Benchmark C2VMC2
Elliptic Membrane Under a Uniformly Load
Test Case
An elliptic membrane structure of thickness t is subjected to a uniformly
distributed outward pressure P. Monitor the tangential edge stress σy at
target point 1 for a series of uniform mesh refinements using quadrilateral
and triangular elements. Compare the effect of increased mesh refinement
with the percent energy error norm.
Results Tables
Target Solution: SY = 92.7 MPa Results Comparison - Quadrilateral Meshing
Assumptions, Modeling Notes, and Solution Comments
From an element performance standpoint, the problem is designed
to test membrane elements for accurate modeling of the strain variation, nodal
stress extrapolation, and curved boundary modeling (of higher order elements).
From a modeling standpoint, the problem is designed to test
quadrilateral and triangular meshes for solution accuracy with various element
types. For the areas modeled, all exterior line segment specifications for
mesh density are made equal for the various mesh options.
For quadrilateral and triangle element meshes under uniform mesh refinement (parameters N1 and
N2 varied), the calculated percent error in energy norm follows a log-log linear relationship
to the number of degrees of freedom in the model. The higher order element
(PLANE183) exhibits nearly identical log-log slopes while the lower
order element (PLANE182) exhibits a more gradual slope. These results
illustrate that the PLANE183 solutions converge at nearly the same
rate under uniform refinement while PLANE183 converges at a slower
rate. The percent error in energy norm results indicate that global accuracy is best obtained
by PLANE82 for any given DOF set. However, the
σy stress at target point 1 shows that for uniform refinement,
PLANE182 gives better results (at that point) under moderate mesh
refinement. A fine mesh using PLANE183 in place of a coarse mesh of
PLANE183 may produce better localized stress values.