/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /verify,vm-nr1677-2-2a-a /title,vm-nr1677-2-2a-a,NRC piping benchmarks problems,Volume II, Problem 2a /com, *************************************************************************** /com, Reference: Piping benchmark problems,Dynamic analysis independant support /com, motion response spectrum method, P. Bezler, M. Subudhi and /com, M.Hartzman, NUREG/CR--1677-Vol.2, August 1985. /com, /com, /com, Elements used: Pipe16, Pipe18, Combin14 and Mass21 /com, /com, Results comparsion: /com, The following results are compared against NRC piping benchmark values /com, 1. Frequencies obtained from modal solution. /com, 2. Maximum nodal displacements and rotations obtained from spectrum solution. /com, 3. Element forces/moments obtained from spectrum solution. /com, 4. Reaction forces obtained from spectrum solution. /com, /com, ******************************************************************************* /out,scratch /prep7 YoungModulus1 = .240e+8 ! Young's Modulus Nu = 0.3 ! Minor Poisson's Ratio ShearModulus1 = YoungModulus1/(2*(1+Nu)) ! Shear Modulus WMass=0.001056893 ! Density WTick=0.241 ! Wall Thickness k=0.71e-5 OD=7.288 ! Outer Diameter RADCUR=36.30 ! Radius of Curvature temp=80 ! Temperature maxm=25 ! No. of Modes to Extract et,1,pipe16 ! Element 1 - PIPE16 et,2,pipe18 ! Element 2 - PIPE18 et,3,combin14 ! Element 3 - COMBIN14 keyopt,3,2,1 ! X Degree of Freedom et,4,combin14 ! Element 4 - COMBIN14 keyopt,4,2,2 ! Y Degree of Freedom et,5,combin14 ! Element 5 - COMBIN14 keyopt,5,2,3 ! Z Degree of Freedom et,6,mass21 ! Element 6 - MASS21 keyopt,6,3,2 ! 3D mass without inertia /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, Real Constants /com,**************** r, 1, OD, WTick r, 2, OD, WTick, RADCUR r, 3, 0.1e+5 r, 4, 0.1e+9 r, 5, 0.1e+11 r, 6, 1.518 /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, Material Properties /com,********************* mp,ex, 1, YoungModulus1 mp,nuxy,1, Nu mp,gxy ,1, ShearModulus1 mp,dens,1, WMass mp,kxx,1, k mp,ex, 2, YoungModulus1 mp,nuxy,2, Nu mp,gxy ,2, ShearModulus1 mp,dens,2, WMass mp,kxx,2, K /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, Nodes /com,******* n,1,0,0,0 n,2,0,54.45,0 n,3,0,108.9,0 n,4,10.632,134.568,0 n,5,36.3,145.2,0 n,6,54.15,145.2,0 n,7,72.0,145.2,0 n,8,97.668,145.2,10.632 n,9,108.3,145.2,36.3 n,10,108.3,145.2,56.8 n,11,108.3,145.2,77.3 n,12,108.3,145.2,97.8 n,13,108.3,145.2,118.3 n,14,108.3,145.2,188.8 n,15,108.3,181.5,225.1 n,16,108.3,236,225.1 n,17,108.3,290,225.1 n,18,148.3,145.2,97.8 n,19,188.3,145.2,97.8 n,20,224.6,145.2,61.5 n,21,224.6,145.2,20 /com, /com, Elastic Support Nodes /com,*********************** n,22,1,0,0 n,23,0,1,0 n,24,0,0,1 n,25,72,145.2,-1 n,26,109.3,145.2,36.3 n,27,108.3,146.2,77.3 n,28,108.3,146.2,118.3 n,29,107.3,182.5,226.5 n,30,109.3,290,225.1 n,31,108.3,291,225.1 n,32,108.3,290,226.1 n,33,225.6,145.2,20 n,34,224.6,146.2,20 n,35,224.6,145.2,21 /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /com, Straight Pipe (Tangent) Elements /com,********************************** mat,1 ! Material ID 1 type,1 ! Element Type 1 real,1 ! Real Constant Set 1 en, 1, 1, 2 en, 2, 2, 3 en, 5, 5, 6 en, 6, 6, 7 en, 9, 9,10 en,10,10,11 en,11,11,12 en,12,12,13 en,13,13,14 en,15,15,16 en,16,16,17 en,17,12,18 en,18,18,19 en,20,20,21 /com, /com, Pipe Bend Elements /com,******************** mat,2 type,2 real,2 en, 3, 3, 4, 2 en, 4, 4, 5, 6 en, 7, 7, 8, 6 en, 8, 8, 9,10 en,14,14,15,16 en,19,19,20,18 /com, /com, Elastic Supports and Anchors /com,****************************** ! rotate nodes with less than 3 supports wplane,,nx(15),ny(15),nz(15),nx(29),ny(29),nz(29),nx(16),ny(16),nz(16) cswplane,11,0 nrotat,15 nrotat,29 csys,0 real,3 ! 0.1e+5 type,4 ! local y e,11,27 e,13,28 real,4 ! 0.1e+9 type,3 !local x e,9,26 e,15,29 type,5 !local z e,7,25 real,5 ! 0.1e+11 type,3 !local x e,1,22 e,17,30 e,21,33 type,4 ! local y e,1,23 e,17,31 e,21,34 type,5 ! local z e,1,24 e,17,32 e,21,35 /com /com, Mass Elements /com,*************** type,6 real,6 e,18 /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /com, Constraints /com,************* nsel,,node,,22,35 d,all,all allsel d,1,rotx,,,,,roty,rotz d,21,rotx,,,,,roty,rotz allsel,all /com, Loading /com,********* /com, **Internal Pressure on PIPE elements** esel,s,ename,,18 esel,a,ename,,16 sfe,all,1,pres,,350 allsel,all save finish /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /com,============= /com, Modal Solve /com,============= /com, /solution antype,modal ! Perform Modal Analysis modopt,lanb,maxm lumpm,on ! Use Lumped Mass Matrix Approximation mxpand,maxm,,,yes ! Expand Solutions with Element Calculations ON solve save /com, /com,=========================== /com, Compare Modal Frequencies /com,=========================== /com, *dim,Amode,ARRAY,maxm *dim,Emode,ARRAY,maxm *dim,ERmode,ARRAY,maxm *dim,moden,ARRAY,maxm *do,i,1,maxm *GET, Amode(i), MODE, i, FREQ *enddo *VFILL,Emode,DATA,9.36,12.706,15.377,17.797,21.603,25.098,32.035,38.069,40.293,48.898 *VFILL,Emode(11),DATA,57.515,61.5,62.541,69.348,77.444,78.881,101.715,103.583,107.966,115.098 *VFILL,Emode(21),DATA,135.244,155.22,160.601,203.789,209.925, *do,i,1,maxm ERmode(i)=ABS(Amode(i)/Emode(i)) moden(i)=i *enddo save,table_1 finish /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /com,================ /com, Spectrum Solve /com,================ /com, /solution antype,spectr ! Perform Spectrum Analysis spopt,sprs,maxm ! Single Point Excitation Response Spectrum srss,0.0 gval = 386.4 /com, /com, spectrum 1 (X) /com,**************** svtyp, 2, gval freq,0.4,0.630119723,0.64516129,1.124985938,1.374948439,1.705029838,2.420135528,2.750275028,3.41997264 SV,,2.7,0.814,0.81,4.15,4.15,2.4,1.7,1.46,1.6, freq,4.679457183,5.720823799,6.600660066,9.900990099,15.12859304,16.50165017,39.0625 sv,,2.05,2.05,1.75,0.9,0.77,0.65,0.65,, sed,1,0,0 ! Excitation in X direction solve /com, /com, spectrum 2 (Y) - coef 1 /com,************************* svtyp, 2, gval freq FREQ,0.4,0.740740741,1.124985938,1.374948439,1.759943682,2.474634991,3.571428571,5.399568035,6.600660066 SV,,0.34,1.15,2.87,2.87,1.5,0.9,0.87,1.32,1.32 FREQ,8.802816901,10.20408163,15.50387597,39.0625 Sv,,0.73,0.55,0.37,0.37 sed,0,1,0 ! Excitation in Y direction solve /com /com, spectrum 2 (Z) - coef 1 /com,************************* svtyp, 2, gval freq FREQ,0.4,0.689655172,1.124985938,1.374948439,1.766160367,2.699784017,4.500450045,5.500550055,6.501950585 SV,,0.34,1.06,3.55,3.55,1.95,1.08,1.38,1.38,1.3 FREQ,7.974481659,13.00390117,17.51313485,39.0625 SV,,1,0.65,0.55,0.55 sed,0,0,1 ! Excitation in Z direction solve finish /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /post1 /input,,mcom /com,----------------------------------- /com, *Labels* *dim,label2,char,1,6 *dim,label3,char,6,1 *dim,label4,char,6,1 *dim,label5,char,5,1 /com,------------------------- label2(1,1) = 'ux_14' label2(1,2) = 'uy_8' label2(1,3) = 'uz_4' label2(1,4) ='rotx_3' label2(1,5) ='roty_7' label2(1,6) ='rotz_17' /com,----------------------- label3(1,1)='PX(I)' label3(2,1)='VY(I)' label3(3,1)='VZ(I)' label3(4,1)='TX(I)' label3(5,1)='MY(I)' label3(6,1)='MZ(I)' /com,----------------------- label4(1,1)='PX(J)' label4(2,1)='VY(J)' label4(3,1)='VZ(J)' label4(4,1)='TX(J)' label4(5,1)='MY(J)' label4(6,1)='MZ(J)' /com,------------------------- label5(1,1)='23' label5(2,1)='26' label5(3,1)='28' label5(4,1)='33' label5(5,1)='34' /com,----------------------------------- /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /com,======================================================== /com, Maximum nodal displacements and rotations comparsion /com,======================================================== /com, /com, Solution obtained from Mechanical APDL /com, **************************** *GET,AdisX,NODE,14,U,X *GET,AdisY,NODE,8,U,Y *GET,AdisZ,NODE,4,U,Z *GET,ArotX,NODE,3,ROT,X *GET,ArotY,NODE,7,ROT,Y *GET,ArotZ,NODE,17,ROT,Z /com, /com, Expected results from NRC manual /com, ********************************* *SET,EdisX,8.49378e-02 *SET,EdisY,3.79278e-02 *SET,EdisZ,9.07052e-02 *SET,ErotX,1.02681e-03 *SET,ErotY,1.89200e-03 *SET,ErotZ,9.07075e-04 /com, /com, Error computation /com,******************** ERdisX=ABS(AdisX/EdisX) ERdisY=ABS(AdisY/EdisY) ERdisZ=ABS(AdisZ/EdisZ) ERrotX=ABS((ArotX)/(ErotX)) ERrotY=ABS((ArotY)/(ErotY)) ERrotZ=ABS((ArotZ)/(ErotZ)) *dim,value,,6,3 *vfill,value(1,1),data,EdisX *vfill,value(1,2),data,AdisX *vfill,value(1,3),data,ERdisX *vfill,value(2,1),data,EdisY *vfill,value(2,2),data,AdisY *vfill,value(2,3),data,ERdisY *vfill,value(3,1),data,EdisZ *vfill,value(3,2),data,AdisZ *vfill,value(3,3),data,ERdisZ *vfill,value(4,1),data,ErotX *vfill,value(4,2),data,ArotX *vfill,value(4,3),data,ERrotX *vfill,value(5,1),data,ErotY *vfill,value(5,2),data,ArotY *vfill,value(5,3),data,ERrotY *vfill,value(6,1),data,ErotZ *vfill,value(6,2),data,ArotZ *vfill,value(6,3),data,ERrotZ save,table_2 /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com,======================================================== /com, Element Forces and Moments Comparison /com,======================================================== /com, Solution obtained from Mechanical APDL /com,****************************** *dim,elem_res_I,,3,6 *dim,elem_res_J,,3,6 *dim,pxi,,3 *dim,vyi,,3 *dim,vzi,,3 *dim,txi,,3 *dim,myi,,3 *dim,mzi,,3 *dim,pxj,,3 *dim,vyj,,3 *dim,vzj,,3 *dim,txj,,3 *dim,myj,,3 *dim,mzj,,3 esel,s,ename,,16 esel,a,ename,,18 /com,========== /com, Node I /com,========== /com, Element #1 /com,*********** *get,pxi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,1 *get,vyi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,2 *get,vzi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,3 *get,txi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,4 *get,myi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,5 *get,mzi(1,1),elem,1,smisc,6 *vfill,elem_res_I(1,1),data,pxi(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(1,2),data,vyi(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(1,3),data,vzi(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(1,4),data,txi(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(1,5),data,myi(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(1,6),data,mzi(1,1) /com, Element #20 /com,************* *get,pxi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,1 *get,vyi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,2 *get,vzi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,3 *get,txi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,4 *get,myi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,5 *get,mzi(2,1),elem,20,smisc,6 *vfill,elem_res_I(2,1),data,pxi(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(2,2),data,vyi(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(2,3),data,vzi(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(2,4),data,txi(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(2,5),data,myi(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(2,6),data,mzi(2,1) /com, Element #8 /com,************* *get,pxi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,1 *get,vyi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,2 *get,vzi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,3 *get,txi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,4 *get,myi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,5 *get,mzi(3,1),elem,8,smisc,6 *vfill,elem_res_I(3,1),data,pxi(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(3,2),data,vyi(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(3,3),data,vzi(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(3,4),data,txi(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(3,5),data,myi(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_I(3,6),data,mzi(3,1) /com,========== /com, Node J /com,========== /com, Element #1 /com,************ *get,pxj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,7 *get,vyj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,8 *get,vzj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,9 *get,txj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,10 *get,myj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,11 *get,mzj(1,1),elem,1,smisc,12 *vfill,elem_res_J(1,1),data,pxj(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(1,2),data,vyj(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(1,3),data,vzj(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(1,4),data,txj(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(1,5),data,myj(1,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(1,6),data,mzj(1,1) /com, Element #20 /com,************* *get,pxj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,7 *get,vyj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,8 *get,vzj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,9 *get,txj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,10 *get,myj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,11 *get,mzj(2,1),elem,20,smisc,12 *vfill,elem_res_J(2,1),data,pxj(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(2,2),data,vyj(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(2,3),data,vzj(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(2,4),data,txj(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(2,5),data,myj(2,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(2,6),data,mzj(2,1) /com, Element #8 /com,************* *get,pxj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,7 *get,vyj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,8 *get,vzj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,9 *get,txj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,10 *get,myj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,11 *get,mzj(3,1),elem,8,smisc,12 *vfill,elem_res_J(3,1),data,pxj(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(3,2),data,vyj(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(3,3),data,vzj(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(3,4),data,txj(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(3,5),data,myj(3,1) *vfill,elem_res_J(3,6),data,mzj(3,1) /com,---------------------------------------------------------------------------- /com, Results from NRC benchmarks /com, *************************** *dim,exp_I,,3,6 *dim,exp_J,,3,6 /com, Element #1 /com,************ *vfill,exp_I(1,1),data,6.496e+01 *vfill,exp_I(1,2),data,9.050e+01 *vfill,exp_I(1,3),data,1.774e+02 *vfill,exp_I(1,4),data,5.110e+03 *vfill,exp_I(1,5),data,1.635e+04 *vfill,exp_I(1,6),data,7.002e+03 *vfill,exp_J(1,1),data,6.496e+01 *vfill,exp_J(1,2),data,9.050e+01 *vfill,exp_J(1,3),data,1.774e+02 *vfill,exp_J(1,4),data,5.110e+03 *vfill,exp_J(1,5),data,7.138e+03 *vfill,exp_J(1,6),data,3.188e+03 /com, Element #20 /com,************* *vfill,exp_I(2,1),data,2.451e+02 *vfill,exp_I(2,2),data,1.916e+02 *vfill,exp_I(2,3),data,3.779e+02 *vfill,exp_I(2,4),data,2.314e+03 *vfill,exp_I(2,5),data,3.823e+03 *vfill,exp_I(2,6),data,3.268e+03 *vfill,exp_J(2,1),data,2.451e+02 *vfill,exp_J(2,2),data,1.916e+02 *vfill,exp_J(2,3),data,3.779e+02 *vfill,exp_J(2,4),data,2.314e+03 *vfill,exp_J(2,5),data,1.660e+04 *vfill,exp_j(2,6),data,1.114e+04 /com, Element #8 /com,************* *vfill,exp_I(3,1),data,4.463e+02 *vfill,exp_I(3,2),data,3.256e+01 *vfill,exp_I(3,3),data,5.178e+02 *vfill,exp_I(3,4),data,2.967e+03 *vfill,exp_I(3,5),data,1.202e+04 *vfill,exp_I(3,6),data,7.986e+02 *vfill,exp_J(3,1),data,6.648e+02 *vfill,exp_J(3,2),data,3.256e+01 *vfill,exp_J(3,3),data,1.591e+02 *vfill,exp_J(3,4),data,2.021e+03 *vfill,exp_J(3,5),data,2.052e+04 *vfill,exp_J(3,6),data,2.487e+03 /com,--------------------------------------------------------------------------- /com, Error computation /com, ********************* *dim,elem_error_I,,3,6 *dim,elem_error_J,,3,6 *dim,elem_tab,,36,3 /com,============ /com, Node I /com,============ *do,i,1,3 *do,j,1,6 *vfill,elem_error_I(i,j),data,abs(elem_res_I(i,j)/exp_I(i,j)) *enddo *enddo /com,============ /com, Node J /com,============ *do,i,1,3 *do,j,1,6 *vfill,elem_error_J(i,j),data,abs(elem_res_J(i,j)/exp_J(i,j)) *enddo *enddo /com,-------------------------------------------------------------------------- *do,i,1,3 cs=(i-1)*6 *do,j,1,6 n=cs+j *vfill,elem_tab(n,1),data,exp_I(i,j) *vfill,elem_tab(n,2),data,elem_res_I(i,j) *vfill,elem_tab(n,3),data,elem_error_I(i,j) *enddo *do,j,1,6 m=cs+j+18 *vfill,elem_tab(m,1),data,exp_J(i,j) *vfill,elem_tab(m,2),data,elem_res_J(i,j) *vfill,elem_tab(m,3),data,elem_error_J(i,j) *enddo *enddo save,table_3 /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com,***************************** /com, Reaction forces comparision /com,****************************** *dim,rf_tab,,5,3 /com, Solution obtained from Mechanical APDL /com,****************************** *GET,RFA23,NODE,23,RF,FY *GET,RFA26,NODE,26,RF,FX *GET,RFA28,NODE,28,RF,FY *GET,RFA33,NODE,33,RF,FX *GET,RFA34,NODE,34,RF,FY /com, Expected results from NRC manual /com,********************************** *SET,RFE23,65 *SET,RFE26,446 *SET,RFE28,164 *SET,RFE33,378 *SET,RFE34,192 /com, Error computation /com,******************* ER23=ABS(RFA23/RFE23) ER26=ABS(RFA26/RFE26) ER28=ABS(RFA28/RFE28) ER33=ABS(RFA33/RFE33) ER34=ABS(RFA34/RFE34) *vfill,rf_tab(1,1),data,RFE23 *vfill,rf_tab(1,2),data,RFA23 *vfill,rf_tab(1,3),data,ER23 *vfill,rf_tab(2,1),data,RFE26 *vfill,rf_tab(2,2),data,RFA26 *vfill,rf_tab(2,3),data,ER26 *vfill,rf_tab(3,1),data,RFE28 *vfill,rf_tab(3,2),data,RFA28 *vfill,rf_tab(3,3),data,ER28 *vfill,rf_tab(4,1),data,RFE33 *vfill,rf_tab(4,2),data,RFA33 *vfill,rf_tab(4,3),data,ER33 *vfill,rf_tab(5,1),data,RFE34 *vfill,rf_tab(5,2),data,RFA34 *vfill,rf_tab(5,3),data,ER34 save,table_4 /com, /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /out, /com, /com, ----------------------vm-nr1677-2-2a-a Results Verification--------------------------- /com, /nopr resume,table_1 /gopr, /out,vm-nr1677-2-2a-a,vrt /com, /com, =========================================== /com, COMPARISON OF MODAL FREQUENCY /com, WITH EXPECTED RESULTS /com, =========================================== /com, /com, Mode | Expected | Mechanical APDL | Ratio /com, *VWRITE,moden(1),Emode(1),Amode(1),ERmode(1) (1X,F3.0,2X,F8.4,3X,F8.4,3X,F4.2,' ') /com, /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /com, /nopr resume,table_2 /gopr /com, /com,==================================================== /com, COMPARISON OF NODAL DISPLACEMENTS AND ROTATIONS /com, WITH EXPECTED RESULTS /com,==================================================== /com, /com, Result_Node | Expected | Mechanical APDL | Ratio /com, *vwrite,label2(1,1),value(1,1),value(1,2),value(1,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label2(1,2),value(2,1),value(2,2),value(2,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label2(1,3),value(3,1),value(3,2),value(3,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label2(1,4),value(4,1),value(4,2),value(4,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label2(1,5),value(5,1),value(5,2),value(5,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label2(1,6),value(6,1),value(6,2),value(6,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, /com,------------------------------------------------------------------------- /com, /nopr resume,table_4 /gopr /com, /com, =========================================== /com, COMPARISON OF REACTION FORCES /com, WITH EXPECTED RESULTS /com, =========================================== /com, /com, Node | Expected | Mechanical APDL | Ratio /com, *vwrite,label5(1,1),rf_tab(1,1),rf_tab(1,2),rf_tab(1,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, /com,-------------------------------------------------------------------------- /com, /nopr resume,table_3 /gopr /com, /com,=============================================== /com, COMPARISON OF ELEMENT FORCES AND MOMENTS /com, WITH EXPECTED RESULTS /com,=============================================== /com, /com,------------------------------------------------------ /com, Note: Element Forces and Moments for some elements /com, along Y & Z directions are flipped between Mechanical APDL /com, and NRC results /com,-------------------------------------------------------- /com, Result | Expected | Mechanical APDL | Ratio /com, /com,=============== /com, Element 1 /com,=============== /com, *vwrite,label3(1,1),elem_tab(1,1),elem_tab(1,2),elem_tab(1,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, *vwrite,label4(1,1),elem_tab(19,1),elem_tab(19,2),elem_tab(19,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, /com, /com,=============== /com, Element 20 /com,=============== /com, *vwrite,label3(1,1),elem_tab(7,1),elem_tab(7,2),elem_tab(7,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, *vwrite,label4(1,1),elem_tab(25,1),elem_tab(25,2),elem_tab(25,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, /com, /com,=============== /com, Element 8 /com,=============== /com, *vwrite,label3(1,1),elem_tab(13,1),elem_tab(13,2),elem_tab(13,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, *vwrite,label4(1,1),elem_tab(31,1),elem_tab(31,2),elem_tab(31,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /com, /com, /com,******************************************************************* /com,******************************************************************* /com, /com, /out, *list,vm-nr1677-2-2a-a,vrt finish