Benchmark D2VMD2
Barrel Vault Roof Under Self Weight
Test Case
A cylindrical shell roof is subjected to gravity loading. The
roof is supported by walls at each end and is free along the sides.
Monitor the y-displacement and bottom axial stress (σz) at target point 1 along with the bottom circumference
stress (σθ) at target point 2
for a series of test cases with varying skew angle β for each
element type. A companion problem that studies uniform element mesh
refinement is VMC3.
Representative Mesh Options
Target Solution
Target solution is obtained using a uniform 8 x 8 quadrilateral
mesh of an 8-node quadrilateral shell element, (see R. D. Cook, Concepts and Applications of Finite Element Analysis).
Results Comparison - Quadrilateral Elements
Assumptions, Modeling Notes, and Solution Comments
The problem is designed to test singly-curved shell
elements under combined membrane and bending deformation. The solid
model is set up to produce irregular element shapes for quadrilateral
elements. The angle β is prescribed, while the angle α is calculated from the resulting
geometry. The range of β is set such that all element interior
angles fall within 90° ± 45°.
The target solution is obtained from the author's
8-node shell element, (see R. D. Cook, Concepts
and Applications of Finite Element Analysis), under a
uniform rectangular element geometry using an 8 x 8 mesh pattern.
Results for uniform quadrilateral element shapes are
noted in the tabular and graphical output for β = 90° and
should be used as a basis for comparison of distorted element performance.
Displacement results over the range of element distortion vary the greatest for
SHELL181. In this problem, SHELL281 predict
the displacements more accurately for mild element geometry distortion.
Axial (σz) stress results, over the range of element distortion,
show some variation for SHELL181, and
SHELL281 elements. Hoop (σθ)
stress results are less affected by irregular element shapes except at the extreme β angle
range.