VM7VM7
Plastic Compression of a Pipe Assembly
Test Case
Two coaxial tubes, the inner one of 1020 CR steel and cross-sectional
area As, and the outer one of 2024-T4 aluminum
alloy and of area Aa, are compressed between
heavy, flat end plates, as shown below. Determine the load-deflection
curve of the assembly as it is compressed into the plastic region
by an axial displacement. Assume that the end plates are so stiff
that both tubes are shortened by exactly the same amount.
Analysis Assumptions and Modeling Notes
The following tube dimensions, which provide the desired cross-sectional
areas, are arbitrarily chosen. Inner (steel) tube: inside radius
= 1.9781692 in., wall thickness = 0.5 in. Outer (aluminum) tube: inside
radius = 3.5697185 in., wall thickness = 0.5 in.
The problem can be solved in three ways:
using PIPE288 - the plastic
straight pipe element
using SOLID185 - the 3-D
structural solid element
using SHELL181 - the 4-Node
Finite Strain Shell
In the SOLID185 and SHELL181 cases, since the problem is axisymmetric, only a one element Θ-sector
is modeled. A small angle Θ = 6° is arbitrarily chosen
to reasonably approximate the circular boundary with straight sided
elements. The nodes at the boundaries have the UX (radial) degree
of freedom coupled. In the SHELL181 model,
the nodes at the boundaries additionally have the ROTY degree of freedom
coupled.
Results Comparison
From POST1 FSUM of bottom nodal
forces (ΣFZ) for PIPE288 model.
From POST1 FSUM of bottom nodal
forces (ΣFZ) X 360°/6°(Identified as parameter "LOAD")
for SOLID185 and SHELL181 models.