/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /verify,vm-nr6645-01-2a /title,vm-nr6645-01-2a,NRC Piping Benchmark Problems,Volume 1,Method 2 /com,**************************************************************************** /com, /com, Reference: Reevaluation of Regulatory Guidance /com, on modal response combination methods /com, for seismic response spectrum analysis /com, NUREG/CR-6645 /com, R.Morante, Y.Wang /com, December 1999. /com, /com, Description: /com, Response spectrum analysis on BM3 piping model using 14 modes + missing mass /com, /com, Lindley Yow rigid resonse calculation /com, /com, Elements used: PIPE289, ELBOW290, COMBIN14 /com, /com, Results : /com, The following results are outputted /com, 1. Frequencies obtained from modal solution. /com, 2. Maximum displacements and rotations obtained from spectrum solution /com, 3. Element forces and moments obtained from spectrum solution /com, 4. Reaction forces obtained from spectrum solution. SRSS, 1% damping /com, /com, /com,**************************************************************************** /out,scratch /prep7 youngmodulus = 2.9e+7 ! Young's modulus nu = 0.3 ! Poisson ratio shearmodulus = youngmodulus/(2*(1+nu)) ! Shear modulus et,1,pipe289,,,,2 sectype,1,pipe secdata,3.5,0.216,24 mp,ex,1,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,1,nu mp,gxy,1,shearmodulus mp,dens,1,1.043e-3 et,2,pipe289,,,,2 sectype,2,pipe secdata,4.5,0.237,24 mp,ex,2,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,2,nu mp,gxy,2,shearmodulus mp,dens,2,1.107e-03 et,3,pipe289,,,,2 sectype,3,pipe secdata,8.625,0.322,24 mp,ex,3,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,3,nu mp,gxy,3,shearmodulus mp,dens,3,1.253e-3 et,4,elbow290,,6 sectype,4,pipe secdata,3.5,0.216,24 mp,ex,4,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,4,nu mp,gxy,4,shearmodulus mp,dens,4,1.043e-3 et,5,elbow290,,6 sectype,5,pipe secdata,4.5,0.237,24 mp,ex,5,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,5,nu mp,gxy,5,shearmodulus mp,dens,5,1.107e-3 et,6,elbow290,,6 sectype,6,pipe secdata,8.625,0.322,24 mp,ex,6,youngmodulus ! Material properties mp,nuxy,6,nu mp,gxy,6,shearmodulus mp,dens,6,1.253e-3 et,7,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,7,2,1 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (UX DOF) r,7,1.0e+5 ! Spring constant et,8,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,8,2,2 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (UY DOF) r,8,1.0e+8 ! Spring constant et,9,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,9,2,3 ! Longitudinal spring damper element (Uz DOF) r,9,1.0e+11 ! Spring constant et,10,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,10,2,4 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTX DOF) r,10,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant et,11,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,11,2,5 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTY DOF) r,11,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant et,12,combin14 ! COMBIN14 spring-damper element keyopt,12,2,6 ! Torsional spring damper element (ROTZ DOF) r,12,1.0e+20 ! Spring constant /com, ******************** /com, Key points /com, ******************** k, 1, k, 2, 15.000, k, 3, 19.500, -4.500 k, 4, 19.500, -180.000 k, 5, 19.500, -199.500 k, 6, 19.500, -204.000, 4.500 k, 7, 19.500, -204.000, 139.500 k, 8, 24.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 9, 96.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 10, 254.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 11, 333.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 12, 411.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 13, 483.000, -204.000, 144.000 k, 14, 487.500, -204.000, 148.500 k, 15, 487.500, -204.000, 192.000 k, 16, 487.500, -204.000, 235.500 k, 17, 492.000, -204.000, 240.000 k, 18, 575.000, -204.000, 240.000 k, 19, 723.000, -204.000, 240.000 k, 20, 727.500, -208.500, 240.000 k, 21, 727.500, -264.000, 240.000 k, 22, 727.500, -264.000, 205.000 k, 23, 727.500, -264.000, 190.000 k, 24, 733.500, -264.000, 184.000 k, 25, 753.500, -264.000, 184.000 k, 26, 845.500, -264.000, 184.000 k, 27, 851.500, -264.000, 178.000 k, 28, 851.500, -264.000, 160.000 k, 29, 851.500, -264.000, 142.000 k, 30, 851.500, -270.000, 136.000 k, 31, 851.500, -360.000, 136.000 k, 32, 727.500, -264.000, 255.000 k, 33, 727.500, -264.000, 270.000 k, 34, 727.500, -264.000, 306.000 k, 35, 727.500, -264.000, 414.000 k, 36, 739.500, -264.000, 426.000 k, 37, 847.500, -264.000, 426.000 k, 38, 955.500, -264.000, 426.000 k,101,16.165,-0.15333,0 k,102,17.25,-0.60289,0 k,103,18.182,-1.318,0 k,104,18.897,-2.25,0 k,105,19.347,-3.3353,0 k,501,19.5,-200.66,0.15333 k,502,19.5,-201.75,0.60289 k,503,19.5,-202.68,1.318 k,504,19.5,-203.4,2.25 k,505,19.5,-203.85,3.3353 k,701,19.653,-204,140.66 k,702,20.103,-204,141.75 k,703,20.818,-204,142.68 k,704,21.75,-204,143.4 k,705,22.835,-204,143.85 k,131,484.16,-204,144.15 k,132,485.25,-204,144.6 k,133,486.18,-204,145.32 k,134,486.9,-204,146.25 k,135,487.35,-204,147.34 k,161,487.65,-204,236.66 k,162,488.1,-204,237.75 k,163,488.82,-204,238.68 k,164,489.75,-204,239.4 k,165,490.84,-204,239.85 k,191,724.16,-204.15,240 k,192,725.25,-204.6,240 k,193,726.18,-205.32,240 k,194,726.9,-206.25,240 k,195,727.35,-207.34,240 k,231,727.7,-264,188.45 k,232,728.3,-264,187 k,233,729.26,-264,185.76 k,234,730.5,-264,184.8 k,235,731.95,-264,184.2 k,261,847.05,-264,183.8 k,262,848.5,-264,183.2 k,263,849.74,-264,182.24 k,264,850.7,-264,181 k,265,851.3,-264,179.55 k,291,851.5,-264.204,140.4471 k,292,851.5,-264.804,139 k,293,851.5,-265.757,137.7574 k,294,851.5,-267,136.8038 k,295,851.5,-268.447,136.2044 k,351,727.91,-264,417.11 k,352,729.11,-264,420 k,353,731.01,-264,422.49 k,354,733.5,-264,424.39 k,355,736.39,-264,425.59 /com, ************************* /com, Straight pipe elements /com, ************************* type,1 secnum,1 mat,1 l, 1, 2 ! line number 1 l, 3, 4 l, 4, 5 l, 6, 7 l, 8, 9 l, 9,10 l,10,11 l,11,12 l,12,13 l,14,15 l,15,16 l,17,18 l,18,19 l,20,21 ! line number 14 lsel,s,line,,1,14,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all type,2 secnum,2 mat,2 l,21,22 ! line number 15 l,22,23 l,24,25 l,25,26 l,27,28 l,28,29 l,30,31 ! line number 21 lsel,s,line,,15,21,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all type,3 secnum,3 mat,3 l,21,32 ! line number 22 l,32,33 l,33,34 l,34,35 l,36,37 l,37,38 ! line number 27 lsel,s,line,,22,27,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all /com, ******************** /com, Curved pipe elements /com, ********************* type,4 secnum,1 mat,4 larc,2,102,101 ! line number 28 larc,102,104,103 larc,104,3,105 larc,5,502,501 larc,502,504,503 larc,504,6,505 larc,7,702,701 larc,702,704,703 larc,704,8,705 larc,13,132,131 larc,132,134,133 larc,134,14,135 larc,16,162,161 larc,162,164,163 larc,164,17,165 larc,19,192,191 larc,192,194,193 larc,194,20,195 ! line number 45 lsel,s,line,,28,45,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all type,5 secnum,2 mat,5 larc,23,232,231 ! line number 46 larc,232,234,233 larc,234,24,235 larc,26,262,261 larc,262,264,263 larc,264,27,265 larc,29,292,291 larc,292,294,293 larc,294,30,295 ! line number 54 lsel,s,line,,46,54,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all type,6 secnum,3 mat,6 larc,35,352,351 ! line number 55 larc,352,354,353 larc,354,36,355 ! line number 57 lsel,s,line,,55,57,1 lesize,all,,,4 lmesh,all allsel,all /com, *************************** /com, nodes for elastic support /com, **************************** dist = 50.0 ! Visualization n,10001, -dist n,20001, , dist n,30001, , , -dist n,10004, 19.500+dist, -180.000 n,30004, 19.500 , -180.000 , -dist n,20007, 19.500 , -204.000+dist, 139.500 n,20011, 333.000 , -204.000+dist, 144.000 n,30011, 333.000 , -204.000 , 144.000-dist n,10015, 487.500-dist, -204.000 , 192.000 n,20017, 492.000 , -204.000-dist, 240.000 n,30017, 492.000 , -204.000 , 240.000-dist n,10023, 727.500-dist, -264.000 , 190.000 n,20023, 727.500 , -264.000+dist, 190.000 n,10031, 851.500+dist, -360.000 , 136.000 n,20031, 851.500 , -360.000-dist, 136.000 n,30031, 851.500 , -360.000 , 136.000-dist n,20036, 739.500 , -264.000-dist, 426.000 n,30036, 739.500 , -264.000 , 426.000-dist n,10038, 955.500+dist, -264.000 , 426.000 n,20038, 955.500 , -264.000-dist, 426.000 n,30038, 955.500 , -264.000 , 426.000-dist /com, **************************** /com, Elastic supports and anchors /com, **************************** type,7 real,8 e, node(19.5,-180.00,0),10004 real,7 e,node(487.50,-204.00,192.00),10015 e,node(727.50,-264.00,190.00),10023 real,9 e, node(0,0,0),10001 e,node(851.50,-360.00,136.00),10031 e,node(955.50,-264.00,426.00),10038 type,8 real,8 e, node(19.50,-204.00,139.50),20007 e,node(333.00,-204.00,144.00),20011 e,node(492.00,-204.00,240.00),20017 e,node(727.50,-264.00,190.00),20023 e,node(739.50,-264.00,426.00),20036 real,9 e, node(0,0,0),20001 e,node(851.50,-360.00,136.00),20031 e,node(955.500,-264.000,426.000),20038 type,9 real,8 e, node(19.50,-180.00,0),30004 real,7 e,node(333.00,-204.00,144.00),30011 e,node(492.00,-204.00,240.00),30017 e,node(739.500,-264.00,426.00),30036 real,9 e, node(0,0,0),30001 e,node(851.500,-360.00,136.00),30031 e,node(955.500,-264.000,426.000),30038 type,10 real,10 e, node(0,0,0),10001 e,node(851.500,-360.000,136.000),10031 e,node(955.500,-264.000,426.000),10038 type,11 real,10 e, node(0,0,0),20001 e,node(851.500,-360.000,136.000),20031 e,node(955.500,-264.000,426.000),20038 type,12 real,10 e, node(0,0,0),30001 e,node(851.50,-360.00,136.00),30031 e,node(955.50,-264.00,426.00),30038 allsel,all /com, ************************************************************ /com, Converting some PIPE289 into ELBOW290 using ELBOW command /com, near the pipe bends /com, ************************************************************ elbow,on,,,sect allsel,all /com, *************** /com, Constraints /com, *************** nsel,s,node,,10000,40000 d,all,all,0 allsel,all fini /com, **************** /com, Modal analysis /com, **************** /solu antype,modal modopt,lanb,14 lumpm,on mxpand,14,,,yes solve fini /post1 /out, /com, ****************************************** /com, Frequencies obtained from modal solution /com, ****************************************** set,list finish /com, ********************** /com, Spectrum analysis /com, ********************** /out,scratch /solu antype,spectrum spopt,sprs,, ! Single point response spectrum solve svtype,2,386.4 ! Seismic acceleration response srss,0.001,disp ! SRSS mode combination, displacement solution sed,1,0,0 ! Excitation in X direction freq , 0.20, 0.30, 0.40, 0.50, 0.60, 0.70, 0.80, 0.90, 1.00 sv, 0.01, 0.06, 0.13, 0.13, 0.20, 0.35, 0.39, 0.37, 0.41, 0.76 freq , 1.10, 1.20, 1.30, 1.40, 1.50, 1.60, 1.70, 1.80, 1.90 sv, 0.01, 0.64, 0.59, 0.91, 1.03, 1.46, 0.95, 0.91, 1.61, 1.92 freq , 2.00, 2.10, 2.20, 2.30, 2.40, 2.50, 2.60, 2.70, 2.80 sv, 0.01, 1.57, 1.18, 2.65, 2.85, 3.26, 4.47, 4.75, 5.29, 7.44 freq , 2.90, 3.00, 3.15, 3.30, 3.45, 3.60, 3.80, 4.00, 4.20 sv, 0.01, 4.27, 4.61, 4.13, 3.96, 4.05, 2.44, 2.09, 2.29, 1.52 freq , 4.40, 4.60, 4.80, 5.00, 5.25, 5.50, 5.75, 6.00, 6.25 sv, 0.01, 1.34, 1.37, 1.36, 1.31, 1.69, 1.27, 1.04, 0.76, 0.76 freq , 6.50, 6.75, 7.00, 7.25, 7.50, 7.75, 8.00, 8.50, 9.00 sv, 0.01, 0.69, 0.70, 0.74, 0.70, 0.67, 0.66, 0.61, 0.75, 0.60 freq , 9.50,10.00,10.50,11.00,11.50,12.00,12.50,13.00,13.50 sv, 0.01, 0.69, 0.61, 0.70, 0.59, 0.61, 0.56, 0.59, 0.59, 0.59 freq ,14.00,14.50,15.00,16.00,17.00,18.00,20.00,22.00,25.00 sv, 0.01, 0.58, 0.59, 0.58, 0.55, 0.56, 0.55, 0.55, 0.55, 0.54 freq ,28.00,31.00,34.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 sv, 0.01, 0.54, 0.54, 0.54, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00, 0.00 mmass,on,0.54 ! Missing mass with ZPA = 0.54 rigresp,on,lindley,0.54 ! Rigid response using Lindley approach solve save fini /post1 /input,,mcom /out, /com, /com,=============================================================== /com, Maximum nodal displacements and rotations from spectrum solution /com,=============================================================== /com, /out,scratch *GET,AdisX,NODE,274,U,X *GET,AdisY,NODE,105,U,Y *GET,AdisZ,NODE,50,U,Z *GET,ArotX,NODE,78,ROT,X *GET,ArotY,NODE,81,ROT,Y *GET,ArotZ,NODE,113,ROT,Z /out, *stat,AdisX *stat,AdisY *stat,AdisZ *stat,ArotX *stat,ArotY *stat,ArotZ /com,============================================================== /com, Element Forces and Moments obtained from spectrum solution /com,============================================================== /out,scratch /com,========== /com, Node I /com,========== /com, Element #1 (Pipe289 element) /com,************************ esel,s,elem,,1 etable,pxi_1,smisc,1 etable,vyi_1,smisc,6 etable,vzi_1,smisc,5 etable,txi_1,smisc,4 etable,myi_1,smisc,2 etable,mzi_1,smisc,3 esel,all /out, /com, ************************************************ /com, Element forces and moments at element1, node i /com, ************************************************ pretab,pxi_1,vyi_1,vzi_1,txi_1,myi_1,mzi_1 /out,scratch /com,========== /com, Node J /com,========== /com, Element #1 (Pipe289 element) /com,************************ esel,s,elem,,1 etable,pxj_1,smisc,14 etable,vyj_1,smisc,19 etable,vzj_1,smisc,18 etable,txj_1,smisc,17 etable,myj_1,smisc,15 etable,mzj_1,smisc,16 esel,all /out, /com, ********************************************** /com, Element forces and moments at element1, node j /com, ************************************************ pretab,pxj_1,vyj_1,vzj_1,txj_1,myj_1,mzj_1 /out,scratch /com,========== /com, Node I /com,========== /com, Element #28 (Elbow 290 element) /com,************************* esel,s,elem,,28 etable,pxi_28,smisc,1 etable,vyi_28,smisc,6 etable,vzi_28,smisc,5 etable,txi_28,smisc,4 etable,myi_28,smisc,2 etable,mzi_28,smisc,3 esel,all /out, /com, ************************************************* /com, Element forces and moments at element 28, node i /com, ************************************************ pretab,pxi_28,vyi_28,vzi_28,txi_28,myi_28,mzi_28 /out,scratch /com,========== /com, Node J /com,========== /com, Element #28 (Elbow290 element) /com,******************************** esel,s,elem,,28 etable,pxj_28,smisc,36 etable,vyj_28,smisc,41 etable,vzj_28,smisc,40 etable,txj_28,smisc,39 etable,myj_28,smisc,37 etable,mzj_28,smisc,38 esel,all allsel,all /out, /com, ********************************************** /com, Element forces and moments at element 28, node j /com, ************************************************ pretab,pxj_28,vyj_28,vzj_28,txj_28,myj_28,mzj_28 /com,---------------------------------------------------------------------------- /com, *************************************** /com, Reaction forces from spectrum solution /com, **************************************** prrsol finish