Averaged vs. Unaveraged Contour Results

Normally, contour results in the Mechanical application are displayed as averaged results. Some results can also display as unaveraged contours. Averaged contours distribute the average elemental nodal results across element and geometric discontinuities. A user option exists that allows you to control whether results are also averaged across body boundaries that contain a conformal mesh. The default setting does not calculate an average across bodies.

Using the Mechanical APDL application terminology, unaveraged contour results display as element nodal contours that vary discontinuously even across element boundaries. These contours are determined by linear interpolation within each element and are unaffected by surrounding elements (that is, no nodal averaging is performed). The discontinuity between contours of adjacent elements is an indication of the gradient across elements.

Results that include the unaveraged contour display option are most elemental quantities such as stress or strain. This option is not available for degree of freedom results such as displacements.

Nodal averaging of element quantities involves direct averaging of values at corner nodes. For higher-order elements, midside node results are then taken as the average of the corner nodes.

There are two distinct techniques for calculating averaged nodal results. The calculation for the first technique is as follows:

  1. Average the component (X, Y, Z, XY, YZ, XZ) stress values from the elements at a common node.

  2. Calculate the equivalent stresses from the averaged component values

The calculation for the second technique is as follows:

  1. Calculate the equivalent stress values (from the six component strains) on a per element basis.

  2. Average these values from the elements at a common node.

For equivalent stress, stress/strain intensity, max shear stress/strain, and principal stresses/strains, the first technique is used to calculate the results. For equivalent strains, which are calculated by the Mechanical APDL solver, the second technique is used. For random vibration analysis, equivalent stresses are calculated by the Mechanical APDL solver using the Segalman method, so the second technique is also used.


Note:  If an elemental result is scoped to a surface body, then there may be two sets of results at each node (Top and Bottom) and sometimes a third set of results (Middle). At release 12.0, if the solver writes Middle results to the result file, then Mechanical displays these results if the Shell Face setting in the Details view equals Middle (Membrane). If the solver did not write Middle results to the result file, then Mechanical displays the average of Top and Bottom if the Shell Face setting in the Details View is Middle (Membrane). For a given node on the shell, the application will average Top results, separately average Bottom results, and separately average Middle results. When you export a result in the application that is set to Top/Bottom, you may note that a node number is repeated in the Excel file. This is because both the Top and Bottom stresses are listed.

Beginning at Release 16.0, Mechanical supports the Top/Bottom/Middle positions for layered solid bodies. Therefore, layered solid elements mimic expanded shell elements, which display as having a thickness between the Top face and Bottom face.


You can display contour results by setting the Display Option field to one of the following:

Characteristics of unaveraged contour displays:

Average Across Bodies

When you select Averaged as the Display Option, the Average Across Bodies property displays in the Integration Point Results category. Setting this property to Yes (the default value is No) allows you to averages the results across separate bodies on your model. This post-processing feature is supported for most averaged element nodal contour results (like stress, strain, and thermal flux).

If a node belongs to two different bodies, its averaged stress value of one of the bodies is typically different from the stress value of the other body. Using the Average Across Bodies feature, the average value at this node is the sum of all of the stress values from all “scoped” elements that contain the node (divided by the number of elements). The feature graphically renders a smoother result contour at the interfaces of bodies. If bodies do not share any nodes, then the feature has no effect.

Calculation Conditions

Note the following conditions and characteristics for calculating averages across bodies:

Support Limitations

The following results features are not supported:

Averaging Element Nodal Results

For most element nodal results (like stresses and strains), the Mechanical solvers write only the unaveraged corner node values to the result file. No element nodal results are written for mid-side nodes. This difference is of critical importance.

To derive the value at a mid-side node, the Mechanical post processor must employ the values at the corner nodes. There are three distinct techniques for this process:

  1. For line elements, such as unexpanded beam and pipe stress, Mechanical calculates the average of the unaveraged values of those corner nodes which share an edge with the mid-side node - corner nodes, node I and node J. See Case 1 below.

  2. For solid elements (i.e. shell, hexahedron, tetrahedron, wedge, and pyramid elements), the technique calculates the mid-side node results from the averaged corner nodes. See Case 2 below.

  3. For contact elements, the technique calculates the mid-side node results by averaging the un-averaged values of adjacent corner nodes. Note: A result max may be at a mid-side node. See Case 3 below.

Corner Node Calculation Case 1

Consider the following example consisting solely of high order line elements, where:

If:

The unaveraged solution is then:

For the averaged solution of nodes 2 and 3:

Note that the value at the mid-side node 23 (90) exceeds the values at the end points.

Corner Node Calculation Case 2

Result averaging for solids: mid-side node results are the average of the averaged corner node values.

Raw Data Averaged Corner Nodes

Mid-Side Nodes Calculated from Averaged Corner Nodes

Corner Node Calculation Case 3

Result averaging for contacts: calculate the final mid-side node results by averaging intermediate mid-side values.

Raw Data Averaged Corner Nodes

Mid-Side Nodes Calculated from Averaged Corner Nodes


Note:  Result maximum in this case may be at a mid-side node.



Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.