/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /verify,vm149 /title,vm149,Residual Vector in Mode Superposition Harmonic Analysis /com, /com, Verification manual to verify the effect of residual /com, vector to improve the solution accuracy in modal /com, response analysis /com, /com, Reference: J.M.Dickens,J.M.Nakagawa,M.J.Wittbrodt /com, "A critique of mode acceleration and modal truncation /com, augmentation methods for modal response analysis" /com, computers & structures,Vol.62,No.6,pp 985-998,1997 /com, /com, ******************************** /com, CASE1: EXTRACTING ALL THE MODES /com, ******************************** /filename,case1 /prep7 et,1,combin14,,,2 ! 2D Spring-damper element et,2,mass21,,,4 ! 2D Mass without rotary inertia et,3,mass21,,,4 ! 2D Mass without rotary inertia r,1,10000 ! Stiffness for spring element r,2,1 ! Mass r,3,0.5 ! Mass n,1 n,2,1 n,3,2 n,4,3 n,5,4 n,6,5 e,1,2 ! Spring 1 e,2,3 ! Spring 2 e,3,4 ! Spring 3 e,4,5 ! Spring 4 e,5,6 ! Spring 5 type,2 real,2 e,2 ! Mass 1 e,3 ! Mass 2 e,4 ! Mass 3 type,3 real,3 e,5 ! Mass 4 d,1,all d,6,all nsel,s,,,2,5 d,all,uy nsel,all finish /solution antype,modal modopt,lanb,4 ! Extracting all modes mxpand,all,,,yes f,4,fx,1 ! Generate load vector for harmonic analysis solve fini /solution antype,harmic,new hropt,msup,4,, ! Mode superposition harmonic analysis outres,all,all fdele,all lvscale,1 ! Scaling the load vector harfrq,3,70 ! Frequency range dmprat,0.02 ! Damping nsubst,500 kbc,1 save solve fini /solution expass,on outres,all,all numexp,all,,,yes solve finish /post26 file,case1,rst numvar,20 /com, ******************************************************* /com, Computing the 1st peak displacement and spring force /com, ********************************************************* nsol,2,4,u,x,4ux realvar,4,2,,,UXR ! Real value of UX imagin,5,2,,,UXI ! Imaginary value of UX prod,6,4,4,,UXR_2 prod,7,5,5,,UXI_2 add,8,6,7,,UXR_2+UXI_2 sqrt,9,8,,,ampl_disp,,,1 ! Amplitude esol,10,4,4,smisc,1 realvar,11,10,,,ForceR ! Real value of Spring force imagin,12,10,,,ForceI ! Imaginary value of Spring force prod,13,11,11,,ForceR_2 prod,14,12,12,,ForceI_2 add,15,13,14,,ForceR_2+ForceI_2 sqrt,16,15,,,ampl_force,,,1 ! Amplitude /out,scratch /grid,1 /gropt,logy,1 /xrange,3,70 /axlab,y,amplitude_disp_force plvar,9,16 prvar,9,16 *get,ux_max_all,vari,9,extrem,vmax *get,force_max_all,vari,16,extrem,vmax *get,freq_ux_all,vari,9,extrem,tmax *get,freq_force_all,vari,16,extrem,tmax /out, /com, ******************************************************* /com, Computing the 2nd peak spring force /com, ******************************************************* timerange,11,70 ! Listing values between 11hz to 70Hz store,new ! Store new set of data esol,10,4,4,smisc,1 realvar,11,10,,,ForceR ! Real value of Spring force imagin,12,10,,,ForceI ! Imaginary value of Spring force prod,13,11,11,,ForceR_2 prod,14,12,12,,ForceI_2 add,15,13,14,,ForceR_2+ForceI_2 sqrt,16,15,,,ampl_force,,,1 ! Amplitude /out,scratch /grid,1 /gropt,logy,1 /xrange,3,70 /axlab,y,amplitude_disp_force plvar,16 prvar,16 *get,force_max_all2,vari,16,extrem,vmax *dim,label,char,5,1 *dim,value,,5,3 label(1,1)='UX_MAX' label(2,1)='F_MAX' label(3,1)='FREQ_UX' label(4,1)='FREQ_F' label(5,1)='F_MAX2' *vfill,value(1,1),data,2.500e-03 *vfill,value(1,2),data,ux_max_all *vfill,value(1,3),data,abs(2.500e-03/ux_max_all) *vfill,value(2,1),data,10.000 *vfill,value(2,2),data,force_max_all *vfill,value(2,3),data,abs(10.000/force_max_all) *vfill,value(3,1),data,10.100 *vfill,value(3,2),data,freq_ux_all *vfill,value(3,3),data,abs(10.100/freq_ux_all) *vfill,value(4,1),data,10.100 *vfill,value(4,2),data,freq_force_all *vfill,value(4,3),data,abs(10.100/freq_force_all) *vfill,value(5,1),data,4.5 *vfill,value(5,2),data,force_max_all2 *vfill,value(5,3),data,abs(4.5/force_max_all2) save,table_1 fini /clear,nostart /out, /com, ******************************************* /com, CASE2: EXTRACTING 1 MODE + RESIDUAL VECTOR /com, ******************************************** /title,vm149,Residual Vector in Mode Superposition Harmonic Analysis /filename,case2 /prep7 et,1,combin14,,,2 ! 2D Spring-damper element et,2,mass21,,,4 ! 2D Mass without rotary inertia et,3,mass21,,,4 ! 2D Mass without rotary inertia r,1,10000 ! Stiffness for spring element r,2,1 ! Mass r,3,0.5 ! Mass n,1 n,2,1 n,3,2 n,4,3 n,5,4 n,6,5 e,1,2 ! Spring 1 e,2,3 ! Spring 2 e,3,4 ! Spring 3 e,4,5 ! Spring 4 e,5,6 ! Spring 5 type,2 real,2 e,2 ! Mass 1 e,3 ! Mass 2 e,4 ! Mass 3 type,3 real,3 e,5 ! Mass 4 d,1,all d,6,all nsel,s,,,2,5 d,all,uy nsel,all finish /solution antype,modal modopt,lanb,1 ! Extract 1 mode mxpand,1,,,yes resvec,on ! Compute residual vector f,4,fx,1 ! Generate load vector solve fini /post1 set,1,2 *get,residual_vector,active,0,set,freq finish /solution antype,harmic, resvec,on ! Include residual vector hropt,msup,1,, fdele,all lvscale,1 ! Scale load vector harfrq,3,70 ! Excitation frequency range dmprat,0.02 ! Damping nsubst,500 kbc,1 save solve fini /solution expass,on outres,all,all numexp,all,,,yes solve finish /post26 file,case2,rst numvar,20 /com, ******************************************************* /com, Computing the 1st peak displacement and spring force /com, ********************************************************* nsol,2,4,u,x,4ux realvar,4,2,,,UXR ! Real value of UX imagin,5,2,,,UXI ! Imaginary value of UX prod,6,4,4,,UXR_2 prod,7,5,5,,UXI_2 add,8,6,7,,UXR_2+UXI_2 sqrt,9,8,,,ampl_disp,,,1 esol,10,4,4,smisc,1 realvar,11,10,,,ForceR ! Real value of Spring force imagin,12,10,,,ForceI ! Imaginary value of Spring force prod,13,11,11,,ForceR_2 prod,14,12,12,,ForceI_2 add,15,13,14,,ForceR_2+ForceI_2 sqrt,16,15,,,ampl_force,,,1 /out,scratch /grid,1 /gropt,logy,1 /xrange,3,70 /axlab,y,amplitude_disp_force plvar,9,16 prvar,9,16 *get,ux_max_residual,vari,9,extrem,vmax *get,force_max_residual,vari,16,extrem,vmax *get,freq_ux_residual,vari,9,extrem,tmax *get,freq_force_residual,vari,16,extrem,tmax /out, /com, ********************************************************* /com, Computing the 2nd peak spring force /com, ********************************************************* timerange,11,70 store,new esol,10,4,4,smisc,1 realvar,11,10,,,ForceR ! Real value of Spring force imagin,12,10,,,ForceI ! Imaginary value of Spring force prod,13,11,11,,ForceR_2 prod,14,12,12,,ForceI_2 add,15,13,14,,ForceR_2+ForceI_2 sqrt,16,15,,,ampl_force,,,1 ! Amplitude /out,scratch /grid,1 /gropt,logy,1 /xrange,3,70 /axlab,y,amplitude_disp_force plvar,16 prvar,16 *get,force_max_resvec2,vari,16,extrem,vmax *dim,label,char,6,1 *dim,value,,6,3 label(1,1)='RES_MODE' label(2,1)='UX_MAX' label(3,1)='F_MAX' label(4,1)='FREQ_UX' label(5,1)='FREQ_F' label(6,1)='F_MAX2' *vfill,value(1,1),data,21.865 *vfill,value(1,2),data,residual_vector *vfill,value(1,3),data,abs(21.865/residual_vector) *vfill,value(2,1),data,2.500e-03 *vfill,value(2,2),data,ux_max_residual *vfill,value(2,3),data,abs(2.500e-03/ux_max_residual) *vfill,value(3,1),data,10.000 *vfill,value(3,2),data,force_max_residual *vfill,value(3,3),data,abs(10.000/force_max_residual) *vfill,value(4,1),data,10.100 *vfill,value(4,2),data,freq_ux_residual *vfill,value(4,3),data,abs(10.100/freq_ux_residual) *vfill,value(5,1),data,10.100 *vfill,value(5,2),data,freq_force_residual *vfill,value(5,3),data,abs(10.100/freq_force_residual) *vfill,value(6,1),data,4.5 *vfill,value(6,2),data,force_max_resvec2 *vfill,value(6,3),data,abs(4.5/force_max_resvec2) save,table_2 finish resume,table_1 /com, /out,vm149,vrt /com, /com, ------------------------------VM149 RESULTS COMPARISON---------------------- /com, /com, | TARGET | Mechanical APDL | RATIO /com, /com, /com, Extracting all modes /com, -------------------- /com, /com, *VWRITE,LABEL(1,1),VALUE(1,1),VALUE(1,2),VALUE(1,3) (1X,A14,' ',F12.5,' ',F12.5,' ',F12.3) /com, /com, /NOPR, resume,table_2 /GOPR /com, /com, Extracting 1 mode + residual vector /com, ----------------------------------- /com, /com, /com, *VWRITE,LABEL(1,1),VALUE(1,1),VALUE(1,2),VALUE(1,3) (1X,A14,' ',F12.5,' ',F12.5,' ',F12.3) /com, /com, /NOPR, /com, /com, /com, -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /out, *list,vm149,vrt finish