Graphs can be either Frequency Response graphs that display how the response varies with frequency or Phase Response plots that show how much a response lags behind the applied loads over a phase period.
You can scope graphical results using:
Geometry selection (vertex, face, edge, or nodes)
Support Boundary Conditions (Fixed Support, Displacement, Frictionless Support, Cylindrical Support)
You can view these options as a value graphed along a specified frequency range. These include the frequency results for stress, elastic strain, deformation, velocity, acceleration (frequency only), and force reaction plotted as a graph. In addition, you can parameterize these frequency results. The plot will include all the frequency points at which a solution was obtained. When you generate frequency response results, the default plot (Bode) shows the amplitude and phase angle.
Note: Direct graphical node selection requires you to generate the mesh and have the Select Mesh (see Graphics Options Toolbar Help) tool chosen.
The following equations describe how frequency graphs are defined and plotted.
The strain result is calculated using the displacement result. Using the Young’s Modulus and strain result, the stress result can be evaluated. Because of this reason, the stress and strain results are in phase with the displacement result.
The displacement vector on a structure subjected to harmonic loading may be expressed as:
EQUATION 1
The Frequency Response chart for Displacement is calculated by expressing Equation (1) in time domain as follows:
EQUATION 2
where:
The equation for velocity can be obtained by taking a time
derivative of Equation (1). The frequency response
for velocity in time domain is calculated as
follows:
EQUATION 3
where:
The equation for acceleration can be obtained by taking a double
time derivative of Equation (1). The frequency
response for acceleration in time domain is
calculated as follows:
EQUATION 4
where:
The Frequency Response for Force Reaction is calculated by replacing displacement with force in Equation (2) as shown below.
EQUATION 5
where:
(Amplitude)
(Phase Angle)
Optionally, the Display property provides the following results values for graphs:
(default setting - plots both Amplitude and Phase Angle)
The Chart Viewing Style property provides the following options to plot results for a scale of an axis:
: this option plots the result values linearly.
: this option plots the X-Axis logarithmically. If negative axis values or a zero value exists, this option is not supported and the graph plots linearly.
(default when graph has Amplitude): this option plots the Y-Axis is plotted logarithmically. If negative axis values or a zero value exists, this option is not supported and the graph plots linearly.
: this option plots the X-Axis and Y-Axis logarithmically. If negative axis values or a zero value exists, this option is not supported and the graph plots linearly.
For edges, faces, surface bodies, and multiple vertex selections (which contain multiple nodes), the results can be scoped as minimum, maximum, or average using the Spatial Resolution option. This option is also available for frequency and phase response results scoped on a single vertex.
Note: The Spatial Resolution option is especially important for results scoped to a shell vertex, where the default option, , may yield unexpected results.
The and settings of the Spatial Resolution option are based on the amplitude and thus are reported from the location with either the largest or smallest amplitude. The setting calculates the average by calculating the real and imaginary components separately.
Note: You cannot use the Mechanical application convergence capabilities for any results item under a harmonic analysis. Instead, you can first do a convergence study on a modal analysis and reuse the mesh from that analysis.
Presented below is an example of a Frequency Response plot:

The average, minimum, or maximum value can be chosen for selected entities. Stress, Strain, Deformation, Velocity, and Acceleration components vary sinusoidally, so these are the only result types that can be reviewed in this manner. (Note that items such as Principal Stress or Equivalent Stress do not behave in a sinusoidal manner since these are derived quantities.)
Similarly, Phase Response plots show the minimum, average, or maximum Stress, Strain, or Deformation for selected graphical entities (vertex, face, edge, or nodes) or a Named Selection. An example of a Phase Response plot is illustrated below.

However, unlike Frequency Response plots that show a response amplitude over a frequency range, Phase Response plots show a response over a phase period, so you can determine how much a response lags behind the applied load.
The following functions outline the relationships of response amplitude, phase response graphs, and result contours (with associated caveats):
Response Amplitude is defined as the maximum value of the following expression:
value = sqrt(real*real +
imag*imag)
|
Where real and imag represent all real and imaginary result values from the result file for the selected frequency.
The graph is the image of the following function, where Sweeping Phase is allowed to vary across a user specified Duration:
value = AMPLITUDE *
sin(phase)
|
Note: Take caution when comparing the values in the Output column of the Tabular Data for a Phase Response against maximum values of contour displays.
Drawing contour displays in a Harmonic Response analysis, Mechanical uses the phase specified by the Sweeping Phase property defined by the user to evaluate the expression:
value = real*cos(phase) -
imag*sin(phase)
|
Where real and imag represent all real and imaginary result values from the result file for the selected frequency.
Because the formula for the Phase Response graph differs from the formula for the contour, an Output value for the graph does not necessarily equal a maximum for a contour result at the same frequency.
General Approach to Harmonic Response Analysis Postprocessing
Generally speaking, you would look at Frequency Response plots at critical regions to ascertain what the frequency of interest may be. In conjunction with Phase Response plots, the phase of interest is also determined. Then, you can request Stress, Strain, or Deformation contour plots to evaluate the response of the entire structure at that frequency and phase of interest.
You can use Frequency Response result types (not including Velocity and Acceleration) to generate new result objects of the same type, orientation, frequency. The phase angle of the contour result will be opposite in sign with the same magnitude as the frequency response result type. The sign of the phase in the Sweeping Phase property of the contour result is reversed so that the response amplitude of the frequency response plot for that frequency and phase defined by the Duration property matches with the contour results. To create a Contour Result in a Harmonic Analysis:
Select and right-click the desired Harmonic result in the solution tree.
Choose .
As illustrated here, you can see how the feature automatically scopes the Type, Orientation, Coordinate System, Frequency, and Sweeping Phase.
The Reported Frequency in the Information category is the frequency at which contour results were found and plotted. This frequency can be potentially different from the frequency you requested.
For a Mode Superposition Harmonic Response Analysis (standalone and linked MSUP), if the Store Results At All Frequencies property in the Options category of the Analysis Settings is set to , the Frequency Response and Phase Response results can be scoped to geometric entities only (node-based scoping is not allowed).
If the Store Results At All Frequencies property in the Options category of the Analysis Settings is set to , the Frequency Response results for force reactions cannot be extracted.