/COM,ANSYS MEDIA REL. 182 (07/10/2017) REF. VERIF. MANUAL: REL. 182 /VERIFY,VMR029-T5-185 /TITLE,VMR029-T5-185, LARGE DEFLECTION OF A CURVED ELASTIC CANTILEVER UNDER TRANSVERSE END LOAD /COM,REFERENCE NAFEMS 3D BEAMS AND SHELLS MANUAL TEST 3DNLG-5 /PREP7 W=1.0 H=1.0 R=100 THETA=45 F=3000.0 ET,1,185 KEYOPT,1,2,2 MP,EX,1,1E7 MP,NUXY,1,0.3 K,1,0,-H/2,-W/2 K,2,0,-H/2,W/2 K,3,0,H/2,W/2 K,4,0,H/2,-W/2 K,5,0,0,R K,6,0,1,R A,1,2,3,4 VROTAT,ALL, , , , , ,5,6,-45, , LESIZE,ALL,,,1 LESIZE,9,,,16 LESIZE,10,,,16 LESIZE,11,,,16 LESIZE,12,,,16 VMESH,ALL NSEL,S,LOC,X,0 D,ALL,ALL NSEL,S,LOC,Z,28.5,30 F,ALL,FY,750 ALLSEL,ALL ESEL,S,,,1 ESEL,A,,,4 ESEL,A,,,16 CM,ELESOL,ELEM ALLSEL,ALL FINISH /SOLVE NLGEOM,ON AUTOTS,ON NSUBST,100,100000,10 OUTRES,ALL,ALL /OUT,SCRATCH SOLVE FINISH /SHOW,,jpeg /POST26 *DIM,XUX,TABLE,11,1 *DIM,YUX,TABLE,11,1 XUX(1,1)= 0 YUX(1,1)= 0 XUX(2,1)= 300 YUX(2,1)= -7.14 XUX(3,1)= 600 YUX(3,1)= -13.68 XUX(4,1)= 900 YUX(4,1)= -18 XUX(5,1)= 1200 YUX(5,1)= -20.5 XUX(6,1)= 1500 YUX(6,1)= -21.5 XUX(7,1)= 1800 YUX(7,1)= -22.8 XUX(8,1)= 2100 YUX(8,1)= -23.7 XUX(9,1)= 2400 YUX(9,1)= -24.4 XUX(10,1)= 2700 YUX(10,1)= -24.6 XUX(11,1)= 3000 YUX(11,1)= -25 /XRANGE,0,3000 /YRANGE,-60,90 /AXLAB,X,LOAD /AXLAB,Y,TIP DISPLACEMENT /COLOR,CURVE,YGRE /GCOLUMN,1,' X_REF' *VPLOT,XUX(1,1),YUX(1,1) /OUT, /NOERASE NSOL,2,3,U,Z,UX PROD,7,1, , ,LOAD, , ,3000.0,0,0, /COLOR,CURVE,MRED XVAR,7 PLVAR,2 /NOERASE *DIM,XUY,TABLE,11,1 *DIM,YUY,TABLE,11,1 XUY(1,1)= 0 YUY(1,1)= 0 XUY(2,1)= 300 YUY(2,1)= -12.18 XUY(3,1)= 600 YUY(3,1)= -23.87 XUY(4,1)= 900 YUY(4,1)= -30 XUY(5,1)= 1200 YUY(5,1)= -33.5 XUY(6,1)= 1500 YUY(6,1)= -38 XUY(7,1)= 1800 YUY(7,1)= -40 XUY(8,1)= 2100 YUY(8,1)= -42.5 XUY(9,1)= 2400 YUY(9,1)= -44 XUY(10,1)= 2700 YUY(10,1)= -45 XUY(11,1)= 3000 YUY(11,1)= -47.31 /COLOR,CURVE,YGRE /GCOLUMN,1,' Y_REF' *VPLOT,XUY(1,1),YUY(1,1) /NOERASE NSOL,3,3,U,X,UY /COLOR,CURVE,MRED XVAR,7 PLVAR,3 /NOERASE *DIM,XUZ,TABLE,11,1 *DIM,YUZ,TABLE,11,1 XUZ(1,1)= 0 YUZ(1,1)= 0 XUZ(2,1)= 300 YUZ(2,1)= 40.53 XUZ(3,1)= 600 YUZ(3,1)= 53.71 XUZ(4,1)= 900 YUZ(4,1)= 60 XUZ(5,1)= 1200 YUZ(5,1)= 62 XUZ(6,1)= 1500 YUZ(6,1)= 63 XUZ(7,1)= 1800 YUZ(7,1)= 64.5 XUZ(8,1)= 2100 YUZ(8,1)= 65.5 XUZ(9,1)= 2400 YUZ(9,1)= 66 XUZ(10,1)= 2700 YUZ(10,1)= 67 XUZ(11,1)= 3000 YUZ(11,1)= 68.09 /COLOR,CURVE,YGRE /GCOLUMN,1,' Z_REF' *VPLOT,XUZ(1,1),YUZ(1,1) /NOERASE NSOL,4,3,U,Y,UZ /COLOR,CURVE,MRED XVAR,7 PLVAR,4 FINISH /POST1 SET,,,1,,0.1,, *GET,UX_300,NODE,3,U,Z *GET,UY_300,NODE,3,U,X *GET,UZ_300,NODE,3,U,Y SET,,,1,,0.15,, *GET,UX_450,NODE,3,U,Z *GET,UY_450,NODE,3,U,X *GET,UZ_450,NODE,3,U,Y SET,,,1,,0.2,, *GET,UX_600,NODE,3,U,Z *GET,UY_600,NODE,3,U,X *GET,UZ_600,NODE,3,U,Y SET,,,1,,1.0,, *GET,UX_3000,NODE,3,U,Z *GET,UY_3000,NODE,3,U,X *GET,UZ_3000,NODE,3,U,Y *DIM,LABEL1,CHAR,1,4 LABEL1(1,1) = ' 300' LABEL1(1,2) = ' 450' LABEL1(1,3) = ' 600' LABEL1(1,4) = '3000' *DIM,VALUE1,CHAR,1,4 VALUE1(1,1) = '-7.14' VALUE1(1,2) = '-10.86' VALUE1(1,3) = '-13.68' VALUE1(1,4) = '-24.97' *DIM,VALUE2,CHAR,1,4 VALUE2(1,1) = '-6.98' VALUE2(1,2) = '-10.70' VALUE2(1,3) = '-13.51' VALUE2(1,4) = '-25.00' *DIM,ERROR1,,1,4 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,1),DATA,UX_300 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,2),DATA,UX_450 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,3),DATA,UX_600 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,4),DATA,UX_3000 /COM, ************************* NOTE **************************** /COM, /COM, THE GLOBAL CS OF THIS MODEL DOES NOT MATCH THE CS OF NAFEMS /COM, TEST. HERE IS THE CORRESPODANCE: /COM, NAFEMS Mechanical APDL /COM, X >>> Z /COM, Y >>> X /COM, Z >>> Y /COM, /COM, ------------- TIP DISPLACEMENT: UX -------------- /COM, /COM, | NAFEMS TEST | Mechanical APDL | /COM, | LOAD | REF. | NUM.RES. | SOL.185 | /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,1),VALUE1(1,1),VALUE2(1,1),ERROR1(1,1) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,2),VALUE1(1,2),VALUE2(1,2),ERROR1(1,2) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,3),VALUE1(1,3),VALUE2(1,3),ERROR1(1,3) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,4),VALUE1(1,4),VALUE2(1,4),ERROR1(1,4) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) /COM, /COM, ----------------------------------------------------- /OUT,SCRATCH VALUE1(1,1) = '-12.18' VALUE1(1,2) = '-18.78' VALUE1(1,3) = '-23.87' VALUE1(1,4) = '-47.31' VALUE2(1,1) = '-11.91' VALUE2(1,2) = '-18.45' VALUE2(1,3) = '-23.54' VALUE2(1,4) = '-47.70' *VFILL,ERROR1(1,1),DATA,UY_300 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,2),DATA,UY_450 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,3),DATA,UY_600 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,4),DATA,UY_3000 /OUT /COM, ------------- TIP DISPLACEMENT: UY -------------- /COM, /COM, | NAFEMS TEST | Mechanical APDL | /COM, | LOAD | REF. | NUM.RES. | SOL.185 | /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,1),VALUE1(1,1),VALUE2(1,1),ERROR1(1,1) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,2),VALUE1(1,2),VALUE2(1,2),ERROR1(1,2) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,3),VALUE1(1,3),VALUE2(1,3),ERROR1(1,3) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,4),VALUE1(1,4),VALUE2(1,4),ERROR1(1,4) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A6,' ',A6,' ',F8.4) /COM, /COM, ----------------------------------------------------- /OUT,SCRATCH VALUE1(1,1) = '40.53' VALUE1(1,2) = '48.79' VALUE1(1,3) = '53.71' VALUE1(1,4) = '68.09' VALUE2(1,1) = '40.15' VALUE2(1,2) = '48.48' VALUE2(1,3) = '53.47' VALUE2(1,4) = '68.56' *VFILL,ERROR1(1,1),DATA,UZ_300 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,2),DATA,UZ_450 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,3),DATA,UZ_600 *VFILL,ERROR1(1,4),DATA,UZ_3000 /OUT /COM, ------------- TIP DISPLACEMENT: UZ -------------- /COM, /COM, | NAFEMS TEST | Mechanical APDL | /COM, | LOAD | REF. | NUM.RES. | SOL.185 | /COM, *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,1),VALUE1(1,1),VALUE2(1,1),ERROR1(1,1) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A5,' ',A5,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,2),VALUE1(1,2),VALUE2(1,2),ERROR1(1,2) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A5,' ',A5,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,3),VALUE1(1,3),VALUE2(1,3),ERROR1(1,3) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A5,' ',A5,' ',F8.4) *VWRITE,LABEL1(1,4),VALUE1(1,4),VALUE2(1,4),ERROR1(1,4) (1X,' ',A4,' ',A5,' ',A5,' ',F8.4) /COM, /COM, ----------------------------------------------------- ESEL,,,,ELESOL NSLE ESEL,ALL PRNSOL,S,COMP PRNSOL,EPTO,COMP FINISH /POST1 /COM, !WARNING! /COM, Mechanical APDL RESULTS GIVEN IN DIFFERENT CS THAN /COM, NAFEMS MANUAL, CS RESULTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AS: /COM, X >>> Z /COM, Y >>> X /COM, Z >>> Y SET,1,23 *GET,UX1,NODE,52,U,Z *GET,UY1,NODE,52,U,X *GET,UZ1,NODE,52,U,Y *GET,APLOAD,TIME RX=ABS(UX1/24.97) RY=ABS(UY1/47.31) RZ=ABS(UZ1/68.09) *DIM,VALUE,,3,2 *DIM,LABEL2,CHAR,3 *DIM,LABEL3,CHAR,3 *DIM,LABEL,CHAR,3 LABEL2(1) = 'UX','UY','UZ' LABEL(1) = 'vmr029-','vmr029-','vmr029-' LABEL3(1) = 't5-185','t5-185','t5-185' *VFILL,VALUE(1,1),DATA,ABS(UX1),ABS(UY1),ABS(UZ1) *VFILL,VALUE(1,2),DATA,RX,RY,RZ /OUT,vmr029-t5-185,vrt /COM /COM,-------------- VMR029-T5 RESULTS COMPARISON --------------- /COM, /COM, | Mechanical APDL | RATIO | INPUT | /COM, /COM,SOLID185 *VWRITE,LABEL2(1),VALUE(1,1),VALUE(1,2),LABEL(1),LABEL3(1) (1X,' ',A2,' ',F12.4,' ',F13.4,' ',A7,A8) /COM, /COM,---------------------------------------------------------------- /OUT FINISH *LIST,vmr029-t5-185,vrt