Benchmark C3VMC3
Barrel Vault Roof Under Self Weight
Test Case
A cylindrical shell roof is subjected to gravity loading. The
roof is supported by walls at each end and is free along the sides.
Monitor the y displacement and bottom axial stress (σz) at target point 1, along with the bottom circumferential
stress (σθ) at target point 2
for a series of test cases with increasing mesh refinement using quadrilateral
and triangular element shapes. A companion problem that studies irregular
element shapes is VMD2.
Target Solution
Target solution is obtained from an 8-node quadrilateral shell
element solution with N=8, (see
R. D. Cook, Concepts and Applications of
Finite Element Analysis).
Assumptions, Modeling Notes, and Solution Comments
The problem is designed to test singly-curved shell
elements under membrane and bending deformation. The quadrilateral
mesh patterns produce uniform rectangular shapes while the triangle
mesh patterns are as generated by the meshing algorithm in the solid
modeler.
Results for SHELL181 in triangular
form are presented, though they are not recommended for use. SHELL181 is based on a hybrid formulation for a quadrilateral
element shape. Hence, degeneration of the element to a triangular
shape will show some slight node-ordering dependence on the element
solution.
The target solution is obtained in the prescribed
reference for the author's 8-node shell element.
As expected, the quadratic SHELL281 performs better than the linear
element SHELL181 for comparable meshes.
Results for the linear triangular-shaped elements
is poor due to the constant-strain membrane behavior within the element.
The effect of constant-strain membrane behavior is to overly stiffen
the element under this type of loading, hence underpredicting both
displacement and stresses. For triangular elements, only a fine mesh
using the quadratic SHELL281 elements produces
acceptable results.