VMMECH072

VMMECH072
Thermal Stresses in a Long Cylinder

Overview

Reference:S. Timoshenko, Strength of Material, Part II, Elementary Theory and Problems, 3rd Edition, D. Van Nostrand Co, Inc., New York, NY, 1956, pg. 234, problem 1.
Solver(s):
ANSYS AIM
ANSYS Mechanical
Analysis Type(s):Thermal Stress Analysis
Element Type(s):2-D Thermal Solid Elements

Test Case

A long thick-walled cylinder is maintained at a temperature Ti on the inner surface and To on the outer surface. Determine the temperature distribution through the wall thickness. Also determine the axial stress σa and the tangential (hoop) stress σt at the inner and outer surfaces Edge sizing is used for all edges and edge behavior is defined as hard.

Figure 167:  Schematic

Schematic

Material PropertiesGeometric PropertiesLoading
E = 30 x 106 psi
α = 1.435 x 10-5/°F
ν = 0.3
k = 8.333 x 10-4 Btu/s-in-°F
a = 0.1875 in
b = 0.625 in
Ti = -1 °F
To = 0 °F

Analysis Assumptions and Modeling Notes for ANSYS Mechanical

Because of the symmetry in loading conditions and in the geometry, this problem is solved as an axisymmetric problem in ANSYS Mechanical. The axial length is arbitrary and it is taken has 0.1 in. Nodal coupling is used in the static stress analysis. Model is used for the thermal and stress solutions.

Figure 168:  Schematic in ANSYS Mechanical

Schematic in ANSYS Mechanical

Analysis Assumptions and Modeling Notes for ANSYS AIM

The following figure shows the finite element model in ANSYS AIM:

Figure 169:  Schematic in ANSYS AIM

Schematic in ANSYS AIM

Results Comparison for ANSYS Mechanical

Thermal AnalysisTargetMechanicalError (%)
T,°F (at X = 0.1875 in)-1-10
T,°F (at X = 0.2788 in)-0.67037-0.670540.025
T,°F (at X = 0.625 in)000
Static AnalysisTargetMechanicalError (%)
Stressa, psi (at X = 0.1875 in)420.42415.47 -1.177
Stresst, psi (at X = 0.1875 in)420.42404.97-3.674
Stressa, psi (at X = 0.625 in)-194.58-195.010.221
Stresst, psi (at X = 0.625 in)-194.58-194.990.211

Results Comparison for ANSYS AIM

Thermal AnalysisTargetAIMError (%)
T, °F (at X = 0.1875 in)-1-10
T, °F (at X = 0.625 in)000
Static AnalysisTargetAIMError (%)
Stressa, psi (at X = 0.1875 in)420.42414.78-1.342
Stresst, psi (at X = 0.1875 in)420.42400.22-4.805
Stressa, psi (at X = 0.625 in)-194.58-195.10.267
Stresst, psi (at X = 0.625 in)-194.58-195.020.226

Release 18.2 - © ANSYS, Inc. All rights reserved.