/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /VERIFY,vm230 /TITLE,vm230,RADIATION BETWEEN TWO CONCENTRIC SPHERES /COM, /COM, REFERENCE: RADIATIVE HEAT TRANSFER, MICHAEL F. MODEST /COM, 3rd EDITION, Pg.205-206 /COM, /COM /COM ***********2D-2D & 3D-3D MODEL IN SAME PREPROCESSOR********** /COM /OUT,SCRATCH /PREP7 R0 = 0.5 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R1 = 1 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R2 = 2 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS R3 = 2.5 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS T1 = 100 ! TEMPERATURE ON INSIDE SPHERE, KELVIN T2 = 1000 ! TEMPERATURE ON OUTER SPHERE, KELVIN e1 = 0.5 ! EMISSIVITY ON INNER SPHERE e2 = 0.4 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTER SPHERE /COM, /COM, ------ CONCENTRIC SPHERES: 2D AXISYMMETRIC MODEL ------ /COM, _GEOM=0 *IF,_GEOM,EQ,1,THEN ET,1,PLANE77 ! 2D AXISYMMETRIC THERMAL ELEMENT KEYOPT,1,3,1 ! AXISYMMETRIC ELEMENT BEHAVIOR MP,DENS,1,.27 ! DENSITY MP,KXX,1,1 ! THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY MP,C,1,1 ! SPECIFIC HEAT CYL4,,,R0,0,R1,90 CYL4,,,R2,0,R3,90 TYPE,1 MAT,1 MSHAPE,0,2D MSHKEY,1 ESIZE,0.25 AMESH,ALL ! MESH THE MODEL WITH PLANE77 AXISYMMETRIC THERMAL ELEMENTS LSEL,S,LINE,,3 NSLL,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T1 ! TEMPERATURE ON INTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE LSEL,S,LINE,,5 NSLL,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T2 ! TEMPERATURE ON EXTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE LSEL,S,LINE,,1 NSLL,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,e1,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON INTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE RDEC,,0.5,,OPTI RSYMM,,,Y RSURF ! 2D RADIOSITY SURFACE ELEMENTS (SURF251) LSEL,S,LINE,,7 NSLL,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,e2,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON EXTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE RSURF ! 2D RADIOSITY SURFACE ELEMENTS (SURF251) ALLSEL,ALL /COM, /COM, ------ CONCENTRIC SPHERES: 3D MODEL ------ /COM, ET,4,SOLID90 ! 3D SOLID THERMAL ELEMENT ET,5,MESH200,7 ! MESH200 ELEMENT K,5000,,-100 K,5001,,100 D = 6 LOCAL,11,0,,D LOCAL,12,2,,D WPOFFS,,D PCIRC,R0,R1,0.0,90.0 PCIRC,R2,R3,0.0,90.0 TYPE,5 MSHK,1 ESIZE,0.25 AMESH,ALL ALLSEL,ALL MAT,1 TYPE,4 MSHK,0 ESIZE,,8 SHPP,OFF VROTAT,3,,,,,,5000,5001,90 VROTAT,4,,,,,,5000,5001,90 ALLSEL,ALL ASEL,S,LOC,Z,0 ACLEAR,3,4 ETDEL,5 ALLSEL,ALL RSYMM,CLEAR RSYMM,,11,Y RSYMM,,11,X RSYMM,,11,Z CSYS,12 NSEL,S,LOC,X,R0 D,ALL,TEMP,T1 ! TEMPERATURE ON INSIDE SPHERE NSEL,S,LOC,X,R3 D,ALL,TEMP,T2 ! TEMPERATURE ON OUTSIDE SPHERE RDEC,,0.5,,OPTI NSEL,S,LOC,X,R1 SF,ALL,RDSF,e1,2 ! EMISSIVITY ON INSIDE SPHERE ESEL,R,TYPE,,4 RSURF ! 3D RADIOSITY SURFACE ELEMENTS (SURF252) ALLSEL,ALL NSEL,S,LOC,X,R2 SF,ALL,RDSF,e2,2 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTSIDE SPHERE ESEL,R,TYPE,,4 RSURF ! 3D RADIOSITY SURFACE ELEMENTS (SURF252) ALLSEL,ALL CSYS,0 CDWRITE,DB,VM230-1,CDB *ELSE CDREAD,DB,VM230-1,CDB *ENDIF FINISH /AUX12 STFCONST = 5.67e-8 T0 = 0. STEF,STFCONST TOFFST,T0 RADOPT,,0.0001,,,0.1,0.1 V2DOPT,1,90,,1000 VFSM,,1,2 VFSM,,2,2 VFOPT,NEW /OUT,SCRATCH /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE VIEW FACTORS FOR 2D AXISYMMETRIC SPHERES ------ /COM, ESEL,S,TYPE,,2 CM,IN1,ELEM ESEL,S,TYPE,,3 CM,OUT1,ELEM ALLSEL,ALL VFQUERY,IN1,IN1 *GET,F11_2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,IN1,OUT1 *GET,F12_2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,IN1 *GET,F21_2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,OUT1 *GET,F22_2D,RAD,,VFAVG ALLSEL,ALL /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE VIEW FACTORS FOR 3D CONCENTRIC SPHERES ------ /COM, ESEL,S,TYPE,,6 CM,IN2,ELEM ESEL,S,TYPE,,7 CM,OUT2,ELEM ALLSEL,ALL VFQUERY,IN2,IN2 *GET,F11_3D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,IN2,OUT2 *GET,F12_3D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT2,IN2 *GET,F21_3D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT2,OUT2 *GET,F22_3D,RAD,,VFAVG ALLSEL,ALL FINISH /SOLUTION ANTYPE,STATIC /OUT,SCRATCH TIME,1 ! END TIME DELTIM,0.5 ! TIME STEPS OUTRES,ALL,ALL CNVTOL,HEAT,1.E-2,,,1.E-5 ! CONVERGENCE TOLERANCE SOLVE FINISH /POST1 SET,LAST /OUT, /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE HEAT FLUXES FOR 2D AXISYMMETRIC CIRCLES ------ /COM, *GET,TI1,NODE,node(1,0,0),TEMP *GET,TO1,NODE,node(2,0,0),TEMP *GET,HFI1,NODE,node(1,0,0),TF,SUM ! INSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX *GET,HFO1,NODE,node(2,0,0),TF,SUM ! OUTSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX HFIEXP1 = ABS((TI1+T0)**4-(TO1+T0)**4)*STFCONST/(1/e1+(R1**2/R2**2)*(1/e2-1)) HFOEXP1 = ABS(-R1**2/R2**2)*HFIEXP1 HFI1ERR = (HFI1/HFIEXP1) HFO1ERR = (HFO1/HFOEXP1) *DIM,VALUE2D,,6,3 *VFILL,VALUE2D(1,1),DATA,0.000,1.000,0.250,0.750,HFIEXP1,HFOEXP1 *VFILL,VALUE2D(1,2),DATA,F11_2D,F12_2D,F21_2D,F22_2D,HFI1,HFO1 *VFILL,VALUE2D(1,3),DATA,0.000,F12_2D/1.000,F21_2D/0.250,F22_2D/0.750,HFI1ERR,HFO1ERR *DIM,LABEL2D,CHAR,10,2 LABEL2D(1,1) = 'VF(1-1)','VF(1-2)','VF(2-1)','VF(2-2)','HFINSIDE','HFOUTSIDE' ALLSEL,ALL /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE HEAT FLUXES FOR 3D CONCENTRIC SPHERES ------ /COM, *GET,TI2,NODE,node(1,6,0),TEMP *GET,TO2,NODE,node(2,6,0),TEMP *GET,HFI2,NODE,node(1,6,0),TF,SUM ! INSIDE SPHERE HEAT FLUX *GET,HFO2,NODE,node(2,6,0),TF,SUM ! OUTSIDE SPHERE HEAT FLUX HFIEXP2 = ABS((TI2+T0)**4-(TO2+T0)**4)*STFCONST/(1/e1+(R1**2/R2**2)*(1/e2-1)) HFOEXP2 = ABS(-R1**2/R2**2)*HFIEXP2 HFI2ERR = (HFI2/HFIEXP2) HFO2ERR = (HFO2/HFOEXP2) *DIM,VALUE3D,,6,3 *VFILL,VALUE3D(1,1),DATA,0.000,1.000,0.250,0.750,HFIEXP2,HFOEXP2 *VFILL,VALUE3D(1,2),DATA,F11_3D,F12_3D,F21_3D,F22_3D,HFI2,HFO2 *VFILL,VALUE3D(1,3),DATA,0.000,F12_3D/1.000,F21_3D/0.250,F22_3D/0.750,HFI2ERR,HFO2ERR *DIM,LABEL3D,CHAR,10,2 LABEL3D(1,1) = 'VF(1-1)','VF(1-2)','VF(2-1)','VF(2-2)','HFINSIDE','HFOUTSIDE' ALLSEL,ALL SAVE,TABLE_1 FINISH /CLEAR,NOSTART /COM /COM ****** 2D-3D CONCENTRIC SPHERES ****** /COM /OUT,SCRATCH /PREP7 R0 = 0.5 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R1 = 1 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R2 = 2 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS R3 = 2.5 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS T1 = 100 ! TEMPERATURE ON INSIDE SPHERE, KELVIN T2 = 1000 ! TEMPERATURE ON OUTER SPHERE, KELVIN E1 = 0.5 ! EMISSIVITY ON INNER SPHERE E2 = 0.4 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTER SPHERE STFCONST = 5.67E-8 T0 = 0. _GEOM=0 *IF,_GEOM,EQ,1,THEN ET,1,PLANE77 ! 2D AXISYMMETRIC THERMAL ELEMENT KEYOPT,1,3,1 ! AXISYMMETRIC ELEMENT BEHAVIOR ET,2,SOLID90 ! 3D SOLID THERMAL ELEMENT ET,3,MESH200,7 ! MESH200 ELEMENTS, 3D QUADRILATERAL WITH 8 NODES MP,DENS,1,.27 ! DENSITY MP,KXX,1,1 ! THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY MP,C,1,1 ! SPECIFIC HEAT PCIRC,R0,R1,0.0,-90.0 VROTAT,1,,,,,,1,4,90 TYPE,3 LSEL,S,LINE,,2,6,2 LESIZE,ALL,,,2 MSHAPE,0,2D MSHKEY,1 ESIZE,0.25 AMESH,1 MAT,1 TYPE,2 VSWEEP,1,1,5 ! CREATING SOLID90 ELEMENTS CYL4,,,R2,-90,R3,90 LSEL,S,LINE,,11,13,2 LESIZE,ALL,,,2 MSHAPE,0,2D MSHKEY,1 ESIZE,0.25 MAT,1 TYPE,1 AMESH,6 ! CREATING AXISYMMETRIC PLANE77 ELEMENTS ALLSEL,ALL ASEL,S,AREA,,4 NSLA,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T1 ! TEMPERATURE ON INNER SPHERE LSEL,S,LINE,,10 NSLL,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T2 ! TEMPERATURE ON OUTER SPHERE ALLSEL,ALL ASEL,S,AREA,,2 NSLA,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,E1,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON INNER SPHERE RSYMM,,,X RSYMM,,,Y RSYMM,,,Z RSURF ALLSEL,ALL RSYMM,CLEAR LSEL,S,LINE,,12 NSLL,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,E2,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTER SPHERE RSYMM,,0,CEXT,40,,0,360 RSURF ALLSEL,ALL CDWRITE,DB,VM230-2,CDB *ELSE SHPP,OFF CDREAD,DB,VM230-2,CDB *ENDIF STEF,STFCONST TOFFST,T0 FINISH /AUX12 RADOPT,,0.0001,,,0.1,0.1 V2DOPT,1,90,,1000 VFSM,,1,2 VFOPT,NEW /OUT,SCRATCH /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE VIEW FACTORS FOR 2D-3D CONCENTRIC SPHERES ------ /COM, ESEL,S,TYPE,,4 CM,IN1,ELEM ESEL,S,TYPE,,5 CM,OUT1,ELEM ALLSEL,ALL VFQUERY,IN1,IN1 *GET,F11_3D3D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,IN1,OUT1 *GET,F12_3D2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,IN1 *GET,F21_2D3D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,OUT1 *GET,F22_2D2D,RAD,,VFAVG ALLSEL,ALL /SOLUTION ANTYPE,STATIC /OUT,SCRATCH TIME,1 DELTIM,0.5 OUTRES,ALL,ALL CNVTOL,HEAT,1.E-2,,,1.E-5 SOLVE FINISH /POST1 SET,LAST /OUT *GET,TI,NODE,NODE(1,0,0),TEMP *GET,TO,NODE,NODE(2,0,0),TEMP *GET,HFI1,NODE,NODE(1,0,0),TF,SUM ! INSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX *GET,HFO1,NODE,NODE(2,0,0),TF,SUM ! OUTSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX HFIEXP1 = ABS((TI+T0)**4-(TO+T0)**4)*STFCONST/(1/E1+(R1**2/R2**2)*(1/E2-1)) HFOEXP1 = ABS(-R1**2/R2**2)*HFIEXP1 HFIERR1 = (HFI1/HFIEXP1) HFOERR1 = (HFO1/HFOEXP1) /OUT,SCRATCH *DIM,VALUE3D2D,,6,3 *VFILL,VALUE3D2D(1,1),DATA,0.000,1.000,0.250,0.750,HFIEXP1,HFOEXP1 *VFILL,VALUE3D2D(1,2),DATA,F11_3D3D,F12_3D2D,F21_2D3D,F22_2D2D,HFI1,HFO1 *VFILL,VALUE3D2D(1,3),DATA,0.000,F12_3D2D/1.000,F21_2D3D/0.250,F22_2D2D/0.750,HFIERR1,HFOERR1 *DIM,LABEL3D2D,CHAR,10,2 LABEL3D2D(1,1) = 'VF(1-1)','VF(1-2)','VF(2-1)','VF(2-2)','HFINSIDE','HFOUTSIDE' ALLSEL,ALL SAVE,TABLE_2 FINISH /CLEAR,NOSTART /COM /COM ****** 2D-2D AXISYMMETRICALLY CONCENTRIC SPHERES ****** /COM /OUT,SCRATCH /PREP7 R0 = 0.5 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R1 = 1 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 1 IN METERS R2 = 2 ! INNER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS R3 = 2.5 ! OUTER RADIUS OF SPHERE 2 IN METERS T1 = 100 ! TEMPERATURE ON INSIDE SPHERE, KELVIN T2 = 1000 ! TEMPERATURE ON OUTER SPHERE, KELVIN E1 = 0.5 ! EMISSIVITY ON INNER SPHERE E2 = 0.4 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTER SPHERE STFCONST = 5.67E-8 T0 = 0. _GEOM=0 *IF,_GEOM,EQ,1,THEN ET,1,PLANE77 ! 2D AXISYMMETRIC THERMAL ELEMENT KEYOPT,1,3,1 ! AXISYMMETRIC ELEMENT BEHAVIOR MP,DENS,1,.27 ! DENSITY MP,KXX,1,1 ! THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY MP,C,1,1 ! SPECIFIC HEAT CYL4,,,R0,-90,R1,90 CYL4,,,R2,-90,R3,90 TYPE,1 MAT,1 MSHAPE,0,2D MSHKEY,1 LSEL,S,LINE,,2,10,2 LESIZE,ALL,,,2 ESIZE,0.2 AMESH,ALL ! GENERATING PLANE77 AXISYMMETRIC ELEMENTS LSEL,S,LINE,,3 NSLL,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T1 ! TEMPERATURE ON INTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE LSEL,S,LINE,,5 NSLL,S,1 D,ALL,TEMP,T2 ! TEMPERATURE ON EXTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE RDEC,,0.5,,OPTI RSYMM,,0,CEXT,40,,0,360 LSEL,S,LINE,,1 NSLL,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,E1,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON INTERIOR CIRCULAR SURFACE RDEC,,,,OPTI RSURF LSEL,S,LINE,,7 NSLL,S,1 SF,ALL,RDSF,E2,1 ! EMISSIVITY ON OUTER CIRCULAR SURFACE RDEC,,0.5,,OPTI RSURF ALLSEL,ALL CDWRITE,DB,VM230-3,CDB *ELSE SHPP,OFF CDREAD,DB,VM230-3,CDB *ENDIF STEF,STFCONST TOFFST,T0 FINISH /AUX12 RADOPT,,0.0001,,,0.1,0.1 V2DOPT,1,90,,1000 VFSM,,1,2 VFOPT,NEW /OUT,SCRATCH /COM, /COM, ------ COMPUTE VIEW FACTORS FOR 2D-2D CONCENTRIC SPHERES ------ /COM, ESEL,S,TYPE,,2 CM,IN1,ELEM ESEL,S,TYPE,,3 CM,OUT1,ELEM ALLSEL,ALL VFQUERY,IN1,IN1 *GET,F11_2D2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,IN1,OUT1 *GET,F12_2D2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,IN1 *GET,F21_2D2D,RAD,,VFAVG VFQUERY,OUT1,OUT1 *GET,F22_2D2D,RAD,,VFAVG ALLSEL,ALL /SOLUTION ANTYPE,STATIC /OUT,SCRATCH TIME,1 DELTIM,0.5 OUTRES,ALL,ALL CNVTOL,HEAT,1.E-2,,,1.E-5 SOLVE FINI /POST1 SET,LAST /OUT *GET,TI,NODE,NODE(1,0,0),TEMP *GET,TO,NODE,NODE(2,0,0),TEMP *GET,HFI2,NODE,NODE(1,0,0),TF,SUM ! INSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX *GET,HFO2,NODE,NODE(2,0,0),TF,SUM ! OUTSIDE CIRCLE HEAT FLUX HFIEXP2 = ABS((TI+T0)**4-(TO+T0)**4)*STFCONST/(1/E1+(R1**2/R2**2)*(1/E2-1)) HFOEXP2 = ABS(-R1**2/R2**2)*HFIEXP2 HFIERR2 = HFI2/HFIEXP2 HFOERR2 = HFO2/HFOEXP2 /OUT,SCRATCH *DIM,VALUE2D2D,,6,3 *VFILL,VALUE2D2D(1,1),DATA,0.000,1.000,0.250,0.750,HFIEXP2,HFOEXP2 *VFILL,VALUE2D2D(1,2),DATA,F11_2D2D,F12_2D2D,F21_2D2D,F22_2D2D,HFI2,HFO2 *VFILL,VALUE2D2D(1,3),DATA,0.000,F12_2D2D/1.000,F21_2D2D/0.250,F22_2D2D/0.750,HFIERR2,HFOERR2 *DIM,LABEL2D2D,CHAR,10,2 LABEL2D2D(1,1) = 'VF(1-1)','VF(1-2)','VF(2-1)','VF(2-2)','HFINSIDE','HFOUTSIDE' ALLSEL,ALL SAVE,TABLE_3 FINISH /OUT,vm230,vrt /COM, /COM, -------------------- VM230 RESULTS COMPARISON ---------------------- /COM, /COM, | TARGET | MECHANICAL APDL | RATIO /COM, /COM, /COM, ******************************************************************* /COM, ***RADIATION BETWEEN 2D-2D AND 3D-3D MODEL IN SAME PREPROCESSOR**** /COM, ******************************************************************** /NOPR RESUME,TABLE_1 /GOPR /COM, /COM, USING PLANE77 AND SURF251 ELEMENTS /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL2D(1,1),LABEL2D(1,2),VALUE2D(1,1),VALUE2D(1,2),VALUE2D(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F8.3,' ',F14.3,' ',1F17.2) /COM, /COM, USING SOLID90 AND SURF252 ELEMENTS /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL3D(1,1),LABEL3D(1,2),VALUE3D(1,1),VALUE3D(1,2),VALUE3D(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F8.3,' ',F14.3,' ',1F17.2) /COM, /COM, /COM, ************************************* /COM, ***RADIATION BETWEEN 3D-2D MODEL **** /COM, ************************************* /COM, /NOPR RESUME,TABLE_2 /GOPR /COM, /COM, USING PLANE77, SOLID90 AND SURF252 /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL3D2D(1,1),LABEL3D2D(1,2),VALUE3D2D(1,1),VALUE3D2D(1,2),VALUE3D2D(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F8.3,' ',F14.3,' ',1F17.2) /COM, /COM, /COM, /COM, ************************************* /COM, ***RADIATION BETWEEN 2D-2D MODEL **** /COM, ************************************* /COM, /NOPR RESUME,TABLE_3 /GOPR /COM, /COM, USING PLANE77 AND SURF252 /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL2D2D(1,1),LABEL2D2D(1,2),VALUE2D2D(1,1),VALUE2D2D(1,2),VALUE2D2D(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F8.3,' ',F14.3,' ',1F17.2) /COM, /COM, --------------------------------------------------------------------- /OUT, *LIST,vm230,vrt FINISH