/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /verify,vm-nr6645-1-1a-a /title,vm-nr6645-1-1a-a,NRC Piping Benchmark Problems,Volume 1,Method 1 /com,**************************************************************************** /com, /com, Reference: Reevaluation of Regulatory Guidance /com, on modal response combination methods /com, for seismic response spectrum analysis /com, NUREG/CR-6645 /com, R.Morante, Y.Wang /com, December 1999. /com, /com, Description: /com, Response spectrum analysis on BM3 piping model using 14 modes + missing mass /com, /com, Elements used: Pipe16, Pipe18,Combin14 /com, /com, Results comparsion: /com, The following results are compared against NRC piping benchmark values /com, 1. Frequencies obtained from modal solution. /com, 2. Reaction forces obtained from spectrum solution. SRSS, 1% damping /com, /com, Note: /com, The reaction moments are not compared since the rotational degrees of /com, freedom for curved pipe elements are not included in the lumped mass /com, matrix formulation. /com, /com,**************************************************************************** /out,scratch /prep7 youngmodulus = 2.9e+7 ! Young's modulus nu = 0.3 ! Poisson ratio shearmodulus = youngmodulus/(2*(1+nu)) ! Shear modulus et,1,pipe16 ! Pipe 16 r,1,3.500,0.2160 ! Outer dia, wall thickness mp,ex,1,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,1,nu mp,gxy,1,shearmodulus mp,dens,1,1.043e-3 et,2,pipe16 ! Pipe 16 r,2,4.500,0.2370 ! Outer dia, wall thickness mp,ex,2,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,2,nu mp,gxy,2,shearmodulus mp,dens,2,1.107e-03 et,3,pipe16 ! Pipe 16 r,3,8.625,0.3220 ! Outer dia, wall thickness mp,ex,3,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,3,nu mp,gxy,3,shearmodulus mp,dens,3,1.253e-3 et,4,pipe18 ! Pipe 18 r,4,3.500,0.2160,4.500 ! Outer dia, wall thickness, radius of curvature mp,ex,4,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,4,nu mp,gxy,4,shearmodulus mp,dens,4,1.043e-3 et,5,pipe18 ! Pipe 18 r,5,4.500,0.2370,6.000 ! Outer dia, wall thickness, radius of curvature mp,ex,5,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,5,nu mp,gxy,5,shearmodulus mp,dens,5,1.107e-3 et,6,pipe18 ! Pipe 18 r,6,8.625,0.3220,12.000 ! Outer dia, wall thickness, radius of curvature mp,ex,6,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,6,nu mp,gxy,6,shearmodulus mp,dens,6,1.253e-3 et,7,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,7,2,1 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (UX DOF) r,7,1.0e+5 ! Spring constant et,8,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,8,2,2 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (UY DOF) r,8,1.0e+8 ! Spring constant et,9,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,9,2,3 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (Uz DOF) r,9,1.0e+11 ! Spring constant et,10,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,10,2,4 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTX DOF) r,10,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant et,11,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,11,2,5 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTY DOF) r,11,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant et,12,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,12,2,6 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTZ DOF) r,12,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant /com, ******************** /com, Nodes /com, ******************** n, 1, n, 2, 15.000, n, 3, 19.500, -4.500 n, 4, 19.500, -180.000 n, 5, 19.500, -199.500 n, 6, 19.500, -204.000, 4.500 n, 7, 19.500, -204.000, 139.500 n, 8, 24.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 9, 96.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 10, 254.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 11, 333.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 12, 411.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 13, 483.000, -204.000, 144.000 n, 14, 487.500, -204.000, 148.500 n, 15, 487.500, -204.000, 192.000 n, 16, 487.500, -204.000, 235.500 n, 17, 492.000, -204.000, 240.000 n, 18, 575.000, -204.000, 240.000 n, 19, 723.000, -204.000, 240.000 n, 20, 727.500, -208.500, 240.000 n, 21, 727.500, -264.000, 240.000 n, 22, 727.500, -264.000, 205.000 n, 23, 727.500, -264.000, 190.000 n, 24, 733.500, -264.000, 184.000 n, 25, 753.500, -264.000, 184.000 n, 26, 845.500, -264.000, 184.000 n, 27, 851.500, -264.000, 178.000 n, 28, 851.500, -264.000, 160.000 n, 29, 851.500, -264.000, 142.000 n, 30, 851.500, -270.000, 136.000 n, 31, 851.500, -360.000, 136.000 n, 32, 727.500, -264.000, 255.000 n, 33, 727.500, -264.000, 270.000 n, 34, 727.500, -264.000, 306.000 n, 35, 727.500, -264.000, 414.000 n, 36, 739.500, -264.000, 426.000 n, 37, 847.500, -264.000, 426.000 n, 38, 955.500, -264.000, 426.000 /com, ******************** /com, Nodes for curvature /com, ******************** n, 203, 15.000, -4.500 n, 506, 19.500, -199.500, 4.500 n, 708, 24.000, -204.000, 139.500 n,1314, 483.000, -204.000, 148.500 n,1617, 492.000, -204.000, 235.500 n,1920, 723.000, -208.500, 240.000 n,2324, 733.500, -264.000, 190.000 n,2627, 845.500, -264.000, 178.000 n,2930, 851.500, -270.000, 142.000 n,3536, 739.500, -264.000, 414.000 /com, *************************** /com, Nodes for elastic support /com, **************************** dist = 50.0 ! Visualization n,10001, -dist n,20001, , dist n,30001, , , -dist n,10004, 19.500+dist, -180.000 n,30004, 19.500 , -180.000 , -dist n,20007, 19.500 , -204.000+dist, 139.500 n,20011, 333.000 , -204.000+dist, 144.000 n,30011, 333.000 , -204.000 , 144.000-dist n,10015, 487.500-dist, -204.000 , 192.000 n,20017, 492.000 , -204.000-dist, 240.000 n,30017, 492.000 , -204.000 , 240.000-dist n,10023, 727.500-dist, -264.000 , 190.000 n,20023, 727.500 , -264.000+dist, 190.000 n,10031, 851.500+dist, -360.000 , 136.000 n,20031, 851.500 , -360.000-dist, 136.000 n,30031, 851.500 , -360.000 , 136.000-dist n,20036, 739.500 , -264.000-dist, 426.000 n,30036, 739.500 , -264.000 , 426.000-dist n,10038, 955.500+dist, -264.000 , 426.000 n,20038, 955.500 , -264.000-dist, 426.000 n,30038, 955.500 , -264.000 , 426.000-dist /com, ************************* /com, Straight pipe elements /com, ************************* type,1 real,1 mat,1 e, 1, 2 e, 3, 4 e, 4, 5 e, 6, 7 e, 8, 9 e, 9,10 e,10,11 e,11,12 e,12,13 e,14,15 e,15,16 e,17,18 e,18,19 e,20,21 type,2 real,2 mat,2 e,21,22 e,22,23 e,24,25 e,25,26 e,27,28 e,28,29 e,30,31 type,3 real,3 mat,3 e,21,32 e,32,33 e,33,34 e,34,35 e,36,37 e,37,38 /com, ******************** /com, Curved pipe elements /com, ********************* type,4 real,4 mat,4 e,2,3,203 e,5,6,506 e,7,8,708 e,13,14,1314 e,16,17,1617 e,19,20,1920 type,5 real,5 mat,5 e,23,24,2324 e,26,27,2627 e,29,30,2930 type,6 real,6 mat,6 e,35,36,3536 /com, **************************** /com, Elastic supports and anchors /com, **************************** type,7 real,8 e, 4,10004 real,7 e,15,10015 e,23,10023 real,9 e, 1,10001 e,31,10031 e,38,10038 type,8 real,8 e, 7,20007 e,11,20011 e,17,20017 e,23,20023 e,36,20036 real,9 e, 1,20001 e,31,20031 e,38,20038 type,9 real,8 e, 4,30004 real,7 e,11,30011 e,17,30017 e,36,30036 real,9 e, 1,30001 e,31,30031 e,38,30038 type,10 real,10 e, 1,10001 e,31,10031 e,38,10038 type,11 real,10 e, 1,20001 e,31,20031 e,38,20038 type,12 real,10 e, 1,30001 e,31,30031 e,38,30038 /com, *************** /com, Constraints /com, *************** nsel,s,node,,10000,40000 d,all,all,0 allsel,all fini /com, **************** /com, Modal analysis /com, **************** /solu antype,modal modopt,lanb,14 lumpm,on mxpand,14,,,yes solve save *dim,label,,14 *dim,freq_ans,,14 ! Frequencies obtained from Mechanical APDL *dim,freq_exp,,14 ! Frequencies obtained from reference *dim,freq_err,,14 *do,i,1,14 label(i) = i *enddo *do,i,1,14 *get,freq_ans(i),mode,i,freq *enddo *vfill,freq_exp,data,2.91,4.39,5.52,5.70,6.98,7.34,7.88,10.30,11.06,11.23 *vfill,freq_exp(11),data,11.50,12.43,13.88,16.12 *stat,freq_ans *stat,freq_exp *do,i,1,14 freq_err(i) = abs(freq_ans(i))/(freq_exp(i)) *enddo save,table_1 fini /com, ********************** /com, Spectrum analysis /com, ********************** /solu antype,spectrum spopt,sprs,, ! Single point response spectrum solve svtype,2,386.4 ! Seismic acceleration response srss,0.001,disp ! SRSS mode combination, displacement solution sed,1,0,0 ! Excitation in X direction freq , 0.20, 0.30, 0.40, 0.50, 0.60, 0.70, 0.80, 0.90, 1.00 sv, 0.01, 0.06, 0.13, 0.13, 0.20, 0.35, 0.39, 0.37, 0.41, 0.76 freq , 1.10, 1.20, 1.30, 1.40, 1.50, 1.60, 1.70, 1.80, 1.90 sv, 0.01, 0.64, 0.59, 0.91, 1.03, 1.46, 0.95, 0.91, 1.61, 1.92 freq , 2.00, 2.10, 2.20, 2.30, 2.40, 2.50, 2.60, 2.70, 2.80 sv, 0.01, 1.57, 1.18, 2.65, 2.85, 3.26, 4.47, 4.75, 5.29, 7.44 freq , 2.90, 3.00, 3.15, 3.30, 3.45, 3.60, 3.80, 4.00, 4.20 sv, 0.01, 4.27, 4.61, 4.13, 3.96, 4.05, 2.44, 2.09, 2.29, 1.52 freq , 4.40, 4.60, 4.80, 5.00, 5.25, 5.50, 5.75, 6.00, 6.25 sv, 0.01, 1.34, 1.37, 1.36, 1.31, 1.69, 1.27, 1.04, 0.76, 0.76 freq , 6.50, 6.75, 7.00, 7.25, 7.50, 7.75, 8.00, 8.50, 9.00 sv, 0.01, 0.69, 0.70, 0.74, 0.70, 0.67, 0.66, 0.61, 0.75, 0.60 freq , 9.50,10.00,10.50,11.00,11.50,12.00,12.50,13.00,13.50 sv, 0.01, 0.69, 0.61, 0.70, 0.59, 0.61, 0.56, 0.59, 0.59, 0.59 freq ,14.00,14.50,15.00,16.00,17.00,18.00,20.00,22.00,25.00 sv, 0.01, 0.58, 0.59, 0.58, 0.55, 0.56, 0.55, 0.55, 0.55, 0.54 freq ,28.00,31.00,34.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 sv, 0.01, 0.54, 0.54, 0.54, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 mmass,on,0.54 ! Missing mass with ZPA = 0.54 solve save fini /post1 /input,,mcom /com, ************************************* /com, Reaction forces obtained from Mechanical APDL /com, ************************************* *get,rf1_x,node,10001,rf,fx *get,rf1_y,node,20001,rf,fy *get,rf1_z,node,30001,rf,fz *get,rf4_x,node,10004,rf,fx *get,rf4_z,node,30004,rf,fz *get,rf7_y,node,20007,rf,fy *get,rf11_y,node,20011,rf,fy *get,rf11_z,node,30011,rf,fz *get,rf15_x,node,10015,rf,fx *get,rf17_y,node,20017,rf,fy *get,rf17_z,node,30017,rf,fz *get,rf36_y,node,20036,rf,fy *get,rf36_z,node,30036,rf,fz *get,rf38_x,node,10038,rf,fx *get,rf38_y,node,20038,rf,fy *get,rf38_z,node,30038,rf,fz *get,rf23_x,node,10023,rf,fx *get,rf23_y,node,20023,rf,fy *get,rf31_x,node,10031,rf,fx *get,rf31_y,node,20031,rf,fy *get,rf31_z,node,30031,rf,fz *dim,label,char,1,21 *dim,value,,21,3 label(1,1) = 'fx1' label(1,2) = 'fy1' label(1,3) = 'fz1' label(1,4) = 'fx4' label(1,5) = 'fz4' label(1,6) = 'fy7' label(1,7) = 'fy11' label(1,8) = 'fz11' label(1,9) = 'fx15' label(1,10) = 'fy17' label(1,11) = 'fz17' label(1,12) = 'fy36' label(1,13) = 'fz36' label(1,14) = 'fx38' label(1,15) = 'fy38' label(1,16) = 'fz38' label(1,17) = 'fx23' label(1,18) = 'fy23' label(1,19) = 'fx31' label(1,20) = 'fy31' label(1,21) = 'fz31' /com, ****************************************** /com, Reaction forces obtained from NRC /com, ****************************************** *vfill,value(1,1),data,43.71*1.10 *vfill,value(2,1),data,4.36*1.26 *vfill,value(3,1),data,1.60*4.74 *vfill,value(4,1),data,116.79*0.80 *vfill,value(5,1),data,20.01*3.77 *vfill,value(6,1),data,13.27*1.20 *vfill,value(7,1),data,13.31*1.48 *vfill,value(8,1),data,81.34*0.99 *vfill,value(9,1),data,731.47*0.60 *vfill,value(10,1),data,25.60*1.91 *vfill,value(11,1),data,65.36*1.22 *vfill,value(12,1),data,46.69*1.93 *vfill,value(13,1),data,42.12*2.02 *vfill,value(14,1),data,732.18*0.89 *vfill,value(15,1),data,43.44*1.21 *vfill,value(16,1),data,29.95*1.40 *vfill,value(17,1),data,259.59*1.02 *vfill,value(18,1),data,26.08*4.04 *vfill,value(19,1),data,55.05*0.92 *vfill,value(20,1),data,14.17*1.75 *vfill,value(21,1),data,16.08*1.97 *vfill,value(1,2),data,rf1_x *vfill,value(2,2),data,rf1_y *vfill,value(3,2),data,rf1_z *vfill,value(4,2),data,rf4_x *vfill,value(5,2),data,rf4_z *vfill,value(6,2),data,rf7_y *vfill,value(7,2),data,rf11_y *vfill,value(8,2),data,rf11_z *vfill,value(9,2),data,rf15_x *vfill,value(10,2),data,rf17_y *vfill,value(11,2),data,rf17_z *vfill,value(12,2),data,rf36_y *vfill,value(13,2),data,rf36_z *vfill,value(14,2),data,rf38_x *vfill,value(15,2),data,rf38_y *vfill,value(16,2),data,rf38_z *vfill,value(17,2),data,rf23_x *vfill,value(18,2),data,rf23_y *vfill,value(19,2),data,rf31_x *vfill,value(20,2),data,rf31_y *vfill,value(21,2),data,rf31_z *vfill,value(1,3),data,abs(rf1_x/(43.71*1.10)) *vfill,value(2,3),data,abs(rf1_y/(4.36*1.26)) *vfill,value(3,3),data,abs(rf1_z/(1.60*4.74)) *vfill,value(4,3),data,abs(rf4_x/(116.79*0.80)) *vfill,value(5,3),data,abs(rf4_z/(20.01*3.77)) *vfill,value(6,3),data,abs(rf7_y/(13.27*1.20)) *vfill,value(7,3),data,abs(rf11_y/(13.31*1.48)) *vfill,value(8,3),data,abs(rf11_z/(81.34*0.99)) *vfill,value(9,3),data,abs(rf15_x/(731.47*0.60)) *vfill,value(10,3),data,abs(rf17_y/(25.60*1.91)) *vfill,value(11,3),data,abs(rf17_z/(65.36*1.22)) *vfill,value(12,3),data,abs(rf36_y/(46.69*1.93)) *vfill,value(13,3),data,abs(rf36_z/(42.12*2.02)) *vfill,value(14,3),data,abs(rf38_x/(732.18*0.89)) *vfill,value(15,3),data,abs(rf38_y/(43.44*1.21)) *vfill,value(16,3),data,abs(rf38_z/(29.95*1.40)) *vfill,value(17,3),data,abs(rf23_x/(259.59*1.02)) *vfill,value(18,3),data,abs(rf23_y/(26.08*4.04)) *vfill,value(19,3),data,abs(rf31_x/(55.05*0.92)) *vfill,value(20,3),data,abs(rf31_y/(14.17*1.75)) *vfill,value(21,3),data,abs(rf31_z/(16.08*1.97)) save,table_2 finish resume,table_1 /com, /out,vm-nr6645-1-1a-a,vrt /com, /com, /com, ----------------------vm-nr6645-1-1a-a Results comparsion------------------------- /com, /com, /com, /com, | TARGET | Mechanical APDL | RATIO /com, /com, /com, ================================== /com, Frequencies from Modal analysis /com, ================================== *vwrite,label(1),freq_exp(1),freq_ans(1),freq_err(1) (1x,f3.0,4x,f10.4,4x,f10.4,4x,F5.3) /com, /com, /nopr, resume,table_2 /gopr /com, /com, /com, ============================================== /com, Reaction forces obtained from Spectrum solve /com, ============================================== /com, *vwrite,label(1,1),value(1,1),value(1,2),value(1,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,2),value(2,1),value(2,2),value(2,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,3),value(3,1),value(3,2),value(3,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,4),value(4,1),value(4,2),value(4,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,5),value(5,1),value(5,2),value(5,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,6),value(6,1),value(6,2),value(6,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,7),value(7,1),value(7,2),value(7,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,8),value(8,1),value(8,2),value(8,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,9),value(9,1),value(9,2),value(9,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,10),value(10,1),value(10,2),value(10,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,11),value(11,1),value(11,2),value(11,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,12),value(12,1),value(12,2),value(12,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,13),value(13,1),value(13,2),value(13,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,14),value(14,1),value(14,2),value(14,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,15),value(15,1),value(15,2),value(15,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,16),value(16,1),value(16,2),value(16,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,17),value(17,1),value(17,2),value(17,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,18),value(18,1),value(18,2),value(18,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,19),value(19,1),value(19,2),value(19,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,20),value(20,1),value(20,2),value(20,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) *vwrite,label(1,21),value(21,1),value(21,2),value(21,3) (1x,a8,' ',f10.4,' ',f10.4,' ',f5.3) /nopr, /com, /com, /com, --------------------------------------------------------------------------- /out, *list,vm-nr6645-1-1a-a,vrt finish