 elements in 2-D models, as shown in the graphic below. The best way to do this is to first create a subset of the surface nodes, and then generate the surface elements using one of the following:
Make sure to first activate the proper element type for the surface elements. Also, if the surfaces are to have different emissivities, assign different material reference numbers before creating the elements.
Caution: Radiating surface mesh of SHELL131 or LINK33 elements must match (node for node) the underlying solid element mesh. If it does not match, the resulting thermal solution will be incorrect.
The orientation of the superimposed elements is important. The AUX12 radiation matrix generator assumes that the "viewing" direction (that is, the direction of radiation) is along +Ze for SHELL131 elements and along +Ye for LINK33 elements (where e denotes the outward normal direction of the element coordinate system). Therefore, you must mesh the superimposed elements so that the radiation occurs from (or to) the proper face. The order in which the element's nodes are defined controls the element orientation, as shown below:
Define a space node, which simply is a node that absorbs radiant energy not received by other surfaces in the model. Location of this node is not important. An open system usually requires a space node. However, you should not specify a space node for a closed system.
Calculating the radiation matrix requires the following inputs:
Nodes and elements that make up the radiating surfaces
Model dimensionality (2-D or 3-D)
Emissivity and Stefan-Boltzmann constant
The method used to calculate the form factors (hidden or visible)
A space node, if desired.
To generate the matrix, perform these steps:
Enter AUX12 using one of these methods:
Select the nodes and elements that make up the radiation surfaces. An easy way to do this is to select elements by type and then select all attached nodes. To perform these tasks, use the GUI path or the commands ESEL,S,TYPE and NSLE. If you have defined a space node, remember to select it.
Specify whether this is a 2-D model or a 3-D model, using either of the following:
The AUX12 radiation matrix generator
uses different algorithms to calculate the form factors for 2-D and
3-D models respectively. It assumes a 3-D model by default. The 2-D
models may be either planar (NDIV value =
0), or axisymmetric (NDIV value > 0),
with planar as the default. Axisymmetric models are expanded
internally to a 3-D model, with NDIV
representing the number of axisymmetric sections. For example,
setting NDIV to 10 indicates ten
sections, each spanning 36 degrees.
Define the emissivity using either method shown below. Emissivity defaults to unity (1.0).
Define the Stefan-Boltzmann constant using either method shown below. The Stefan-Boltzmann constant defaults to 0.119E-10 Btu/hr-in2-R4. (In S.I. Units, the constant has the value 5.67E-8 W/m2-K4.)
Specify how to calculate form factors, using either of the following:
You can choose between the hidden and non-hidden methods:
The non-hidden method calculates the form factors from every element to every other element regardless of any blocking elements.
The hidden method (default) first uses a hidden-line algorithm to determine which elements are "visible" to every other element. (A "target" element is visible to a "viewing" element if their normals point toward each other and there are no blocking elements.) Then, form factors are calculated as follows:
Each radiating or "viewing" element is enclosed with a unit hemisphere (or a semicircle in 2-D).
All target or "receiving" elements are projected onto the hemisphere or semicircle.
To calculate the form factor, a predetermined number of rays are projected from the viewing element to the hemisphere or semicircle. Thus, the form factor is the ratio of the number of rays incident on the projected surface to the number of rays emitted by the viewing element. In general, accuracy of the form factors increases with the number of rays. You can increase the number of rays via the NZONE field on the VTYPE command or the menu option; both indicate the number of radial sampling zones.
If necessary, designate the space node using either of the methods shown below:
Use either the WRITE command or the menu option to write the radiation matrix to the file Jobname.SUB. If you want to write more than one radiation matrix, use a separate filename for each matrix. To print your matrices, issue the command MPRINT,1 before issuing the WRITE command.
Reselect all nodes and elements using either of the following:
You now have the radiation matrix written as a superelement on a file.
After writing the radiation matrix, re-enter the preprocessor (PREP7) and read the matrix in as a superelement. To do so, perform these steps:
Re-enter the preprocessor using one of these methods:
Switch the element type pointer to the superelement using either of the following:
Read in the superelement matrix using one of these methods:
Either unselect or delete the superimposed mesh of SHELL131 or LINK33 elements, using either of the following:
(The thermal analysis does not require these elements.)
Exit from the preprocessor and enter the SOLUTION processor.
Assign the known boundary condition to the space node using either of the following:
This boundary typically is a temperature (such as ambient temperature), but also may be a heat flow. The boundary condition value should reflect the actual environmental conditions being modeled.
Proceed with the thermal analysis as explained in the other chapters of this manual.
Although modeling radiation does not always require a space node, the decision to or not to use one can affect the accuracy of your thermal analysis results. Keep the following recommendations about space node usage in mind as you build your model.
The non-hidden method of form factor calculation usually is accurate enough for any system without requiring special attention to space nodes. Generally, you should not specify a space node for a closed system, but you should specify one for an open system. Only one situation requires special attention: when modeling an open system which includes gray body radiation (emissivity is less than 1), you must use a space node to ensure accurate results.
For the hidden method of form factor calculation, the accuracy of the form factor calculations within AUX12 can affect the accuracy of the radiation calculated to the space node. Because inaccuracies in the calculations accumulate at the space node, the relative error in the space node form factor can be exaggerated in a closed or nearly closed system.
When using the hidden method, you may need to increase the number of rays used in the form factor calculation and to refine the mesh in order to make the form factors more accurate. If this is not possible, consider the following tips when defining the space node:
For a closed system in which all radiating surfaces form an enclosure and do not radiate to space, do not use a space node.
If the nature of the problem makes it acceptable to simulate radiation between the radiating surfaces only (ignoring radiation to space), then do not specify a space node. This approach is valid only when modeling black body radiation (where emissivity = 1).
For a nearly closed system, if you must account for radiation to space, then mesh the opening and constrain the temperature of the nodes in the opening to the temperature of space. The form factor to space will then be calculated explicitly and more accurately.
For an open system where there are significant losses to space, you can use a space node (with a specified boundary condition) to capture the lost radiation with acceptable accuracy using moderate mesh refinement and a moderate number of rays.
Below are some general guidelines for using the AUX12 radiation matrix generator approach to radiation analysis:
The non-hidden method should be used if and only if all the radiating surfaces see each other fully. If the non-hidden method is used for cases where any blocking effect exists, there will be significant inaccuracies in view factor calculations, and the subsequent thermal analysis results can be physically inaccurate, or the problem might not even converge.
The hidden method requires significantly longer computer time than the non-hidden method. Therefore, use it only if blocking surfaces are present or if surfaces cannot be grouped.
In some cases, you may be able to group radiating surfaces so that each group is isolated completely from the other groups in terms of radiation heat transfer. In such cases, you can save significant time by creating a separate radiation matrix for each group using the non-hidden method. (This is true so long as no blocking effects exist within a group.) You can do this by selecting the desired group of radiating surfaces before writing the matrix.
For the hidden method, increasing the number of rays usually produces more accurate form factors.
For both hidden and non-hidden methods, the finer the mesh of
the radiating surface elements, the more accurate are the form factors.
However, when hidden method is used, it is particularly important to
have a fairly refined mesh in order to obtain the same level of accuracy
in view factor computation as the non-hidden method. Event though
increasing the number of rays used (controlled by
NZONE argument of the
VTYPE command) helps in accuracy, for a coarse
mesh, increasing NZONE to even its maximum
limit might not yield an accurate solution for the hidden
method.
For axisymmetric models, about 20 axisymmetric sectors provide reasonably accurate form factors. Elements should have reasonable aspect ratios whey they are expanded to a 3-D model.
LINK33 elements, which are used as superimposed radiation surface elements in 2-D planar or axisymmetric models, do not directly support the axisymmetric option. In axisymmetric models, therefore, be sure to delete (or unselect) them before doing the thermal analysis.
Theoretically, the summation of view factor from any radiating surface to all
other radiating surfaces should be 1.0 for a closed system. This is printed as
***** FORM FACTORS ***** TOTAL =
Value for each radiating surface if the view factors for
radiating surfaces are printed using the MPRINT,1 command. For
open systems, the summation should always be less than 1.0. One way of checking
whether the view factor calculations are correct or not is to use the
MPRINT,1 command, and check if the summation of view factors
for any radiating surface exceeds 1.0. This can happen if the non-hidden method is
inadvertently used for calculating view factors between radiating surfaces with
blocking effects. For more information, see Radiation Matrix Method in the Mechanical APDL Theory Reference.