/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /VERIFY,VM7 /PREP7 /TITLE, VM7, PLASTIC COMPRESSION OF A PIPE ASSEMBLY C*** MECHANICS OF SOLIDS, CRANDALL AND DAHL, 1959, PAGE 180, EX. 5.1 C*** USING PIPE288, SOLID185 AND SHELL181 ELEMENTS THETA=6 ! SUBTENDED ANGLE ET,1,PIPE288,,,,2 ET,2,SOLID185 ET,3,SHELL181,,,2 ! FULL INTEGRATION SECTYPE,1,SHELL SECDATA,0.5,1,0,5 ! THICKNESS (SHELL181) SECTYPE,2,SHELL SECDATA,0.5,2,0,5 ! THICKNESS (SHELL181) SECTYPE,3,PIPE SECDATA,4.9563384,0.5 ! OUTSIDE DIA. AND WALL THICKNESS FOR INSIDE TUBE (PIPE288) SECTYPE,4,PIPE SECDATA,8.139437,0.5 ! OUTSIDE DIA. AND WALL THICKNESS FOR OUTSIDE TUBE (PIPE288) MP,EX ,1,26.875E6 ! STEEL MP,PRXY,1,0.3 MP,EX ,2,11E6 ! ALUMINUM MP,PRXY,2,0.3 TB,BKIN,1,1 ! DEFINE NON-LINEAR MATERIAL PROPERTY FOR STEEL TBTEMP,0 TBDATA,1,86000,0 TB,BKIN,2,1 ! DEFINE NON-LINEAR MATERIAL PROPERTY FOR ALUMINUM TBTEMP,0 TBDATA,1,55000,0 N,1 ! GENERATE NODES AND ELEMENTS FOR PIPE288 N,2,,,10 MAT,1 SECNUM,3 ! STEEL (INSIDE) TUBE E,1,2 MAT,2 SECNUM,4 ! ALUMINUM (OUTSIDE) TUBE E,1,2 CSYS,1 N,101,1.9781692 ! GENERATE NODES AND ELEMENTS FOR SOLID185 N,102,2.4781692 N,103,3.5697185 N,104,4.0697185 N,105,1.9781692,,10 N,106,2.4781692,,10 N,107,3.5697185,,10 N,108,4.0697185,,10 NGEN,2,10,101,108,,,THETA ! GENERATE 2ND SET OF NODES TO FORM A THETA DEGREE SLICE NROTAT,101,118,1 TYPE,2 MAT,1 ! INSIDE (STEEL) TUBE E,101,102,112,111,105,106,116,115 MAT,2 ! OUTSIDE (ALUMINUM) TUBE E,103,104,114,113,107,108,118,117 N,201,2.2281692 ! GENERATE NODES AND ELEMENTS FOR SHELL181 N,203,2.2281692,,10 N,202,3.8197185 N,204,3.8197185,,10 NGEN,2,4,201,204,,,THETA ! GENERATE NODES TO FORM A THETA DEGREE SLICE TYPE,3 SECNUM,1 ! INSIDE (STEEL) TUBE E,203,201,205,207 SECNUM,2 ! OUTSIDE (ALUMINUM) TUBE E,204,202,206,208 C*** APPLY CONSTRAINTS TO PIPE288 MODEL D,1,ALL ! FIX ALL DOFS FOR BOTTOM END OF PIPE288 D,2,UX,,,,,UY,ROTX,ROTY,ROTZ ! ALLOW ONLY UZ DOF AT TOP END OF PIPE288 MODEL C*** APPLY CONSTRAINTS TO SOLID185 AND SHELL181 MODELS CP,1,UX,101,111,105,115 ! COUPLE NODES AT BOUNDARY IN RADIAL DIR FOR SOLID185 CPSGEN,4,,1 CP,5,UX,201,205,203,207 ! COUPLE NODES AT BOUNDARY IN RADIAL DIR FOR SHELL181 CPSGEN,2,,5 CP,7,ROTY,201,205 ! COUPLE NODES AT BOUNDARY IN ROTY DIR FOR SHELL181 CPSGEN,4,,7 NSEL,S,NODE,,101,212 ! SELECT ONLY NODES IN SOLID185 AND SHELL181 MODELS NSEL,R,LOC,Y,0 ! SELECT NODES AT THETA = 0 FROM THE SELECTED SET DSYM,SYMM,Y,1 ! APPLY SYMMETRY BOUNDARY CONDITIONS NSEL,S,NODE,,101,212 ! SELECT ONLY NODES IN SOLID185 AND SHELL181 MODELS NSEL,R,LOC,Y,THETA ! SELECT NODES AT THETA FROM THE SELECTED SET DSYM,SYMM,Y,1 ! APPLY SYMMETRY BOUNDARY CONDITIONS NSEL,ALL NSEL,R,LOC,Z,0 ! SELECT ONLY NODES AT Z = 0 D,ALL,UZ,0 ! CONSTRAIN BOTTOM NODES IN Z DIRECTION NSEL,ALL FINISH /SOLU OUTPR,BASIC,LAST ! PRINT BASIC SOLUTION AT END OF LOAD STEP C*** APPLY DISPLACEMENT LOADS TO ALL MODELS *CREATE,DISP NSEL,R,LOC,Z,10 ! SELECT NODES AT Z = 10 TO APPLY DISPLACEMENT D,ALL,UZ,ARG1 NSEL,ALL /OUT,SCRATCH SOLVE *END *USE,DISP,-.032 *USE,DISP,-.05 *USE,DISP,-.1 FINISH /OUT, /POST1 C*** CREATE MACRO TO GET RESULTS FOR EACH MODEL *CREATE,GETLOAD NSEL,S,NODE,,1,2 ! SELECT NODES IN PIPE288 MODEL NSEL,R,LOC,Z,0 /OUT,SCRATCH FSUM ! FZ IS TOTAL LOAD FOR PIPE288 MODEL *GET,LOAD_288,FSUM,,ITEM,FZ NSEL,S,NODE,,101,118 ! SELECT NODES IN SOLID185 MODEL NSEL,R,LOC,Z,0 FSUM *GET,ZFRC,FSUM,0,ITEM,FZ LOAD=ZFRC*360/THETA ! MULTIPLY BY 360/THETA FOR FULL 360 DEGREE RESULTS *STATUS,LOAD LOAD_185 = LOAD NSEL,S,NODE,,201,212 ! SELECT NODES IN SHELL181 MODEL NSEL,R,LOC,Z,0 FSUM /OUT, *GET,ZFRC,FSUM,0,ITEM,FZ LOAD=ZFRC*360/THETA ! MULTIPLY BY 360/THETA FOR FULL 360 DEGREE RESULTS *STATUS,LOAD LOAD_181 = LOAD *VFILL,VALUE_288(1,1),DATA,1024400,1262000,1262000 *VFILL,VALUE_288(I,2),DATA,ABS(LOAD_288) *VFILL,VALUE_288(I,3),DATA,ABS(LOAD_288)/(VALUE_288(I,1)) *VFILL,VALUE_185(1,1),DATA,1024400,1262000,1262000 *VFILL,VALUE_185(J,2),DATA,ABS(LOAD_185) *VFILL,VALUE_185(J,3),DATA,ABS(LOAD_185)/(VALUE_185(J,1)) *VFILL,VALUE_181(1,1),DATA,1024400,1262000,1262000 *VFILL,VALUE_181(K,2),DATA,ABS(LOAD_181) *VFILL,VALUE_181(K,3),DATA,ABS(LOAD_181)/(VALUE_181(K,1)) *END C*** GET TOTAL LOAD FOR DISPLACEMENT = 0.032 C*** --------------------------------------- SET,1,1 I = 1 J = 1 K = 1 *DIM,LABEL,CHAR,3,2 *DIM,VALUE_288,,3,3 *DIM,VALUE_185,,3,3 *DIM,VALUE_181,,3,3 *USE,GETLOAD C*** GET TOTAL LOAD FOR DISPLACEMENT = 0.05 C*** -------------------------------------- SET,2,1 I = I + 1 J = J + 1 K = K + 1 *USE,GETLOAD C*** GET TOTAL LOAD FOR DISPLACEMENT = 0.1 C*** ------------------------------------- SET,3,1 I = I +1 J = J + 1 K = K + 1 *USE,GETLOAD LABEL(1,1) = 'LOAD, lb','LOAD, lb','LOAD, lb' LABEL(1,2) = ' UX=.032',' UX=0.05',' UX=0.10' FINISH /OUT,vm7,vrt /COM,------------------- VM7 RESULTS COMPARISON --------------------- /COM, /COM, | TARGET | Mechanical APDL | RATIO /COM, /COM,RESULTS FOR PIPE288: /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL(1,1),LABEL(1,2),VALUE_288(1,1),VALUE_288(1,2),VALUE_288(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F10.0,' ',F14.0,' ',1F15.3) /COM, /COM,RESULTS FOR SOLID185: /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL(1,1),LABEL(1,2),VALUE_185(1,1),VALUE_185(1,2),VALUE_185(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F10.0,' ',F14.0,' ',1F15.3) /COM, /COM,RESULTS FOR SHELL181: /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL(1,1),LABEL(1,2),VALUE_181(1,1),VALUE_181(1,2),VALUE_181(1,3) (1X,A8,A8,' ',F10.0,' ',F14.0,' ',1F15.3) /COM, /COM,----------------------------------------------------------------- /OUT *LIST,vm7,vrt